Which schooling fish acts like Buenos Aires tetra?

Acorno1

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Aug 14, 2022
Messages
131
Reaction score
60
Points
28
Location
Utah
I’m planning a 110 gallon tank with two Severums a cribroheros rostratus and some Brichardi cichlids.
The water should be fine but what schooling fish should I use. I don’t like mixing schools because it doesn’t work as well. My current favorite schooling species is actually the Buenos Aires tetra. Anything able to match the energy of a group?
It would be impressive.
 
Your Cichlid mix features some size issues, and water issues. A severum is soft water, and a Criboheros is large compared to brichardi, which wants very clean, stable hard water.

Buenos Aires are from a seasonal environment and do best if the temperature sits in the low 20s. So I see you having problems. Ideal temps for a brichardi are not ideal for a buenos aires.

If you follow the plan, a lot of barbs would be okay with Buenos. Equal sized tetras can handle them. You aren't following geography, so I would go with size. But I'd also have three different tanks for those fish.
 
I’m not planning on using Buenos Aires Tetras in this tank. I’m interested in a fish which matches their energy.
 
A fish I like with that general size and energy is Moenkhausia costae. They have become common around here recently.

Or, if you want all out crazy energy that the Central American cichlid probably won't kill, rosy barbs.
 
You should pay more attention to what GaryE just posted. Ignoring the size issues the fish you want are definitely from different water parameters. Also, they have different dietary needs.

Neolamprologus brichardi is a small cichlid endemic to Lake Tanganyika. It lives along the rocky shoreline, mostly between 5 and 25 m deep (Konings, 1993). It gathers in large groups that can look like shoals, but most adults in them live as breeding pairs. It hovers up to a metre above the rocks to feed on plankton
Temperature 23–26°C pH 8.0–9.0 Hardness 9–19dGH
https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/neolamprologus-brichardi

Cribroheros rostratus is native to Central America, specifically the Atlantic slope of Nicaragua and Costa Rica. A floodplain fish found between 0 and 200 m elevation. Inhabits lakes and rivers of low to high current velocity. A soil-eating omnivore with a strong carnivorous tendency; it sifts and digs through sand and substrate to feed on aquatic insects, detritus, and sediments. The generic name Cribroheros derives from the Latin word for a sieve, reflecting this sifting behavior.
Temperature range of 73–93°F ( 23°C - 34°C) and a pH of 7.0–8.2 General Hardness (GH). Aim for 8–20 dGH
https://www.fishbase.se/summary/Cribroheros-rostratus.html

Heros efasciatus is widespread throughout the Amazon main channel and rio Solimoes and also recorded from the rio Xingu. Slow moving rivers, tributaries and floodplain lakes. It's most abundant in deeper, calm waters with a lot of submerged tree roots and branches. Omnivorous and unfussy. Feed good quality dried foods, along with meatier fare such as bloodworm, chopped earthworms and prawns. Some vegetable matter should also feature in the diet. Shelled frozen peas, blanched spinach and dried spirulina-based foods are all recommended.
Temp 22.2–28.9°C pH 5.5–7.0 Hardness 1–8dGH
https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/heros-efasciatus

Most wild Tetras live in the Neotropical rivers, streams, and blackwater or clearwater systems of South America, particularly throughout the Amazon Basin (spanning countries like Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Venezuela, and Bolivia). The vast majority of wild tetras live in the Neotropical rivers, streams, and blackwater or clearwater systems of South America, particularly throughout the Amazon Basin (spanning countries like Brazil, Peru, Colombia, Venezuela, and Bolivia).
The Tetras tend to live in softer and somewhat acid pH waters. Because most tetras (like neon tetras) are small fish, choose finely crushed flakes or micro-sized granules they can easily swallow. They are an omnivorous fish.

Mixing the fish you are looking at in the same tank will not be good for half of the 4 species. Depending, on your tank parameters and how you feed, you may even manage to kill half of the 4 species.
 
I’m changing my stocking plan. Would a deep water hap work with brichardi? I would also like to know. Is there a schooling fish that could live in the same tank?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top