Pregnant platys???

The April FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

ACLC123

New Member
Joined
Jun 23, 2022
Messages
5
Reaction score
4
Location
United kingdom
Hi there quite new to this! I took these platies on from a friends who moved away, they are just a portion of the fish she had the others went to a relative.

I just wondered if anyone could tell me if they are pregnant or not I tried my best the get photos. I’ve done a bit of research but can’t seem to determine if they are or not! So thought why not ask the experts!

And any advice on what to do if they are!
Thank you!
 

Attachments

  • 00BFA9EC-8C4E-43E7-A11B-9A2850550A66.jpeg
    00BFA9EC-8C4E-43E7-A11B-9A2850550A66.jpeg
    187.8 KB · Views: 52
  • 6DC48857-0813-47B5-B596-261626246257.jpeg
    6DC48857-0813-47B5-B596-261626246257.jpeg
    202.2 KB · Views: 46
  • 6C00E8F2-B2D6-4BC0-8356-D90D1504CA8B.jpeg
    6C00E8F2-B2D6-4BC0-8356-D90D1504CA8B.jpeg
    196.1 KB · Views: 46
  • B3DB4091-13A4-4175-8333-E8EDDC3640CE.jpeg
    B3DB4091-13A4-4175-8333-E8EDDC3640CE.jpeg
    210.6 KB · Views: 48
  • F265B7B4-7DF0-4B10-81C9-0959C23EEDB2.jpeg
    F265B7B4-7DF0-4B10-81C9-0959C23EEDB2.jpeg
    191.7 KB · Views: 52
  • 02A14260-0109-4104-8D0A-D5A7AD7BDE4F.jpeg
    02A14260-0109-4104-8D0A-D5A7AD7BDE4F.jpeg
    186.2 KB · Views: 46
  • E6DD2370-2649-4C5F-BECC-742DD06F0596.jpeg
    E6DD2370-2649-4C5F-BECC-742DD06F0596.jpeg
    180.5 KB · Views: 43
Hi! Welcome to the forum and the hobby! :D
I think they might be swordtails rather than platies, but I'm not an expert - luckily, we do have a livebearer expert here! @emeraldking truly is your man for all things livebearer :)
Some in the pics do look as though they might be gravid, and if she gave you some from a tank with a load of fish, it's very likely that there was a male or two in there, and female livebearers can store sperm for months after contact with a male, so it's very likely that you'll be having fry at some point!

Are you sure that they're all female? I can see most in the photos are, but photo number five looks as though it might be a male, hard to tell from the pic, just my suspicion! And if you do have a male, then fry are even more inevitable! It can get overwhelming, since livebearers tend to produce a lot of fry in a pretty short time period. Worth checking out if any fish stores near you would be willing to take your fry once they're old enough to sell, so your tank doesn't get overstocked. :)
 
To be sure about male or female, look at the anal fin. See pic below. Males have a sharper looking, pointy fin thing there called a gonopodium, while the females have that fan shape that you see in most of your photos. Worth sitting by the tank for a few minutes and watching, checking for whether there's any chasing going on, and having a look at those fins!

These fish are guppies, but the fin shape is pretty similar in platies, mollies and swordtails too.
guppy-fish-male-female-photo.jpg
 
Hi! Welcome to the forum and the hobby! :D
I think they might be swordtails rather than platies, but I'm not an expert - luckily, we do have a livebearer expert here! @emeraldking truly is your man for all things livebearer :)
Some in the pics do look as though they might be gravid, and if she gave you some from a tank with a load of fish, it's very likely that there was a male or two in there, and female livebearers can store sperm for months after contact with a male, so it's very likely that you'll be having fry at some point!

Are you sure that they're all female? I can see most in the photos are, but photo number five looks as though it might be a male, hard to tell from the pic, just my suspicion! And if you do have a male, then fry are even more inevitable! It can get overwhelming, since livebearers tend to produce a lot of fry in a pretty short time period. Worth checking out if any fish stores near you would be willing to take your fry once they're old enough to sell, so your tank doesn't get overstocked. :)
Thank you for the welcome!

That would be interesting to know if they aren’t platies! Im pretty certain they are all female judging from their underside fin and comparing the images you sent Of the guppies!
If I am going to have fry any advice on timescales, how to raise them etc ?
 
Thank you for the welcome!

That would be interesting to know if they aren’t platies! Im pretty certain they are all female judging from their underside fin and comparing the images you sent Of the guppies!
If I am going to have fry any advice on timescales, how to raise them etc ?
This thread links really helpful advice about the different ways people raise livebearers etc, really worth reading through! :D

My personal advice based on breeding mollies, guppies and platies for a few years varies, depending on what you want to happen! Do you want to have them all raised in the same tank like a colony breeding set up? Rescue every fry? Adults will eat newborn fry if they have the chance, but there are different methods to try to prevent that happening. Some use breeding nets or boxes to contain the fry safely for a few weeks until they're big enough to no longer be considered a snack for adults, or some people will use a lot of live plants for the fry to hide in. That makes it easier in terms of not setting up another tank or raising them in a breeder box, and it tends to be weaker or sickly fry that get eaten by adults if done this way, so it can actually be helpful that only the stronger ones make it... natural selection, kinda.

Or some set up a nursery/grow out tank and raise the fry in there, I've done that too, but depends whether you're able or want to set up another tank! I highly advise finding out if a store is willing to take batches of livebearer fry once they're old enough to sell - most of the big chain stores won't, so you'll want to look for privately owned, local fish stores. They're more likely to take them off your hands, and some may give some store credit or something in exchange for a nice batch of healthy young fish. :) Otherwise, you're looking at trying to sell them privately via places like Gumtree, which can be tricky and time consuming. I shut down my livebearer breeding entirely when my local fish store who used to take my batches of young fish closed down... I didn't have time to arrange private sales of 2-3 fish at a time when the adults were churning out 30 or so fry in each batch!

Don't get me wrong, I really enjoyed breeding them while I did! It's fun to raise adorable baby fish and watch them grow, see what colours they turn out to be, etc. It's just that the numbers can get overwhelming quickly if you're saving all the fry, and don't have a plan for where they will go once you have 30, 40, 50 young fish bursting your tank at the seams! lol
 
They're all female. And they're pregnant. And they are platies, Variatus platies (Xiphophorus variatus) in this case. It's a bit hard to tell when they'll deliver those fry. For with Variatus platies can get very big or moderate before they'll drop fry.
 
This thread links really helpful advice about the different ways people raise livebearers etc, really worth reading through! :D

My personal advice based on breeding mollies, guppies and platies for a few years varies, depending on what you want to happen! Do you want to have them all raised in the same tank like a colony breeding set up? Rescue every fry? Adults will eat newborn fry if they have the chance, but there are different methods to try to prevent that happening. Some use breeding nets or boxes to contain the fry safely for a few weeks until they're big enough to no longer be considered a snack for adults, or some people will use a lot of live plants for the fry to hide in. That makes it easier in terms of not setting up another tank or raising them in a breeder box, and it tends to be weaker or sickly fry that get eaten by adults if done this way, so it can actually be helpful that only the stronger ones make it... natural selection, kinda.

Or some set up a nursery/grow out tank and raise the fry in there, I've done that too, but depends whether you're able or want to set up another tank! I highly advise finding out if a store is willing to take batches of livebearer fry once they're old enough to sell - most of the big chain stores won't, so you'll want to look for privately owned, local fish stores. They're more likely to take them off your hands, and some may give some store credit or something in exchange for a nice batch of healthy young fish. :) Otherwise, you're looking at trying to sell them privately via places like Gumtree, which can be tricky and time consuming. I shut down my livebearer breeding entirely when my local fish store who used to take my batches of young fish closed down... I didn't have time to arrange private sales of 2-3 fish at a time when the adults were churning out 30 or so fry in each batch!

Don't get me wrong, I really enjoyed breeding them while I did! It's fun to raise adorable baby fish and watch them grow, see what colours they turn out to be, etc. It's just that the numbers can get overwhelming quickly if you're saving all the fry, and don't have a plan for where they will go once you have 30, 40, 50 young fish bursting your tank at the seams! lol
Amazing thank you so much for the advice! I might give it a go and see how I get on!
 
They're all female. And they're pregnant. And they are platies, Variatus platies (Xiphophorus variatus) in this case. It's a bit hard to tell when they'll deliver those fry. For with Variatus platies can get very big or moderate before they'll drop fry.
Amazing thank you for the confirmation I will keep an eye on them and set up another tank in preparation 😊
 
They're all female. And they're pregnant. And they are platies, Variatus platies (Xiphophorus variatus) in this case. It's a bit hard to tell when they'll deliver those fry. For with Variatus platies can get very big or moderate before they'll drop fry.

Thank you for confirming what they are! They're just a slightly different shape from the ones I kept before, they look kinda longer bodied than the ones I'm used to, so I wondered if they might be swordtail girls. :) Maybe my own platies were a different type of platy. But any livebearer questions, I know to tag you, and that we're lucky to have you here!
 
Thank you for confirming what they are! They're just a slightly different shape from the ones I kept before, they look kinda longer bodied than the ones I'm used to, so I wondered if they might be swordtail girls. :) Maybe my own platies were a different type of platy. But any livebearer questions, I know to tag you, and that we're lucky to have you here!
You've probably had maculatus platies (Xiphophorus maculatus). Those platies are most sold within the commercial scene.
 
You've probably had maculatus platies (Xiphophorus maculatus). Those platies are most sold within the commercial scene.

Yes! Looking at the google pics, that's the shape I think of as a platy shape, just because it's what I'm used to :D
Had santa platies, mickey mouse, red wagtails, and blues, that all interbred and produced some fun mixes of colours and mickey patterns:)

The blues were my favourites though! Kept a trio of blue males just because I couldn't part with them, but couldn't have more fry, lol. Here's one of the first blue females I had. Does that look like a maculatus? You see what I mean about the tail end seems shorter than the species above? Because my mental image is of them like this, more compact than the longer shape of a molly or sword. :)

DSCF3646.JPG
 
Yes! Looking at the google pics, that's the shape I think of as a platy shape, just because it's what I'm used to :D
Had santa platies, mickey mouse, red wagtails, and blues, that all interbred and produced some fun mixes of colours and mickey patterns:)

The blues were my favourites though! Kept a trio of blue males just because I couldn't part with them, but couldn't have more fry, lol. Here's one of the first blue females I had. Does that look like a maculatus? You see what I mean about the tail end seems shorter than the species above? Because my mental image is of them like this, more compact than the longer shape of a molly or sword. :)

View attachment 161916
Yes, yours is of the Maculatus version. Maculatus and Variatus platies are the ones that are used in the commercial world. And mostly the Maculatus platies in comparison to the Variatus platies. But besides the Xiphophorus maculatus and the Xiphophorus variatus, there are way more platy species in the wild. But those weren't used in the commercial world. Some other wild platy species are Xiphophorus evelynae, Xiphophorus milleri, Xiphophorus xiphidium, Xiphophorus meyeri, etc... And they all differ in shape and coloration.
 
Yes, yours is of the Maculatus version. Maculatus and Variatus platies are the ones that are used in the commercial world. And mostly the Maculatus platies in comparison to the Variatus platies. But besides the Xiphophorus maculatus and the Xiphophorus variatus, there are way more platy species in the wild. But those weren't used in the commercial world. Some other wild platy species are Xiphophorus evelynae, Xiphophorus milleri, Xiphophorus xiphidium, Xiphophorus meyeri, etc... And they all differ in shape and coloration.
Thank you for taking the time to share your knowledge! :D It's really fascinating to pick up these bits of info from you, and nice to know why I was a bit thrown off by the the different shapes! I can see why you chose to dive deep and specialise in livebearers. Lots of people in the hobby get a bit snobby and dismiss livebearers as "beginner fish", but there's good reason that they're so popular, and a really fascinating world of many mostly unknown species and biology there for those that care to look :)
 

Most reactions

trending

Staff online

Members online

Back
Top