Should I Kill My Cichlids And Catfish? (Please Read)

Should They Be Killed Or Should I Let Them Live And See What Happens?


  • Total voters
    10
what :huh: so you have no feet?no wheels or change for a bus ride, wow take your attitude it stinks

I Live In A Small Suburb There Are No Buses No Taxis And The Shop I Bought The Fish From Must Be 75 Miles Away. It Takes Like Half An Hour To Drive There.
Next Time Think Before Your Ignorant.
 
ps forgot.....WithAllTheCapitalLettersAtTheBegginingOfEachWordMakesItHardToRead....Thats how it looks to me so no couldnt be bothered to read everything...Were here to help,so either except help or walk away

my lord feels like the kids kicked out of school early
troll-0.jpg
 
ps forgot.....WithAllTheCapitalLettersAtTheBegginingOfEachWordMakesItHardToRead....Thats how it looks to me so no couldnt be bothered to read everything...Were here to help,so either except help or walk away

Well Youre Not Helping Let Alone Making An Effort To Help. And Im Not Going To Get In An Online Argurement With You So Yeah.
 
if you have absolutely NO way of getting to the fishstore, then your option is to do lots of waterchanges. and big ones. cut back feeding to everyother day. make sure your water is "conditioned" with water dechlorinator. most of the folks here have been given terrible advice at one time or other. you are no different. shame on that lady! but you have a reasonable responsibility to keep these fish alive (as you were prepared to do when you got them). so lots of hard work ahead of you in the way of water changing.
have a read about cycling. you are in a fish IN cycle. waterchanges are an absolute necessity for their overall health.
sorry for all the rudeness. generally not so around here, particularly with noobies, BUT mentioning euthanizing your (realistically healthy, if not in bad water conditions) fish to folks who care deeply about their fishy friends is just not a good way to start things off im afraid.
i know you are frustrated, but the majority of people here are here to HELP you...not to be harsh. learn from your mistakes (of listening to the fish store BEFORE doing your own research). i hope this has a good outcome for you and the fish.
good luck
cheers
 
Just seems a lot of threads lately titled, shall i kill my fish :blink:

Can you not take them back to the fish shop? if no go to the shop,ask for some mature filter media and seed your filter,

where are you located within the world?


so this isnt helping?????

mature filter media will mature you filter in a few days not weeks n months....asking local fish shop for this usually works..

where are you located<means where do you live, as we have so many people round the world someone could give you some

media...but no, obviously from that i wasnt helping, so you thought being rude to me would work :huh:
 
Pipedream I don't see how your post helped the problem at hand at all. He is a young kid just starting off and I gurantee most of us started off in very similar situations I know I did. So please if your not going to try to help then don't post. Now fwfishlover back to the topic at hand. If you can't get you dad grandma aunt cousin friends parents anyone that has a car to take you to the petstore then give them away. I would get on craigslist and post free in big letters and the fish you have. You really need that test kit but until you get it you need to be doing big water changes like 50 to 75 percent aleast once a day. What you really need to do is consetrate on finding a ride to return the fish those tow fish in the bowl with no filter won't last long.
 
Pipedream I don't see how your post helped the problem at hand at all. He is a young kid just starting off and I gurantee most of us started off in very similar situations I know I did. So please if your not going to try to help then don't post. Now fwfishlover back to the topic at hand. If you can't get you dad grandma aunt cousin friends parents anyone that has a car to take you to the petstore then give them away. I would get on craigslist and post free in big letters and the fish you have. You really need that test kit but until you get it you need to be doing big water changes like 50 to 75 percent aleast once a day. What you really need to do is consetrate on finding a ride to return the fish those tow fish in the bowl with no filter won't last long.

Thanks For The Advice :nod: Definitely Some Good Advice.
 
what :huh: so you have no feet?no wheels or change for a bus ride, wow take your attitude it stinks

I Live In A Small Suburb There Are No Buses No Taxis And The Shop I Bought The Fish From Must Be 75 Miles Away. It Takes Like Half An Hour To Drive There.
Next Time Think Before Your Ignorant.
Settle down now no need to give nelly an attitude hes just trying to help. You say 75 miles to the shop and it takes 30min your flying try about an hour and ten mins or so..Its kind of hard to believe the nearest place that sells fish to you is 75 miles away. You don't have to take them back to the same place go to a petstore that has fish and see if they'll take them
 
My god - some people on here.

Pipe Dream - I've read your past posts, pretty much all of them are just immature snipes at various newbies. Why even bother coming on here? Insulting people on the internet in a feeble attempt to look superior. How old are you?

FWFishlover - first of all, PLEASE DON'T REPLY TO THIS WithAllTheCapitalLettersAtTheBegginingOfEachWordMakesItHardToRead - and think about what you type (extreely annoyingly) before you decide to insult Nelly, one of the most respected members on this forum. Like Nelly says, except help or walk away.
Reading some of your previous posts, you've obviously researched livebearers thoroughly and your tank would have been fine if you'd cycled it, which you haven't read by the looks of things - but everyone makes mistakes. To be honest I'd point out to your dad that he was the one who suggested cichlids - play the guilt card, see if he'll take one. If not, ask around neighbours to see if they have tanks, but make sure they're suitable before giving them away.
BTW that bowl will need 100% daily water changes of preferably 2 75% changes a day.
 
i agree plenty of water change's also what type of decor do you have usually lot's of plant's and hiding place's will help with agression in fish. I personally have kept a large catfish with an angel fish and mollies before but don't have any experience with many other cichlid's.Read a few thread's on cichlid's on here it might give you some idea's on how to kerb the aggression.
 
Hello,

Firstly, about style, then I'll get to your particular dilemma. Yes, using capital letters in their traditional places matters. As does using a spell check if for some reason you aren't confident about the quality of your written English. Why? Because there's a relationship between how a question is asked and the quality of the reply you'll get. Writing proper English is the single best way there is to show respect when communicating via text. It says to the reader that you care about them, and that you want to make your writing as clear as possible so that there's little scope for misunderstanding. Writing in text speak or making up your own grammar and spellings sends the opposite message. It says to the reader that you don't care about them, and that you're a selfish person who abides by your own standards and not those of society around you. The end result will be fewer people will bother to reply, and those that will may be more hostile or critical than otherwise.

Anyway, as for your situation. Of course you do not need to kill your fish. Indeed, you shouldn't even consider doing so unless you understand how to euthanise fish humanely. Flushing them down the loo or sticking them in the freezer aren't humane, and even putting aside any bad karma you'll accumulate by doing this, treating animal deaths casually is a slippery slope that can lead to bad character traits more generally. As others have suggested, you can announce your "yard sale" of fish on this bulletin board or elsewhere, and hopefully folks will be able to help you out. Alternatively, call the pet store, explain the situation, and return the fish as soon as practical. In the very short term, daily water changes of 25% should avoid any fatalities, but this isn't a long-term solution.

Now, was this situation the retailer's fault? Yes and no. Yes, retailers should be obliged to provide good information. But they are, after all, retailers, and even the best can't know everything about every species of fish they sell. You wouldn't buy a car from a retailer based on his or her recommendation, and you wouldn't buy clothes based on the opinion of the retailer rather than your own. Personal judgement is always a part of any retail transaction. In this situation, by all means go shopping for fish, but either research some good species beforehand, so you can pick up the exact fish you want, or else buy (or borrow) a good aquarium fish encyclopaedia, and use that while you're shopping to check the basic facts such as size, temperament, water chemistry requirements and so on. For some reason teenagers today are terrified of books, but trust me, books are our friends, and they are remarkably easy to use. Simply open the covers, turn to the index, look up the species you see in the tank before you, and read the words of wisdom provided. If the facts presented mean the fish should work in your aquarium, then you can buy the fish with confidence. If the facts suggest problems, then you can avoid disappointment and unwanted expense by leaving the fish in the pet store. What could be simpler? Once you get the hang of reading books, you'll wonder how you lived without them. (Yes, I am being sarcastic here, and I'd like to think you read books anyway, but my point stands: an aquarium book is your friend while shopping.)

What you've done is learned a lesson most of us experienced hobbyists have learned at some point: ignorance is expensive. There's a reason we read, why we go to school, why we get college degrees. The more you know, the better your life becomes. This applies to everything from keeping pets through to getting a job. Spend more time reading about your fish, and then when the time comes to go shopping, you'll be able to craft a great collection of pet fish ideally suited to the tank you have.

Cheers, Neale

Oh, and PS. The pet store can't be 75 miles away. If it takes 30 minutes to get there, and it's 75 miles away, then you must be travelling at 150 miles per hour, which seems unlikely.

I Live In A Small Suburb There Are No Buses No Taxis And The Shop I Bought The Fish From Must Be 75 Miles Away. It Takes Like Half An Hour To Drive There.
Next Time Think Before Your Ignorant.
 
People Nelly Was Being Rude To Me! I Dont Care Whether He's One Of The Most Respected Members Or A Newbie He Shouldnt Have Been Being Rude For No Reason. Read It Again And You Should See Him Being Rude First And The Aggressor
 
People Nelly Was Being Rude To Me! I Dont Care Whether He's One Of The Most Respected Members Or A Newbie He Shouldnt Have Been Being Rude For No Reason. Read It Again And You Should See Him Being Rude First And The Aggressor
That's not what I saw! He simply missed the part were you said you couldn't drive probaly because of the way you wrote it. Your response to him not seeing that part wass what was rude. So please show some respect the the elders of this forum or go else were
 
Just seems a lot of threads lately titled, shall i kill my fish :blink:

Can you not take them back to the fish shop? if no go to the shop,ask for some mature filter media and seed your filter,

where are you located within the world?
i don't see anyhing wrong with this,nelly is giving you advice,I don't know why you took offence to this post but I can assure you that none of us meen you any offence (well maybe pipe dream :rolleyes: )
 

Most reactions

Back
Top