What's new

Fish You Wanted To Get, Didn't Get, And Are Glad You Decided Not T

onidrase

Let's Be Friends
Joined
Oct 2, 2011
Messages
2,046
Reaction score
1
Points
0
Location
Colorado
I remember when I was first getting into the hobby. My original stocking was atrocious, which is how I ended up upgrading my tank. (2 blue gouramis that killed each other, 2 male guppies, 4 female guppies, 3 ghost catfish, 3 bleeding heart tetras, 1 algae eater, all in a single 20 gallon hexagon tank)

Anyways, I remember the first fish I wanted when I went to the LFS were pengasius catfish and bala sharks. Active, pretty, you know. Nobody was telling me not to do it, I asked how big the fish get, and if it would fit in my tank, and the employee told me my first aquarium myth, that my tank size doesn't matter, as fish only grow to the size of the tank.

This really turned me away from both of those fish species, I loved the two species a lot, but I didn't like the thought that I'd be keeping a fish from reaching its full potential just because I wanted to shove them in a tiny tank.

And thank goodness for that. From then on, I spent all my time exploring different websites, forums, and the like, reading everything I could on the aquarium trade and commonly found fish in domestication. Things have changed so much since then. I'm proud to be one of the people who doesn't stock their tank according to old fish keeping myths like those.

Does anyone else have any stories of fish that they really wanted to get, but are ultimately glad they didn't?
 
I really wanted a red-tailed black shark... still do as a matter of fact :P, but i know a 55g isn't adequate for them. I'll just have to wait until i get that monster tank i've always dreamed of.... :drool:
 
I really wanted a red-tailed black shark... still do as a matter of fact :P, but i know a 55g isn't adequate for them. I'll just have to wait until i get that monster tank i've always dreamed of.... :drool:
a 55g standard should be fine for a RTBS.. that's a good 4 feet long, 1 foot wide. Is it column style or something?
 
Unfortunatly i have done this before but i was younger
It was with goldfish you know how it is when yor young and belive evrything your told but i still had problems when i moved my fancys to an appropritate tank size so i gave up on goldies and i have had few problems with my tropicals so i find tropicals far easier to care fore and all my fish are happy healthy and growing fast :)
 
Silver sharks. I managed to keep a shoal of adults in a 6x2x2 for a number of years. Wish I hadn't though. The most skittish self harming fish around. I had to keep the lights off and everything silent in their room. It was like trying not to wake a baby.

I'm glad I never caved in years ago and bought leaf fish, knife fish or other predators when they used to be cheap.
 
Blind Cave Fish and American Flag fish

.....when I first started these seemed really tempting.....no idea why now!
 
The ID shark and the ever popular cute "little" Clown Loach. Beautiful fish. Would love to have a tank big enough for them both. I think there should be a rule keeping pet stores from selling schooling fish solo, unless of course you have proof that you are adding that fish to an existing school. How many single loaches have been sold, brought home, and hid until they die? So sad.
 
The ID shark and the ever popular cute "little" Clown Loach. Beautiful fish. Would love to have a tank big enough for them both. I think there should be a rule keeping pet stores from selling schooling fish solo, unless of course you have proof that you are adding that fish to an existing school. How many single loaches have been sold, brought home, and hid until they die? So sad.
clown loaches, knife fish, eels, large catfish, tin foil barbs, pacu, large cichlids, and the like imo shouldn't even be sold to the general public. Very few people out there have a tank near the minimum size for them.
 
I've always really wanted Angelfish. I fully intended to get a couple when I first got my tank (yes my 60l) but then I found out I couldn't. So I'm glad I found out about their size needs (and the territoral issues with them) before I got any.

Still really want some though, though now they're a fish for one day and not tomorrow.
 
I've always really wanted Angelfish. I fully intended to get a couple when I first got my tank (yes my 60l) but then I found out I couldn't. So I'm glad I found out about their size needs (and the territoral issues with them) before I got any.

Still really want some though, though now they're a fish for one day and not tomorrow.
I was a bit surprised that they could be aggressive, myself. They just look so delicate, and even the name of them sends a message of it being a peaceful fish.
 
Lol yep. and I had this terrible book that told me 2 small Angelfish would be fine in a tank of my size - along with loads of others!
 
Would love to get a Harlequin Shark (my local Aquajardin had some youngsters for ~18 months, probably still got some) and a Distichodus spp. (again were in stock at store) to add to my African riverine theme. However, the former makes the RTBS looks like a pussy cat and the latter never grow anywhere near wild sizes (~40v80cm) but are far to active for a 5-footer [much like another fish I love, Flagtail Carachin/Prochilodus].
 
wanted some tiger barbs coz they were supposed to be only semi aggressive - after watching their antics i decided that i might want to rethink!!
 
a school of pictus cats. As in, probably a dozen of them. Yikes.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top