What's new

Tough Decision Between Coldwater And Tropical - Please Help

Aquatic Hippo

New Member
Joined
Feb 4, 2012
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I have a common and a Fantail in a 29 gallon. The common will outgrow it eventually, and he will get stunted and die. I cannot have a bigger tank because I have literally no more room at all. The Goldfish are quite boring.

I want to do tropical. However, it is too late since I already have my Goldfish. I have a heater, so I could do tropical if my Goldfish were gone. A local park says I can give them my Goldfish to take off my hands and dump in their pond. They have tons of other Goldfish and catfish in there. My fantail is about 1 1/2" long, and my common is about 2 1/2". I was thinking of letting them go, so they can live happily, and be free with their own kind. Also, I'm in Pennsylvania. Its about 35 degrees here in January on average, and 80 to 90 degrees on average in months like July.

In a 29 gallon, there isn't much option for coldwater besides Goldfish. However, for tropical, there are TONS of options for a 29 gallon. I was going to do a tropical community. If I were to let them go, how could I get them from 70 degree tank water, to pond water where it is about 30 to 40 degrees farenheit outside without them going into shock? I think its best if I let them go, and get some tropical fish.

What do you guys think?

EDIT: People are saying Fantail can't go in a pond, what could I do with him then? Also, I wanted Silver Hatchetfish, Black Kuhli Loaches, Otinculus (type of Plecostomus), and maybe some Ghost Shrimp? Like I said I wanted a community of unique fish, like the Hatchetfishes' unique body shape, the Kuhli loaches worm/snake like body, Otinculus cleans tank by eating algae, and Ghost Shrimp for some little tank mates.
 
mmmh you should definatley go for a tropical tank! I even have a stocking suggestion, if you'd like :nod:


12x Praecox Rainbows
10x Cardinal Tetras
8x Otocinclus Catfish (for algae control)
8x Kuhli Loaches (bottom feeders)

or you could go

12x Cardinal Tetras
12x Rummy Nose Tetras
8x Oto cats
Trio of dwarf cichlids, so one male two female of either Agassizi Cichlid or Cockatoo Cichlid :good:
 
I'm afraid fantials aren't hardy enough to live outside, assuming you're in the UK.
 
Of course there are more varieties for cold water than goldfish!

Don't put the fantail in the pond,fancies aren't suited for ponds.

You could keep the fancy goldfish, but other temperate fish include white cloud mountain minnows, variatus platys, danios, peppered corys, some barbs...all sorts.
 
Of course there are more varieties for cold water than goldfish!

Don't put the fantail in the pond,fancies aren't suited for ponds.

You could keep the fancy goldfish, but other temperate fish include white cloud mountain minnows, variatus platys, danios, peppered corys, some barbs...all sorts.
I have my fantails and telescope eyes in a pond.......
 
There's heck of a lot of difference between the climate in Texas and the UK, mate!
 
Of course there are more varieties for cold water than goldfish!

Don't put the fantail in the pond,fancies aren't suited for ponds.

You could keep the fancy goldfish, but other temperate fish include white cloud mountain minnows, variatus platys, danios, peppered corys, some barbs...all sorts.
I have my fantails and telescope eyes in a pond.......

You live in Texas, that might be a lot warmer than whereever the op is.
 
Anyway, fancies are slower and can't compete as well with single tailed fish for food. Not really fair to dump them in a pond, they're a man made creation designed to look pretty, not survive in the wild.
 
I live in Pennsylvania. Its like 35 degrees average in January, but in hot months like July its about 85 to 90 degrees daily.
 
Wow; it's -1°C/30°F where I am right now *shivers* My pond's been frozen all day.
 
Anyway, fancies are slower and can't compete as well with single tailed fish for food. Not really fair to dump them in a pond, they're a man made creation designed to look pretty, not survive in the wild.
Exactly; it's not just about temperatures. It would be like putting a pekingese in with a wolf pack!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top