Definately get the Fuji, they're made by Nikon so you know they'll be good quality. And the camera just has so much more to offer!
I'll post side by side comparisons where I feel it really counts!
1. Max-min shutter speed Kodak= 1/1700 second-8 seconds
Fuji= 1/200 second-15 seconds
Basically withe the Fuji you have all the range of the Kodak and then a bit on both ends of the shutter speed range! you will have better luck catching action with a faster shutter speed and better results in low light with the slower speed!
2. ISO sensitivity Range Kodak=80-400 (with 800 available but you have to lower your resolution to a pathetic 1.8 mp.
Fuji=64-1600
ISO will help your shutter speed range be even more versatile, basically the higher the ISO the better it will perform in lower light conditions. (There's more to it than that but this is essentially the basic idea) You can use a slower shutter speed in low light with a higher ISO so you will have more options for you picture taking style to develop.
3. As was stated above the Fuji can manually focus while the Kodak can't. The min focusing distance for macro is much less on the Fuji as well.
4. Exposure compensation is almost the same in both cameras but it just a bit more adjustable in the Fuji.
5. The Fuji is listed to be RAW capable as well as JPEG, the Kodak doesn't say which means it probably isn't RAW, probably just JPEG. RAW files are larger and require more processing usually but the results are much better.
There are many more advantages to having the Fuji, but I think you get the idea. You'll have much much more camera with the Fuji so get that one!
SLC