pH drop at start of cycle

orange shark3 2

Fish Gatherer
Joined
Feb 17, 2007
Messages
2,003
Reaction score
1
Points
38
Location
GB
Hi folks,

I’m getting back into the hobby after a long time out. I’ve started back up with a small 25l tank intended for a betta and a few shrimp, and I started my fishless cycle recently.

When I tested yesterday my pH seems to have dropped to 6.4-6.6 (when testing my tap water it’s around 7), and I’m worried about the cycle stalling right at the start. Is there anything I can do to up the pH slightly (safely), or should I just let it be on the understanding the cycle might just take a bit longer?

Thanks
 
I can't help with pH-affecting cycling questions, as that part of the hobby I still don't fully understand.
But do you have anything in the tank that causes the pH drop? Do you have aquatic soil or botanicals in the tank? If so, over time, their acidic compounds will wear off in tandem with water changes, bringing the pH back to tap water levels.

@Essjay @TwoTankAmin can help with cycling queries :)
 
At the minute the only thing in the tank is black sand (bought from LFS), I figured I’d get the cycle started and then when I get the chance add decorations while it’s going on
 
Test your tap water pH both immediately out of the faucet and then again in 24 hrs.

Please describe your set up…..aeration, filtration, temp etc.
What is the ammonia reading atm?

I am a fan of using crushed coral to slowly raise KH and pH if needed.
 
@orange shark Does your water company give alkalinity on its website? That's what water companies call KH. If KH is low, pH can drop.

I have done a couple of fishless cycles following TwoTankAmin's method on here, and the first one did suffer a pH drop. To rectify this I added bicarbonate of soda to the water during cycling - it's not good when there are fish in the tank, but it's OK during cycling and the big water change at the end of the cycle removes it before fish are added. I used 1 x 5ml spoon bicarb in a 25 litre tank. You may already have some bicarbonate of soda in the kitchen; if not it comes in small tubs in the home baking aisle in the supermarket.
My KH is 3 degrees, which is why the pH dropped. But because I do regular large water changes this tops up the KH and the pH remains stable. I don't need to add anything to boost KH. Of course it does depend on how low KH is, lower than mine may well need the crushed coral that bgarthe suggested.
 
Test your tap water pH both immediately out of the faucet and then again in 24 hrs.

Please describe your set up…..aeration, filtration, temp etc.
What is the ammonia reading atm?

I am a fan of using crushed coral to slowly raise KH and pH if needed.
Will do that thanks, when I tested straight out the tap it was c.7.0

Standard compact internal filter (Marina i25), positioned so the flow is providing plenty of surface movement (plan to adjust this post cycle for the Betta). Temperature sitting at 27.

Ammonia sat at around 3ppm yesterday morning, when I tested today it looked closer to 0.5ppm to me (I added Nitrico yesterday evening) but Nitrites were 0, so not entirely sure what’s happened but might just be me misreading the Ammonia chart!

Will look in to crushed coral thanks.
 
Last edited:
@orange shark Does your water company give alkalinity on its website? That's what water companies call KH. If KH is low, pH can drop.

I have done a couple of fishless cycles following TwoTankAmin's method on here, and the first one did suffer a pH drop. To rectify this I added bicarbonate of soda to the water during cycling - it's not good when there are fish in the tank, but it's OK during cycling and the big water change at the end of the cycle removes it before fish are added. I used 1 x 5ml spoon bicarb in a 25 litre tank. You may already have some bicarbonate of soda in the kitchen; if not it comes in small tubs in the home baking aisle in the supermarket.
My KH is 3 degrees, which is why the pH dropped. But because I do regular large water changes this tops up the KH and the pH remains stable. I don't need to add anything to boost KH. Of course it does depend on how low KH is, lower than mine may well need the crushed coral that bgarthe suggested.

Not sure an alkalinity, when I googled it says it’s typically slightly alkaline and soft (9.3 mg/l calcium if that helps). Handy tip on the bicarbonate, I’ll keep an eye on readings over the next few days and if it gets any worse I may add.
 
What's the name of your water company? I'll see what I can find.

Water chemistry can be confusing, luckily my younger son once worked as an analyst at a water testing company so he explained a lot. When a water company uses the term alkalinity they mean carbonate hardness or KH. It's not the same as water being alkaline, which means having a pH above 7.0.

Hardness, or GH, has several units of measurement. Fish keeping uses just 2 of those - German degrees or dH and ppm or mg/l calcium carbonate. Fish profiles will give the hardness range for a species in one or other of those two so it's useful to know our hardness in both those units. Your 9.3 mg/l calcium converts to 1.3 dH and 23.2 ppm. It's not just soft, it's very soft. As a general rule, if GH is low KH will also be low so with your very low GH it is likely you also have very low KH as well, in which case it may well be advisable to use crushed coral.
 
What's the name of your water company? I'll see what I can find.

Water chemistry can be confusing, luckily my younger son once worked as an analyst at a water testing company so he explained a lot. When a water company uses the term alkalinity they mean carbonate hardness or KH. It's not the same as water being alkaline, which means having a pH above 7.0.

Hardness, or GH, has several units of measurement. Fish keeping uses just 2 of those - German degrees or dH and ppm or mg/l calcium carbonate. Fish profiles will give the hardness range for a species in one or other of those two so it's useful to know our hardness in both those units. Your 9.3 mg/l calcium converts to 1.3 dH and 23.2 ppm. It's not just soft, it's very soft. As a general rule, if GH is low KH will also be low so with your very low GH it is likely you also have very low KH as well, in which case it may well be advisable to use crushed coral.
It’s Yorkshire Water, I had a quick google and couldn’t find much of use.

I assume crushed coral goes in the filter? Only challenge there is with the compact filter but sure I can shove some somewhere!

Thanks for your help!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top