If you go near direct line, expect them to try and shaft you for your money, they only honour new customers, not old. Was Direct Line for a fair few years and instead of getting a bit cheaper each year, the cost kept going up, when i rang them to find out why all i got was "well as a new customer... you get a larger discount" etc... and when i asked what they did for customers when 4/5 people in a family all insure with them and parents have done for 20 odd years between them... they just said 'err.. nothing... you just become a regular paying customer'.
I told them they could consider me a customer all the liked but i sure as heck wasnt going to be a paying one. Admiral quoted me £200 less after i had been with Direct Line for 4 years!
Admiral screwed me over, didnt bother notifying me of changes to my policy, were horrendous to deal with after an accident and took soooo long to sort anything and kept losing my information and messing around with charges.
I now insure with Ford Insure for my 1.2 Fiesta and 1 years no claims is £600 and thats paying monthly! Would have been about £500.
So changing from Admiral to Ford Insure and splitting up with my Ex and moving from Luton to Reading outskirts, my car insurance dropped by £500!! Woman on the phone nearly choked trying not to laugh when i told her Id have left my Ex a lot sooner if i had realised how much money it would save me!