What Does Aquirium Salt Do

Live Plants use ammonia and can help eliminate ammonia from a tank, obviously thats not why you buy plants, but they do use ammonia (i.e. take it out of the water)
if that is true then y do people (including me) inject co2 into their planted aquariums? y not just put ammonia in there when there is no fish. i meen i have a 10g planted with no fish and im spending $100+ on co2 equipment and bottles when i could be spending 95 cents on bottled ammonia according to you.

Ammonia/ammonium (NH3/NH4) is a source of nitrogen N for plants, and CO2 is a source of carbon C. Adding ammonia as a nitrogen source is not a good idea for obvoius reasons, so potassium nitrate (KNO3) is used, which also provides potassium K. This has nothing to do with the original post, but I hope it clears a few things up.

Dave.
 
Yup, exactly what Dave said. Plants need all sorts of chemicals... nitrogen, which they prefer to uptake via ammonia, but can also take up nitrite and nitrate, carbon which they get from CO2, and potassium. They also need trace amounts of lots of minerals, magnesiuim, manganese, iron, etc. So, plants don't just use CO2, it doesn't have nitrogen in it, so is insufficient for life, since nitrogren is necessary for plant life.

If you want to read all about aquatic plant nutrition, I'd recommend Diana Walstad's Ecology of the Planted Aquarium. it is excellent in telling you what you need to keep plants alive.
 
ok but that says nothing about fry lovers post about plants just using ammonia.
 
afishdude, you got to be careful about putting words into others' mouths. frylover never said anything about plants "just" using ammonia. You are the one who put that word just in the there. Re-read the thread, the only time the word "just" appears in any of frylover's posts is quotes from you.
 
ok but that says nothing about fry lovers post about plants just using ammonia.

You appear to be confused :hyper:

Where did i say about "plants just using ammonia"

Why dont you quote my post because i cant see it anywhere where i said that :blink:

EDIT: okay having seen Big Nose post i dont want to labour the point
 
It adds aelctro lights( sp?) It also reduces the harmel affects of nitrate when at high concentrations, plus some fish live in the enviroment that need some type of salt, such as mollies, they do a hell of alot better with it.
 
does it help with ick

I would say that there is some evidence that salt can help with ich. The idea is that the presence of salt stresses everything in the tank, the fish and the ich. But, the ich, being a much lower life form than the fish, succumb to the stress earlier and more fatally. That is, the salt only stresses the fish and doesn't kill them, but does succeed in killing the ich. That said, all the caveats I listed above and in those previous threads I referenced still remain. There are species that are very intolerant of salt -- it doesn't do much good to kill the ich by injuring your fish. Fish whose natural habitats are very low mineral are going to be exceptionally intolerant of salt -- the cure in this case may be worse than the disease.

Not only that, but there are strains of ich that do not respond to the salt treatment at all -- that is, some strains of ich survive just fine all the way up through brackish water. My usual recommendation to people who want to try to use salt (almost always coupled with the heat treatment, too) is to try it for a few days, but if there isn't significant improvement you need to have medications ready to use. You can't know before hand how the ich will respond to the salt, so you have to have medications ready in case the salt is ineffective.

So, salt can help, sometimes, with ich and other parasites. However, it is not a magic bullet. And, for a lot of parasites, there are medications that are faster, more effective at killing the parasites and safer for the fish, to boot. So, yes it can help, but it may not be best choice. Again, research is needed to know what medications are available for the diseases.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top