Plants - Live Or Fake?

The December FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Lioness70

Mostly New Member
Joined
Jun 15, 2013
Messages
11
Reaction score
0
Location
GB
2nd question for you guys and girls....

Small-ish tank (50 litre) and at the moment I'm just running it to get the levels right before stocking it. I've got a couple of fake plants in there but wondered if I should put real ones in as well/instead? Do I have to do anything different? I've got gravel in the bottom currently. If live plants are better, what would you suggest?

Thanks. :)
 
I personally think live plants are better than fake, but they do create a bit more work, in terms of controlling algae, ensuring they are fed enough, have the right spectrum of light, etc. But there's no doubt that a well planted tank looks tons better than plastic or even silk. Furthermore, plastic plants can be harmful to the fins of certain long-finned species.
 
Sorry, I know it's off topic, somewhat, but when you say you are running the tank to get the levels right, are you adding bottled ammonia?
 
Thanks for that. I'll go have a look at some live ones!

Yes, I got some additives from the place I bought the tank and am going to get the water tested on Saturday
 
If I may offer you some advice, DON'T go and look at plants in the shop.  Research some suitable starter plants first and try those first, such as anubias, java fern and cryptocorynes.  The pet shop will sell all sorts of plants some of which require high light or CO2 and others are not even aquatic at all and will simply die.  It's much better to set out knowing exactly which plants will survive in your tank.
 
Can you tell us the names of the additives you are using to cycle the tank?
 
The "additives" bottle is almost certainly NOT bottled ammonia - it is a "bacteria in a bottle" product. Many people, myself included, believe these products are next to useless. I can see how they might be beneficial when used alongside bottled ammonia, but even if there are live bacteria in the bottle, they can't be that great until they have some food and that food is ammonia.
 
I can pretty much guarantee that right now, at this very moment, your tank will be perfect for fish - because there is nothing in it that will make it not-perfect. The moment you put a fish in there, it will start to produce ammonia, but you won't have sufficient bacteria in the filter to process this ammonia and consequent nitrite, and you will poison your fish. Have a read-through of some of the threads in the Emergencies section - "Why did my platy die" is one, there's also one I've just replied to about a danio that's been suffering, and swimming at an angle.
 
At the top of this section of the forum is something called the "Beginners Resource Area". In there are two articles that you really, really need to read. One is called The Nitrogen Cycle - it gives you all the theoretical stuff. THe second is called "Fishless Cycling" - this tells you how to grow the filter bacteria without harming any fish (and it's a lot less work than trying to do it with fish in the tank. I should point out that it's rather out of date, particularly the "Add Daily" method, and in the very near future, it will be replaced with the latest thinking, but in the meantime, it's a good read, and it tells you stuff that most LFS won't tell you - because it's not profitable for the retailers to do so.
 
You also really need your own tests, rather than relying on the LFS. I personally recommend the Salifert and Nutrafin ranges, many others recommend the API kit.
 
I started off with fake plants. I had 1 silk 3 plastic looking ferns. I now have 2 crypts and I have a Java fern along with Java moss in the post coming. TBH, real plants do look much better. They also eat up ammonia and nitrates, as well as providing your tank with oxygen.
I am in the process of buying some fertilisers for the plants.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top