What's new

Tank Cycled, I Need To Stock Up

The link I gave was not to the thread I thought. I just did a cursory search. Certainly, you can seek out a better one if you choose.


Green neons are not as inbreed and "sensitive" as the traditional neon tetras (red and blue).


And while I agree that algae is easy to grow, normally during a fishless cycle, the lights are kept off the entire time, and then the tank is emptied before adding fish, so those nutrients that have been building up for the algae to use to grow, are actually long gone by the time the fish are added.


This is just my sense of things. Certainly opinions differ. My thoughts on a more conservative approach is what I would do. Of course, I'd rather not lay out big bucks for all my fish at one time and then get smacked by something unexpected. There my not be a lot of "hard" science regarding the sensitive fish issue (there is very limited science available regarding the trade in general). But, there are lots of anecdotes of certain fish, including regular neons, dying for seemingly no reason with zero ammonia or nitrite the whole time. There are also the instances of neon tetra disease which seems to creep up out of nowhere for folks. I believe that many times this is the result of the immaturity of the tank. I'd rather lean on the side of caution. I think slowly raising the stocking of the tank is always a better method than just banging all the fish in at once. While its true that the bacteria will die back slightly because of the smaller bioload. The colony also bounces back stronger when needed and you can monitor new additions as needed and add the most aggressive/territorial fish last.


Those are my two cents. It won't buy a whole lot anymore, but it might still be worth something. :/
 
The link I gave was not to the thread I thought. I just did a cursory search. Certainly, you can seek out a better one if you choose.


Green neons are not as inbreed and "sensitive" as the traditional neon tetras (red and blue).


And while I agree that algae is easy to grow, normally during a fishless cycle, the lights are kept off the entire time, and then the tank is emptied before adding fish, so those nutrients that have been building up for the algae to use to grow, are actually long gone by the time the fish are added.


This is just my sense of things. Certainly opinions differ. My thoughts on a more conservative approach is what I would do. Of course, I'd rather not lay out big bucks for all my fish at one time and then get smacked by something unexpected. There my not be a lot of "hard" science regarding the sensitive fish issue (there is very limited science available regarding the trade in general). But, there are lots of anecdotes of certain fish, including regular neons, dying for seemingly no reason with zero ammonia or nitrite the whole time. There are also the instances of neon tetra disease which seems to creep up out of nowhere for folks. I believe that many times this is the result of the immaturity of the tank. I'd rather lean on the side of caution. I think slowly raising the stocking of the tank is always a better method than just banging all the fish in at once. While its true that the bacteria will die back slightly because of the smaller bioload. The colony also bounces back stronger when needed and you can monitor new additions as needed and add the most aggressive/territorial fish last.


Those are my two cents. It won't buy a whole lot anymore, but it might still be worth something. :/

IMO both methods make sense

I certainly agree on the difference between Green Neons and Blue/Red Neons.

And I do agree with the slow additions but I do think its worth adding a reasonable amount of fish after the fishless cycle.

And 2 cents is always worth somewhat - this thread now has a collective value of 4 cents :D

Wills
 
And I do agree with the slow additions but I do think its worth adding a reasonable amount of fish after the fishless cycle.

And 2 cents is always worth somewhat - this thread now has a collective value of 4 cents :D

Wills


There's just too much agreement here, because I agree regarding the "reasonable" amount of fish suggestion. If you scroll back up, you'll see that I recommended adding the shoal of rummys, barbs/tetras and cories. That would be quite a "reasonable" amount of stocking for that tank and wouldn't have much die back. The filter would easily be able to handle the addition of the remainder of the fish all in one go, if the OP wanted to go that way.


4 cents! :yahoo: Now we got a party!
 
thanks for all the advice guys, very helpful.

Now i havent done my water change yet. Am i pushing it, if i do the water change this morning i.e. now and add fish later today, or is it recommended to wait a day before adding the fish?
 
That's probably fine. Just test it for nitrates after the wc.


What are you adding?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top