Blue Freshwater Crayfish

The December FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

mitch70

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
160
Reaction score
0
Location
GB
Keep seeing these online and a number of online retailers stating that they are suitable for a community tank

that they are too slow to catch fish and will only eat dead or dying fish

has anyone kept them in a community tank?

is it a recepie for disaster?
 
my LFS (its a good one) had a couple of these in. they had 2 in a tank on there own. i asked about them and they said there no good for community tanks but thats the only advice i can give on them... the claws are massive though i wouldn't run the risk... i bet there faster when on the hunt :good:
 
A LFS in my area keeps a 6" crayfish in with some regular community fish. They say that it'll catch and eat the occasional slow fish, but if you keep it well fed it won't bother. Their display tanks are really small though, in a bigger tank the fish might have more room to hide.
 
Keep seeing these online and a number of online retailers stating that they are suitable for a community tank

that they are too slow to catch fish and will only eat dead or dying fish

has anyone kept them in a community tank?

is it a recepie for disaster?
you say "blue Crayfish" do you know the species? (vital this as most North American cray, are utterly hopeless for this job)
so, if you have an "Electric Blue" P.Allani,, its a none starter.
however if you have an "Blue Lobster" Cherax quadricarinatus perhaps.

either way, as a new Cray keeper. its"a recipe for disaster".

they are, by no means, "too slow to catch fish".
but, its true, they do only eat the sick and dying. ( or should if they are kept right.)

Crayfish are not carnivores (indeed they share, broadly, similar dietary requirements as a common pleco)

their diet should be of over ripe/rotting veg. supplemented by careful feeding of low fat meats (roast chicken breast, or the like.).
they will eat Algae wafers, catfih pellets and flake. but in reality they eat almost anything past its best.

there is good evidence cray like fresh meat. but this is made up of snails, worms and insect lave.
they do not hunt uless they are taught too. ie only fed feeder fish.

whilst it does seem that it is practical to keep cray in a community (i do).
both fish and cray need the correct environment, prior to the attempt.


so, if you have a stocked fully mature tank (of 50 gallons, or more). rough rule of thumb 2 years of stability. with no fish younger than 1 year.
and have a crayfish you have kept, on its own, for 1 year or so. (my experience says they need to be females.
maybe, just maybe, it might work.

but then, maybe, just maybe. you end up with fish soup!
 
Thankyou for the replies - blue lobsters i have seen are Cherax Quadricarinatus ,

think i will wait a while get a bit more expertise and see in a years time where I am.


learn to walk before I can run. They look so amazing though!
 
Thankyou for the replies - blue lobsters i have seen are Cherax Quadricarinatus ,

think i will wait a while get a bit more expertise and see in a years time where I am.


learn to walk before I can run. They look so amazing though!

indeed, fantastic stock. and very satisfying.
cycle your tank. add substrate.(ideally crushed coral, but i have plain 5mm gravel) then pile all the decor you have in the middle. the cray will set the tank out, as it wants it (over a month or so). it really is something to behold.
make sure you have two or three caves/hides too.
no plants though, even plastic ones get some stick.

why not pop over to WWW.crayfishmates.com. say Tylor sent you. lol, promises you wont get banned.
 
i have 3 lobsters my blue one is a bit more aggressive...but it varies i wouldnt put very beloved expensive fish in with them. definitly no oscars with the blue lobster
 
i have 3 lobsters my blue one is a bit more aggressive...but it varies i wouldnt put very beloved expensive fish in with them. definitly no oscars with the blue lobster

a very wise view. but you are talking about a different species of Crayfish, from a different continent. and that is relevant to the thread.

my fish, too, are valuable to me. but they live happily with the Cray.
whilst it is not something i would recommend. it can and does work.
knowledge and experience are the keys here.
its usually clear long before a cray is old enough to be placed in a tank, that it is not suited. the same is true of the fish it may be kept with.

what are the ages and sexes of your crays. also tank size (dimensions as well as volume). for my own interest only.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top