Most Active Tropical Fish

[Athena]

...and all those incompatible tankmates held within a two and half foot tank? Really?? And you still want to add more to the pot?

Or is this a little wind-up?

If it's true then I can only suggest you (i) rehome the sharks (I note the plural there, so you obviously have more than 1 which is a definite no-no anyway - and any of the shark family are not suited to that size tank with other tankmates as they are territorial and will chase and bully other fish - if they're not doing it right now, they will when they mature); (ii) rehome the convict (same as for the shark, they are territorial and will chase/bully etc and the tank is a bit small for their fully grown adult size); and (iii) that will leave you with the Betta...

There aren't that many fish you can choose to house with a Betta. So, unless you want a fairly empty tank with just a betta and maybe some Ottocinclus, or cories, you might want to rehome the betta and start completely afresh. If you're unsure about fish compatibility, ask on here before you buy anything.

 

[Dieses Madchen]

tanks two and a half ft

PRobably a bit small for Danio then. You'd probably be ok with a group of male guppies, they're pretty active. But post up the info that Fluttermoth asked you for, and you'll get much better advice.

I agree with you there. My fancy guppies (males and females) are absolutely bonkers! Very entertaining to watch. My swordtails are very active too.

...and all those incompatible tankmates held within a two and half foot tank? Really?? And you still want to add more to the pot?

Or is this a little wind-up?

If it's true then I can only suggest you (i) rehome the sharks (I note the plural there, so you obviously have more than 1 which is a definite no-no anyway - and any of the shark family are not suited to that size tank with other tankmates as they are territorial and will chase and bully other fish - if they're not doing it right now, they will when they mature); (ii) rehome the convict (same as for the shark, they are territorial and will chase/bully etc and the tank is a bit small for their fully grown adult size); and (iii) that will leave you with the Betta...

There aren't that many fish you can choose to house with a Betta. So, unless you want a fairly empty tank with just a betta and maybe some Ottocinclus, or cories, you might want to rehome the betta and start completely afresh. If you're unsure about fish compatibility, ask on here before you buy anything.

I have a half-moon betta in a tank with platys, guppies, and swordtails. I was under the impression they are compatible (they do seem to get along very well) but after reading your post, i am a little concerned? is my mix okay? or do I need to keep an eye out for potential problems?

 

[Louiseness]

I have a half-moon betta in a tank with platys, guppies, and swordtails. I was under the impression they are compatible (they do seem to get along very well) but after reading your post, i am a little concerned? is my mix okay? or do I need to keep an eye out for potential problems?

I'd watch out for the guppies, as they're usually viewed as potential problems with bettas, because of the similarity of their colours and fins - but if they've both been OK so far I wouldn't be overly concerned.

Keep an eye out for nipped fins on anyone, or the betta showing signs of being stressed, but platies etc are much better tankmates than convicts and sharks, by far!

 

[Athena]

tanks two and a half ft

PRobably a bit small for Danio then. You'd probably be ok with a group of male guppies, they're pretty active. But post up the info that Fluttermoth asked you for, and you'll get much better advice.

I agree with you there. My fancy guppies (males and females) are absolutely bonkers! Very entertaining to watch. My swordtails are very active too.

...and all those incompatible tankmates held within a two and half foot tank? Really?? And you still want to add more to the pot?

Or is this a little wind-up?

If it's true then I can only suggest you (i) rehome the sharks (I note the plural there, so you obviously have more than 1 which is a definite no-no anyway - and any of the shark family are not suited to that size tank with other tankmates as they are territorial and will chase and bully other fish - if they're not doing it right now, they will when they mature); (ii) rehome the convict (same as for the shark, they are territorial and will chase/bully etc and the tank is a bit small for their fully grown adult size); and (iii) that will leave you with the Betta...

There aren't that many fish you can choose to house with a Betta. So, unless you want a fairly empty tank with just a betta and maybe some Ottocinclus, or cories, you might want to rehome the betta and start completely afresh. If you're unsure about fish compatibility, ask on here before you buy anything.

I have a half-moon betta in a tank with platys, guppies, and swordtails. I was under the impression they are compatible (they do seem to get along very well) but after reading your post, i am a little concerned? is my mix okay? or do I need to keep an eye out for potential problems?

Guppies are not a good tankmate for bettas due to their similar long-flowing finnage - sooner or later you could find problems with fin-nipping/aggression...and possibly deaths. Bettas can also become stressed if they are housed with fast-moving fish - obviously it depends on the temperament of your betta as they are quite individual, some are more accepting than others. Personally, I would never again (yes I did it once) keep a male betta in a community tank.

Yes, I would keep an eye out for any signs of distress, any abnormal behaviour in your betta (if he's looking sulky, withdrawn or showing any physical signs of illness) and keep an eye on your other fish for signs of fin-nipping, hanging out behind the filter or other hidey place, pop eye etc). A lot will depend also on the size of your tank and your stock volume - if it's a large tank and understocked then they can pretty much avoid each other easier than if they are in a smaller tank and fully stocked.

Regards, Athena

 

[covict]

thanks for ur comments but i think il keep it as it is just now see how i get on maybe rehome when they get bigger

 

[Dieses Madchen]

tanks two and a half ft

PRobably a bit small for Danio then. You'd probably be ok with a group of male guppies, they're pretty active. But post up the info that Fluttermoth asked you for, and you'll get much better advice.

I agree with you there. My fancy guppies (males and females) are absolutely bonkers! Very entertaining to watch. My swordtails are very active too.

...and all those incompatible tankmates held within a two and half foot tank? Really?? And you still want to add more to the pot?

Or is this a little wind-up?

If it's true then I can only suggest you (i) rehome the sharks (I note the plural there, so you obviously have more than 1 which is a definite no-no anyway - and any of the shark family are not suited to that size tank with other tankmates as they are territorial and will chase and bully other fish - if they're not doing it right now, they will when they mature); (ii) rehome the convict (same as for the shark, they are territorial and will chase/bully etc and the tank is a bit small for their fully grown adult size); and (iii) that will leave you with the Betta...

There aren't that many fish you can choose to house with a Betta. So, unless you want a fairly empty tank with just a betta and maybe some Ottocinclus, or cories, you might want to rehome the betta and start completely afresh. If you're unsure about fish compatibility, ask on here before you buy anything.

I have a half-moon betta in a tank with platys, guppies, and swordtails. I was under the impression they are compatible (they do seem to get along very well) but after reading your post, i am a little concerned? is my mix okay? or do I need to keep an eye out for potential problems?

Guppies are not a good tankmate for bettas due to their similar long-flowing finnage - sooner or later you could find problems with fin-nipping/aggression...and possibly deaths. Bettas can also become stressed if they are housed with fast-moving fish - obviously it depends on the temperament of your betta as they are quite individual, some are more accepting than others. Personally, I would never again (yes I did it once) keep a male betta in a community tank.

Yes, I would keep an eye out for any signs of distress, any abnormal behaviour in your betta (if he's looking sulky, withdrawn or showing any physical signs of illness) and keep an eye on your other fish for signs of fin-nipping, hanging out behind the filter or other hidey place, pop eye etc). A lot will depend also on the size of your tank and your stock volume - if it's a large tank and understocked then they can pretty much avoid each other easier than if they are in a smaller tank and fully stocked.

Regards, Athena

It's a 40 gallon tank with the betta, 5 guppies, 3 swordtails, and 2 platys. They seem to avoid each other. I have noticed some nipping, but its been between the male guppies. The betta has not been involved at all. I will definatly keep an eye on it. If things look to be aggressive, I will move the betta to another tank, as I have a 10 gallon in cycle right now. Thank you for the advice.

 

[Athena]

@ the OP

Yes... I thought you might...

Hey - why don't you add a few piranhas, a few bosemani's and some tiger barbs eh?

*Thinks that is the kind of irresponsible remark that this OP would like to see*

There's an old saying...you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

Ok - I give up on this one...

 

[fluttermoth]

thanks but i think il keep it as it is

That's all very well, but the fish you have now aren't suited; either to each other or the size of the tank. You're going to run into big problems (and very likely fish deaths too) sooner rather than later if you just 'keep it as it is'.

What kind of 'shark' are they, btw?

 

[the_lock_man]

There's an old saying...you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

There's also one about heads and brick walls - it's not worth the headache.

 

[Athena]

tanks two and a half ft

PRobably a bit small for Danio then. You'd probably be ok with a group of male guppies, they're pretty active. But post up the info that Fluttermoth asked you for, and you'll get much better advice.

I agree with you there. My fancy guppies (males and females) are absolutely bonkers! Very entertaining to watch. My swordtails are very active too.

...and all those incompatible tankmates held within a two and half foot tank? Really?? And you still want to add more to the pot?

Or is this a little wind-up?

If it's true then I can only suggest you (i) rehome the sharks (I note the plural there, so you obviously have more than 1 which is a definite no-no anyway - and any of the shark family are not suited to that size tank with other tankmates as they are territorial and will chase and bully other fish - if they're not doing it right now, they will when they mature); (ii) rehome the convict (same as for the shark, they are territorial and will chase/bully etc and the tank is a bit small for their fully grown adult size); and (iii) that will leave you with the Betta...

There aren't that many fish you can choose to house with a Betta. So, unless you want a fairly empty tank with just a betta and maybe some Ottocinclus, or cories, you might want to rehome the betta and start completely afresh. If you're unsure about fish compatibility, ask on here before you buy anything.

I have a half-moon betta in a tank with platys, guppies, and swordtails. I was under the impression they are compatible (they do seem to get along very well) but after reading your post, i am a little concerned? is my mix okay? or do I need to keep an eye out for potential problems?

Guppies are not a good tankmate for bettas due to their similar long-flowing finnage - sooner or later you could find problems with fin-nipping/aggression...and possibly deaths. Bettas can also become stressed if they are housed with fast-moving fish - obviously it depends on the temperament of your betta as they are quite individual, some are more accepting than others. Personally, I would never again (yes I did it once) keep a male betta in a community tank.

Yes, I would keep an eye out for any signs of distress, any abnormal behaviour in your betta (if he's looking sulky, withdrawn or showing any physical signs of illness) and keep an eye on your other fish for signs of fin-nipping, hanging out behind the filter or other hidey place, pop eye etc). A lot will depend also on the size of your tank and your stock volume - if it's a large tank and understocked then they can pretty much avoid each other easier than if they are in a smaller tank and fully stocked.

Regards, Athena

It's a 40 gallon tank with the betta, 5 guppies, 3 swordtails, and 2 platys. They seem to avoid each other. I have noticed some nipping, but its been between the male guppies. The betta has not been involved at all. I will definatly keep an eye on it. If things look to be aggressive, I will move the betta to another tank, as I have a 10 gallon in cycle right now. Thank you for the advice.

You're welcome! Yes, that would be the right thing to do. At least if you're aware of these things it can help you to know what to do if you happen to notice anything untoward going on. Great that you have another tank in the process, just in case!

All the best - Athena

 

[ZoddyZod]

There's an old saying...you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

Ok - I give up on this one...

don't worry, the school holidays wont last for ever and the board will soon be back to normal!

 

[Athena]

There's an old saying...you can lead a horse to water but you cannot make it drink.

Ok - I give up on this one...

don't worry, the school holidays wont last for ever and the board will soon be back to normal!

ah, that explains it!

 

[fluttermoth]

Don't forget we have two tanks concerning us here; the OP's 2.5 foot with the convicts and 'sharks' and Dieses's 40g with betta, 5 guppies, 3 swordtails, and 2 platys...

 

[the_lock_man]

Don't forget we have two tanks concerning us here; the OP's 2.5 foot with the convicts and 'sharks' and Dieses's 40g with betta, 5 guppies, 3 swordtails, and 2 platys...

I don't think the OP wants us to be too concerned about his anymore.

 

[Athena]

Don't forget we have two tanks concerning us here; the OP's 2.5 foot with the convicts and 'sharks' and Dieses's 40g with betta, 5 guppies, 3 swordtails, and 2 platys...

Hi - yes, am aware of two different situations. Have edited my other reply so that Dieses didn't think my comment was aimed at them, as his/her[?] post just pipped mine and I thought, oh dear, hope they realise my reply was aimed at the OP.

Anyway, off for a much needed cuppa LOL