Looking To Do A Fairly Major Rescape Advice Needed

Its hard to tell without the other plants around or it near/infront or in the tank to compare but if you don't use the one of the pieces I would happily buy it.

You need to think about how your plants are going to be placed in relation based on the rules people have mentioned above. I am amature at the tank thing but have worked with design/art and engineering over the last 6 years so have a basic idea.

I am currently struggling with what you have mastered in the terms of getting plants to grow although I think a little is down to trying plants that need medium/high light and I have just about low light.

I would make sure you know what your plants are, how they grow and what you expect. Some times although one plant may be taller when it finishes growing it could take 3x as long as another which ends up slightly smaller so you have to think about how the plant grows over time as well as the end product otherwise you want see all your plants.

You could do a straight swap with the u-boat and first piece of bogwood. Move the centre plant about 15cm to the right (facing the tank). The plants that are on the left central as they are smaller and the ones which are currently at the back to the right to the left hand side. This would give you a 'V' shape with a focal point just to one side of the 'V' being the bogwood.

I can only picture this in my head and may need tweaking just to get the basic idea but it works around the golden rules, keeps you current plants which you can then swap for similar size but may preffer something else and see how it goes from there.

As I said only my idea with what I would do but you have some great healthy plants I am jelous off.

Take some photos as you go and keep asking as you are putting it back together. People who know more than me may be able to give you a better idea on exactly which plant where but don't forget to express yourself.

Kind Regards,

Adam
 
1) The U-boat is going on ebay I hate the thing its only contibution to my tank is/was making it look less empty during my fishless cycle I've spent my time since planting stuff in front of it to hide it lol

3) As my plant knowledge Isnt great im considering something likeTHIS Ive been reading up on v shapes etc and it left me feeling baffled and out my depth :blush:

135quid! They call that planting on a budget???!! For such little amount of plants? This is very expensive! This is almost 3000 pesos! This is half a month's salary for many people here...

Glad you got rid of the U-boat. I didn't like it either, but everybody their choice... :rolleyes:

I love the wood. Good luck with the new scape.
 
Many thanks for all the replys they have given me a lot of confidence !

I think i'll buy the 2nd bit of wood see what its like with both in maybe resell one if its no good. Only thing putting me off getting it is its a fairly hunk piece and make make a 2nd eye attraction lessing the impact of the first ?
 
I have also expressed the price of those plants. It seems to be getting more and more expensive @ TGM.
 
Ah yes thanks for the reply ! I hadn't replied yet as you showed offline ;p

i have some of the plants already green machine bill would be circe £75 does that website do online ordering btw ? ;p
 
Many thanks for all the replys they have given me a lot of confidence !

I think i'll buy the 2nd bit of wood see what its like with both in maybe resell one if its no good. Only thing putting me off getting it is its a fairly hunk piece and make make a 2nd eye attraction lessing the impact of the first ?

If you take 2 pieces of wood with a similar size, this might happen, yes. But if you opt for 1 big piece and a smaller piece at the other end, you can go with a so-called island scape with one bigger island at 1 side and a smaller one at the other side. Then your eyes would be drawn first to the bigger island and later to the smaller one. No problem.

You could alternatively combine the 2 pieces together and turn it into 1 scape. I think your tank is big enough for it.
 
Based on the size of both I would suggest looking at a slightly smaller piece to one side should you go down the route of two pieces. I currently have 4 pieces but 2 are small/medium and the other 2 make one big piece to plant around so I will end up with a V shape once planting is sorted and I find what works for my tank.

Anyways let us know and make sure to the pics coming as you go so we can see how things develop.

Good Luck,

Adam
 
The bogwood arrived yesterday and the two pieces of redwood bogwood arrived today and are currently soaking. All the plants are came about an hour ago except for 2 crypt Beckettii 'petchii' and 50 x dwarf sag which come next week. Had to go to university about 5 mins after plants came so there sitting in the sink while the redmoor wood is in the bath. The packaging is all over the kitchen lol

I *may* be in trouble if I dont beat my fiancee home tonight :crazy:

Will get planting when I'm home in few hours and take plenty of pics as its in progress :good:
 
Still got work to do on the tank but here it is as it stands atm. Changes still to be made are

1) The tall spindly plants in front right corner are still to be removed
2) The small crypts in the front left need removed (not sure if ill bin them sell em or move em yet)
3) The Dwarf Sag needs to be planted when it arrives (50x)
4) The 2 Petchii need to be planted when it arrives.


The list of plants added/will be added is

3 x Cryptocoryne Mi Oya
2 x Echinodorus bleheri
1 x Echinodorus uruguayensis
1 x Echinodorus rose
1 x Microsorum pteropus (I'm using my existing motherplant)
2 x Microsorum pteropus 'Narrow'
1 x Anubias barteri var nana (bought from forum member AaronNorth :good:)
1 x Anubias barteri var angustifolia
10x Flame Moss (For the left hand bog wood not here yet)
2 x Cryptocoryne petchii (not here yet)
2 x Cryptocoryne willisii
50x Dwarf Sag (not here yet)

It still needs tweaked and things moved a little so all "YOUR DOING IT WRONG!" comments are warmly invited :good:


dscf06681.jpg
 
Theres 5 plants along the back (in between the 2 Swords) The 3 Cryptocoryne Mi Oya 1 Echinodorus uruguayensis and 1 Echinodorus rose there just not massive specimens atm :good: The dwarf sag I want to use as a carpet as opposed to Parvula or Pygmy Chain Swords.

The only other thing I've been musing is 1 more piece of redmoor bogwood to extend it down to nearer the RHS.
 
I would not add more wood, as I think it would take the attention away from the 'branchy' piece. Exactly, I think you are right choosing the first 4 plants on your list to fill out the background. Like I said before, it looks very good already. If you get your background a bit more filled out with the taller species you are planning, I think you will have a brilliant tank.
 
Everything is going nicely with the exception of the enchindorus 'rose' that doesnt see to be to happy :angry: If it dies whats a good low/medium light replacement for it at the back ? Will post more pics when rest of the stuff is here and planted.
 
give it a chance, it may die back before comming back to life. The chances are its been grown out of water, so needs to adapt itself. Why is there some plants still in pots?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top