Uh oh i just read through the comments and saw someone say not to buy i whisper filter (must have missed that comment) however they then said that tetras were good? i bought a tetra 20 i filter. yay or nay? shall i return it?
Hi Gnad,
I find it a bit hard to comment on the smaller, more proprietary filters like the Tetra 20i model you are asking about. The problem for me is that there seem to be several downsides (which I'll try to mention) but then there also may be members who have overcome these problems or who don't find them to be a problem and the issue of expense always comes in, so the inexpensiveness of this filter may be an important factor.
I don't have hands-on experience with this filter but from pictures it appears to be an internal that adjusts up and down the inside aquarium wall on its suction cups (which is good.) Its got a flow rate of 125g per hour, which puts it a bit over 5x turnover for your 20g, which is appropriate range that we usually recommend, so its got the basics right. The negative thing is that it appears to be one of the more "proprietary" designs. The designers appear to have worked hard on the problem of how to get the consumer back into the store buying replacement cartridges on a regular basis, this often being what the companies spend their design time on. The selling point is "easy snap-in maintenance." The problem is that "replacement" maintenance is not at all what modern "biofilters" are all about. Biofilters are all about growing the correct two species of bacteria and them attempting to keep them alive and healthy for life, *not* throwing them out!
This Tetra model appears to want you to buy "bio-bags" to periodically snap in. I searched and the bio-bags appear to be perhaps padded mesh bags (which means they will form part of the biofilter which one does not want to throw out) that hold carbon (aka activated charcoal.) Carbon is actually used by hobbyists as an optional -chemical- filtration media and is only effective for about 3 days, after which it is ready to be thrown out. It is only usually needed for removal of meds, tannins or unusual organic smells, which should be only unusual rare occurances during the years you practice the hobby. In other words, carbon is meant to sit on the shelf, not in the filter on a regualr basis.
As a result, out on the web you find owners attempting to modify their Tetra 20i filters to hold more of the regular biomedia that is needed in large amounts. I found a
picture of a person trying to stretch pantyhose over the Tetra media frame to create a custom "biobag" to hold what looks like ceramic pebbles (stuff that looks like aquarium gravel but actually has much better gripping surface for the beneficial bacteria.)
At the 20G sized aquarium you should be fine with an internal filter, but its good to be aware that in general HOB (hang on back) filter have somewhat larger media volume than internals and then external cannisters have considerably larger media volume than either of those, and more flexibility in holding custom media chosen by the owner rather than the manufacturer.
Again, I hope one or more members will come along (maybe already have while I write!) who can relate their experience wtih these, perhaps reassuring you that they are fine!
~~waterdrop~~