This thread will probably make it obvious just how much more of a SW person I am than a FW one. I can grow corals out my ears and used to have tons of fw tanks too in my much earlier years, but all those were loaded with snails of various species, so I have essentially never had to even think about FW algae even once in around 30 years of aquarium-keeping...until now. Because this tank doesn't have snails LOL.
I've been battling alternating species of algae blooms in a tank set up a few months ago where I'm primarily growing Azolla. The Azolla is my main goal with the tank - I'm treating it like a crop that I harvest. The algae situation though is to the point where I'm considering algaecide to ensure the Azolla survives the winter (since I won't be able to get more for around 6 months if I lose it). I would LOVE a better solution though, but none of the things I know to try have done what they were supposed to do.
Tank size: 10gal
What's in the tank:
- Azolla over 50-75% of the surface (I harvest some occasionally). I have never kept Azolla before - this is my first time trying it.
- A bit of java fern
- A single male betta (I thought I'd give one of those poor boys in a cup a better time)
- Air driven Sponge filter
Params are 0/0/0 on nitrogen forms. The pH is around 7.5. I don't have a fw phosphate kit on hand right now and for stupid reasons they are very difficult to get where I am (yes, even mail-order), so I'm not likely to have one any time soon - but I'm going to guess phosphate is zeroed out as well because of the Azolla mass. I am getting alternating green filamentous and very soft whispy brown filamentous algae. I also have constant green algae coming in on the glass, although I expect that. I remove one and the other comes in. I have tried reducing photo period - that reduced the green filamentous and brought in the brown whispy stuff in a scary fast way. I have tried reducing light intensity - that goes back the other way and I get the green filaments coming back, but I can't do that for too long because the Azolla starts to struggle before the algae gives up.
Water changes are sparse with there being no real need to remove nutrients and trying to avoid disturbing the Azolla except when I harvest it every few weeks. All new water going in is RODI with a remineralizer so there is no tap-water-based source of ammonia or any other nutrient that would be feeding the algae.
Normally I would just go get something like Amano shrimp to knock back the filamentous stuff biologically. I like biological solutions and don't like trying to solve things with a bottle when I can avoid it, especially a bottle that kills something. Unfortunately, I am likely going to have to wait several months until I can get any FW inverts, and I'm worried the filamentous algaes will choke out the Azolla's roots between now and then. The only place near me is a big box store, and honestly I don't trust what's in their FW tanks. I have a FW bowl with some Planorbids that could deal with the algae (even though they certainly would) because I'm feeding the Azolla I harvest to chickens and there are various reasons I don't want snails in that mix - so I don't want to just dump in some Planorbids and then struggle getting rid of them later or make the Azolla unsuitable for use with the chickens due to being full of snails.
So...any advice for this situation other than turning to algaecide would be much appreciated. Worst case I suppose I could set up a heated tub to split off some Azolla and algaecide *that* and keep it going the winter on liquid fertilizers to avoid algaeciding the tank itself.
I've been battling alternating species of algae blooms in a tank set up a few months ago where I'm primarily growing Azolla. The Azolla is my main goal with the tank - I'm treating it like a crop that I harvest. The algae situation though is to the point where I'm considering algaecide to ensure the Azolla survives the winter (since I won't be able to get more for around 6 months if I lose it). I would LOVE a better solution though, but none of the things I know to try have done what they were supposed to do.
Tank size: 10gal
What's in the tank:
- Azolla over 50-75% of the surface (I harvest some occasionally). I have never kept Azolla before - this is my first time trying it.
- A bit of java fern
- A single male betta (I thought I'd give one of those poor boys in a cup a better time)
- Air driven Sponge filter
Params are 0/0/0 on nitrogen forms. The pH is around 7.5. I don't have a fw phosphate kit on hand right now and for stupid reasons they are very difficult to get where I am (yes, even mail-order), so I'm not likely to have one any time soon - but I'm going to guess phosphate is zeroed out as well because of the Azolla mass. I am getting alternating green filamentous and very soft whispy brown filamentous algae. I also have constant green algae coming in on the glass, although I expect that. I remove one and the other comes in. I have tried reducing photo period - that reduced the green filamentous and brought in the brown whispy stuff in a scary fast way. I have tried reducing light intensity - that goes back the other way and I get the green filaments coming back, but I can't do that for too long because the Azolla starts to struggle before the algae gives up.
Water changes are sparse with there being no real need to remove nutrients and trying to avoid disturbing the Azolla except when I harvest it every few weeks. All new water going in is RODI with a remineralizer so there is no tap-water-based source of ammonia or any other nutrient that would be feeding the algae.
Normally I would just go get something like Amano shrimp to knock back the filamentous stuff biologically. I like biological solutions and don't like trying to solve things with a bottle when I can avoid it, especially a bottle that kills something. Unfortunately, I am likely going to have to wait several months until I can get any FW inverts, and I'm worried the filamentous algaes will choke out the Azolla's roots between now and then. The only place near me is a big box store, and honestly I don't trust what's in their FW tanks. I have a FW bowl with some Planorbids that could deal with the algae (even though they certainly would) because I'm feeding the Azolla I harvest to chickens and there are various reasons I don't want snails in that mix - so I don't want to just dump in some Planorbids and then struggle getting rid of them later or make the Azolla unsuitable for use with the chickens due to being full of snails.
So...any advice for this situation other than turning to algaecide would be much appreciated. Worst case I suppose I could set up a heated tub to split off some Azolla and algaecide *that* and keep it going the winter on liquid fertilizers to avoid algaeciding the tank itself.
Last edited:







