why did my mollies die

laboul said:
PS. Many people say mollies are hardy but I have had two die on me and they were from Petsmart too. I wouldn't get any more just yet.

Just read Raechal's post while I was writing this, very good advice. I'd definitely return the larger fish and you may even want to consider upgrading your ten gallon to a 20 or 30 gallon eventually. Once your tank stabilizes you're going to have baby fish from those platies!
http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showforum=39 gourami

http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showforum=40 tetra

http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showforum=37 platy

http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?showforum=43 barbs

You can read those pages and figure out what kind of gouramis, tetras, and barbs you have. Then you can read about them and learn how big they get and what their needs are.
 
laboul said:
Hi there - just to let you know, the Petsmart in my area (Canada) does free water testing, just bring in a little baggie of water. Hopefully they do this in Illinois too.

It would be smart to ask them what the actual values for nitrite, nitrate, ammonia, and pH are. Sometimes they will tell you your water is fine without showing you the values... because they just want you to buy more fish.

Your values should be:
ammonia: 0
nitrite: 0
nitrate: below 40
pH: between 6 and 8

Values higher than 0 in ammonia and nitrite indicate that your tank is not cycled yet. Sorry if I'm repeating things that have already been said.

Test kits are good if you can afford one eventually because changes in a small tank can be more drastic. Also, the liquid based test kits are more accurate than the strip tests, or so I've heard.

I'd say 2 platies and 1 algae eater are enough for that tank, even overstocked. :sick: You'll need to find another home for the angelfish and gourami. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news. The general rule is one inch in length of fish per gallon. That means with 2 platies at an adult length of at least 2 inches you'll be overstocked in a 3 gallon.

Don't feel too bad about not knowing this stuff beforehand. It's not like Petsmart tells you how to properly take care of fish. I started there too and my tank was a disaster: I killed 2 fish and a snail from ammonia poisoning and disease. :X I've learned so much on this forum in just a month and you will too! :D

Good luck!
Thanks so much for the infor , I am going to get a test kit if i ever get off this pc
My angel is in the 10 gallon tank w/th e platy and gourami.
 
Raechal said:
dolphinonj said:
Raechal said:
Well if you decide to get anymore fish I would maybe go with a betta. Do you like those?

EDIT: Nevermind, I didn't read that you had fish in the 3 gallon still.

What kind of tetras and what kind of barbs? When your molly died did it have any injuries, marks or anything unusual about it?

You have a 10 gallon as well, what fish do you have in there? To speed up your cycling process, maybe you could go to the local fish store or pet store and ask for some of their gravel as that will contain some good bacteria and help your tank along.
Love bettas have 2 of them thats what started me on this finding nemo journey, my friends are calling me a fish wh...
did know you could do that, wow ! i should have done some research before all this .
In my 10 gallon i have 2 gourami a angelfish 4 platy and 1 algea eater .... to much?
The angelfish will have to get either a larger tank or get sent back to the local fish store. It will get way too tall for the 10 gallon and it's fins will probably stick out of the water. :no:

What kind of gourami do you have? What do they look like? You may be able to keep two in there if they aren't two males. They may get a little territorial and attack each other. You can tell a male from a female by their dorsal fins. The fin on their back. The female will have a shorter more rounded dorsal fin and the male will have a more longer pointed one.

4 platies is fine as well but beware they will breed very easily and give you lots of baby fish! :wub:

What kind of algae eater is it? A common sucker fish? Is it brown with brown kind of spots on it? These can get longer than a foot when they are their adult size! I would take him back as well with the angel. Then you could probably add the tetras and the barbs you have in the 10 gallon and get a betta for the 3 gallon. Normally tetras should be in schools of atleast 5, but since you don't have room I guess it would be better to keep the only 2 you have.
i have a chinese alge eater. i think i have two male gourami and my angel fish is a small a one it said (not the fish ha ha) that it will get about 6 inches
I have a common placo that i just found out yesterday will get about 18 inches and he's in the smaller tank right now. the girl at petco (where i now go) said that i will have to get a bigger tank or find a home for him .
i had gotten the tertas to go with my one betta, they said at petsmart that tetras and betta get along, but i found out that just because they say they get along doesnt mean they always will. Boris (thats my bettas name ) was not having it , so i put him back in the 1 gallon tank.
 
dolphinonj said:
Raechal said:
dolphinonj said:
Raechal said:
Well if you decide to get anymore fish I would maybe go with a betta. Do you like those?

EDIT: Nevermind, I didn't read that you had fish in the 3 gallon still.

What kind of tetras and what kind of barbs? When your molly died did it have any injuries, marks or anything unusual about it?

You have a 10 gallon as well, what fish do you have in there? To speed up your cycling process, maybe you could go to the local fish store or pet store and ask for some of their gravel as that will contain some good bacteria and help your tank along.
Love bettas have 2 of them thats what started me on this finding nemo journey, my friends are calling me a fish wh...
did know you could do that, wow ! i should have done some research before all this .
In my 10 gallon i have 2 gourami a angelfish 4 platy and 1 algea eater .... to much?
The angelfish will have to get either a larger tank or get sent back to the local fish store. It will get way too tall for the 10 gallon and it's fins will probably stick out of the water. :no:

What kind of gourami do you have? What do they look like? You may be able to keep two in there if they aren't two males. They may get a little territorial and attack each other. You can tell a male from a female by their dorsal fins. The fin on their back. The female will have a shorter more rounded dorsal fin and the male will have a more longer pointed one.

4 platies is fine as well but beware they will breed very easily and give you lots of baby fish! :wub:

What kind of algae eater is it? A common sucker fish? Is it brown with brown kind of spots on it? These can get longer than a foot when they are their adult size! I would take him back as well with the angel. Then you could probably add the tetras and the barbs you have in the 10 gallon and get a betta for the 3 gallon. Normally tetras should be in schools of atleast 5, but since you don't have room I guess it would be better to keep the only 2 you have.
i have a chinese alge eater. i think i have two male gourami and my angel fish is a small a one it said (not the fish ha ha) that it will get about 6 inches
I have a common placo that i just found out yesterday will get about 18 inches and he's in the smaller tank right now. the girl at petco (where i now go) said that i will have to get a bigger tank or find a home for him .
i had gotten the tertas to go with my one betta, they said at petsmart that tetras and betta get along, but i found out that just because they say they get along doesnt mean they always will. Boris (thats my bettas name ) was not having it , so i put him back in the 1 gallon tank.
Did you find out what type of gouramis you have? What do they look like?
 
Well you're lucky those stay fairly small at 1.5-2 inches each. If you have any problems with aggression maybe you could split them up and put one of the 2 powder blue gouramis in the 3 gallon. :nod: I think he might be fine in there. This is what i would keep in the 10 gallon:

2 powder blue gouramis
4 platies
1 chinese algae eater

With good filtration and weekly water changes I am sure you could pull that off. More idealy I would get rid of two platies and only keep two.

Then you should get rid of 2 platies and your angelfish along with the common plec. Then you'd have an extra 3 gallon to either save just incase your gouramis start acting up or if you keep a male and female platy you can keep the 3 gallon for when the male and female have babies! :wub:
 

Most reactions

Back
Top