Water Change Dechlorination Help

Chloramine is simply a more stable form of chlorine, when it comes to the impact on fish.
I do not know the specific mechanism that we used to kill all those fish. It may have been a gill damage situation or something else. I only vividly remember the resulting fish deaths. Until you have seen several hundred pounds of fish destroyed by a small dose, in relative terms, of chlorine, you really don't understand how lethal the stuff is.
 
I have to admit I do actually love chlorine gas, I saw it once during my A levels in chemistry and to visually see a pure element such as chlorine in gas form is actually quite impressive. I'm usually in awe by such simple and basic building blocks of life.
 
The dirt cheapest way to dechlorinate is mixing your own dechlorinator using sodium thiosulfate. The only problem is with chloramine, it will leave you with ammonia, which can cause problems depending on the amount of water changed, level of disinfectant, and capabilities of the nitrifying bacteria in your filter.

I'll bet chlorine does do a real number on marine fish. They are from what I understand quite a bit more sensitive to environmental changes than most freshwater fish. While I have never done a marine setup, I do know that you shouldn't start with tap water, even if it is dechlorinated, and changes in temperature that would be fairly routine in a fresh water setup would be bad news in a marine tank.

Many old school fishkeepers still don't use dechlorinator, don't do more than 25% water changes, despite the fact that the water they think contains chlorine also contains chloramine now. They do a good job breeding & keeping fish, thinking the chlorine is just gassing out, and a bit of disinfecting is good for the health of their fish. Trying to teach them the science behind it is akin to trying to teach my dogs to read, they know what works in their setup, and aren't too concerned why.

While this works for seasoned veterans who remember when hob filters were a newfangled gadget, it is in no way the best starting point for a new aquarist. This is why from the beginning dechlorinating water is advised, water testing, along with many other things that add up to making starting out less problematic. Most everything concerning aquatics is guidelines, there are few carved in stone rules. Once you understand why these guidelines are suggested you can start to stray outside of them, hopefully with a solid backup plan in place.
 
Interesting discussion, have enjoyed reading it. One thing I'd like to repeat for Joshua is that the advice from Hovanec that led us to settle in on 1.5x (to 2x max) was specifically aimed at the "still maturing aquarium," the tank that's heading towards 6 months or 1 year in other words. Its my feeling that as a biofilter gets out around a year, its going to be quite robust and doing things that are aimed at optimizing bacterial growth are no longer very relevant. The 2x plus dose of conditioner is just something that slows bacterial growth, specifically N-Bac growth if I remember correctly, not something that is a bother to mature colonies. So something like a short 5x overdose once a filter is mature would be unnoticed by the colonies in my opinion and would be just fine if one were just trying to deal with some other perceived chlorine overdose problem or wanted some of the other qualities of the conditioner.

~~waterdrop~~
 

Most reactions

Back
Top