Red CaribSea Eco-Complete substrate question

Firestorm_1976

New Member
Joined
Dec 6, 2023
Messages
43
Reaction score
3
Location
Gilbert, AZ 85297
Yesterday, I put together a new 29 gallon aquarium. The idea was to plant it in such a way that it would require minimal trimming due to most plants being non-stem plants (samolus parviflorus red, and a few types of crypts, so heavy root feeders). Only some stem plants toward the back, and some bacopa (which is a very easy straight-forward trimming) throughout. For the first time tried a new substrate combo: about 2.5-3" of Red CaribSea Eco-Complete topped with about 1-1.5" of pool filter sand. How good is red eco-complete? I did put some Osmocote Plus and muriate of potash on the very bottom (under the substrate), but was hoping that Eco-Complete (especially topped with sand, which would allow to keep nutrients from leaching into the water) would provide a good substrate for the heavy room feeders long-term. Yet, now I am reading that Eco-Complete is near-inert in terms of plants' abilities to use the nutrients??
 

Attachments

  • 10-23-2025, Day 1, picture 1.jpg
    10-23-2025, Day 1, picture 1.jpg
    366.6 KB · Views: 80
Sorry I'm late, but I'm new to the forum and haven't had time to butt in on everyone's posts yet.:) And by now you've probably already figured it out.

Anyway take this with a grain of salt, since I myself am a known and notorious plant murderer, but I think eco-complete is ideal. Reason being, it's just basalt, or lava rock. Yes it's inert but all those little nooks and crannies do a great job retaining nutrients while simultaneously allowing water/oxygen flow. Back in the UGF days it was the thing, although it wasn't marketed as a "plant" substrate. The aqua soil guys will poo poo this, but what do they know, with their award-winning tanks and all that. Showoffs. They just like to play in the mud, like a certain other mammal that tastes great on a sammich.
Shove a few root tabs down there and in 10 years laugh at the poor sods having to replace their nutrient-deficient dirt and complaining loudly about the mess the whole time.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top