Hi Jesse, I suspect none of the members have tackled your question with comments because there are so very many things it could possibly be (not to mention that it's the holiday and everyone has scattered here and there, lol!)
You may very well have a ciclid specific problem that I'm not really qualified to answer but I'll just throw in (in case it's needed) that anytime you see your fish appearing to be more pale, but not just as a temporary result of fear, it's good of course to be sure your water stats are all up to normal.
You want to take a check with your liquid kit and be sure that ammonia and nitrite(NO2) are both rock solid zero ppm and that your nitrate(NO3) levels have not drifted upward away from the normal range you should have tallied in your aquarium log in your notebook. Are you having any problems in that area?
~~waterdrop~~