Is Dan Blowing Smoke?

I have purchased 5 species from Dan. The 10 red coral dwarf Platy arrived with worms that responded to Flubenzadole. I have purchased 4 species from the Wet Spot. A female a. borelli died on day 14 of quarantine. So even the best sellers are not perfect. I prefer Dan’s single fish per bag packaging but I prefer the Wet Spots prices and massive selection, including a nice menu of wild caught fish.
 
If for some reason I lived in the US, I would order from him, Wet Spot and Reheboth Aquatics, although Dan's carries fewer of the fish I really like. He's a good source, and the one time I had fish from him, they were difficult softwater species that adjusted rapidly to my soft water.
Who is this Reheboth Aquatics you speak of? I've never heard of them and they don't seem to have a working website.
 
Who is this Reheboth Aquatics you speak of? I've never heard of them and they don't seem to have a working website.
Apparently they function via Face Book.
 
Btw- the Wet Spot is the retail arm of their business. The larger part is the wholesale side. They buy imported etc. and sell to folks who retail the fish. The wholesale side supplies the retail operation.

Many years ago I bought fish from a seller who both imported and purchased wholesale including from the Wet Spot wholesale side. I have never bough fish from the retail side.
(edited for typos)
 
Last edited:
If for some reason I lived in the US, I would order from him, Wet Spot and Reheboth Aquatics, although Dan's carries fewer of the fish I really like. He's a good source, and the one time I had fish from him, they were difficult softwater species that adjusted rapidly to my soft water.
Dan was shipping to Canada but that is now on hold due to delays in delivery due to holdups in customs. If the customs delays can be solved he will start shipping to Canada again.
Dan's Fish said:

Where does Dan's Fish ship orders?​


United States: We ship to locations in the United States including Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. The final shipping cost will be shown in checkout.


Canada: UPDATE - We're pausing service to Canada until customs is able to determine the cause of their intermittent delays.
Please create an account and add a shipping address. Our system will verify that we can ship to your area. By default shipments will be sent Mondays.
All prices at DansFish.com are shown as USD. To see final shipping costs for your location please fill your cart and then open checkout. Shipping charges should include customs import duties/taxes. If there is cause for a refund it will be processed at the exchang rate at the time of the refund and you may get more or less than expected. Please contact us with questions or suggestions.
 
It's been years since I ordered from Rehoboth, and they were all good experiences. Do they still do a retail on-line business or are they wholesale only now? They have several interesting offerings including this killie, Chromaphyosemion pamaense, which you don't see every day. I don't even recall seeing it in AKA listings or on aquabid.


pamenese.png
 
The thing about this "fish will adjust to different parameters". I am sure they do to a degree.

But Byron went to great lengths educating about how we can't cheat evolution in terms of a fish's biolgocial/chemical needs (if evolution is the right word).

Mostly, if not entirely, there must be good reasons why there are parameter ranges in temperature, hardness and pH for fish.
 
Here's food for thought. When I had moderately hard water, I could keep probably 90% of the species I do now. But I couldn't breed them. For most rare fish, water hardness is incredibly important. There is no soft pedalling that.
And for old school hobbyists who aren't just consumers of fish but watchers of behaviour, breeding etc, it is crucial.

I didn't read Dan's (I have no loyalties - it's another country and I don't buy there) message as saying that fish adjust to anything. It read to me like a message to educated hobbyists that the fish would be okay if they transitioned to soft water. If you have hard water and don't use RO or something similar for some of those fish, you shouldn't be shopping at a dealer of rare rainforest fish.

As for buying if Dan's sells to Canada - in the tariff war that has been launched at us, that's not happening.
 
Here's food for thought. When I had moderately hard water, I could keep probably 90% of the species I do now. But I couldn't breed them. For most rare fish, water hardness is incredibly important. There is no soft pedalling that.
Beyond breeding did you notice any different in longevity or behavior of the fish over long period of time ?
 
I have always maintained that Dan sells for very expensive prices. Today I did a fly through his site and took a look at his pleco offerings in the Catfish section. He sells a couple of the fish which I have bred over the years. This includes Hypancistrus zebra, the L236 and Super White L236 both from the Budrovcan line as well as a few Super Red Bushynose. L236 has recently been identified along with several other L numbers as all being variants of Hypancistrus seideli.

I have been breeding these various plecos since May of 2006. Today I only have a single breeding group of the pretty rare Hypancistrus L173 remaining along with the last 13 Super White Budrovcan line 236 born in my tanks. For the past 3 years I have been on a path of divesting myself of all the rest due to advanced age.

I have taken great pride in the quality of the fish I sell and in their being in the best condition and health when sold. If you are interested in my history etc., you can do a Google search for my screen name and find out for yourself. Here is a bit of a headstart. See the 4th thread:
Fishaholics.org - The zebra pl*co saga

The prices I have charged for my fish are between 1/3 to 1.2 of what Dan charges for the ones he offers. I have sold everything from 1.5 inch to 4+ inch fish over the years. U have also sold as many as 85 fish in a single sale. I also did not sell my fish in ones and twos. Normally my minimum has been 5 or 6 of any given species. Further, if one was able to pick up the fish rather than having me ship them, I would discount the price per fish by 18-20%. I also would discount based on the size of an order.

I have never had a web site for doing sales nor I am not regstered on social media.so have not sold vian these either. Desprite that I am told I have an excellent reputation but have never seen this for myself. What I do know is people have been able to find me because of referrals and my presence on a few fish forums like Planet Catfish as well as several now defunt forums. I have also done room sales at the All Aquarium Catfish Conventions, in the vendor room of the annual NEC events. My my final event was the 2023 Keystone Clash. Being at such events was one of the ways people came to know me and the species I was fortunate to have spawning in my tanks.

Like Dan, I have had almost no DOAS, The few I did have were due to shipping delays and to an episode involving toxic fish bags. Chemical in Plastic Bags Lethal to Aquarium Fish (I corresponded with the lead researcher involved with discovering the cause of this problem.)

I have no issues with the quality of Dans fish. He has an excellent rep. in this regard. But, I do have a problem with his pricing. I also understand that he is business and sells many more species than I ever have. No matter where one buys their fish, what matters the most is that they receive healthy fish of high quality so that, as long as they are cared for properly, they should live long lives. I was never as much of a business as I was one who wanted to make my fish pay for themselves in the long run. I have had a weakness for the B&W Hypancistrus since I saw my first picture of a zebra pleco. in 2001 in the Baensch Aquarum Atlas. I also wanted to get my fish into the hands of other people who wanted to breed them.

I have bought more of my fish as imports or at wholesale prices or directly from breeders than I have on a retail basis. This has meant buying them in larger quantities- 25 - 300+ fish at one time. There has been one feature in commonwith all the pruchases. They were fish I wanted to keep for myself. So, if I did not sell them all I was perfectly happy to keep them for myself. All of this contributed to my being able to sell some of the same species as Dan and of similar quality but for a lot less money.

I do not fault anybody who buys from Dan as long as they are willing to pay what he charges. This is especially true when the species involved are difficult to find.
 
I can't answer the questions of longevity etc accurately, because I have improved my skills as an aquarist since I had harder water. So what causes increased longevity - the water or my practices?

If I had had access to the kind of soft water I have now, I would have probably had my rainforest fish for much longer with much more success. Understanding that and not listening to people who said the fish would adapt to my water was a big part of learning.

I now think that if you can breed a fish, you should. It isn't so much the longevity of individual fish that matters as the how long the species can thrive in your set up. Sharing them out, whether for money or networking matters. Buying fish and keeping them alive makes you a consumer. My moderately hard (140ppm) water allowed cardinals to live 5 years. I think that in my softwater, they will live longer than that. It'll take time for me to know.

I've kept I don't know how many generations of softwater Aphyosemion zygaima here. I'm at 33 years with them. They are longer lived in softwater, and much easier to breed.

People get antagonistic online, and we all write quickly. Saying what I interpret Dan's as saying, or saying that fish can live longish lives in the wrong water isn't saying that I'd do it by choice. We like straw man, unsophisticated analyses on forums, often because people don't read the full thread. It makes for better fights.

Keeping fish without breeding them is a lower level of fishkeeping, skills wise, compared to breeding them over generations. Keeping fish as ornamental creatures is limited, but if people didn't do it, fish wouldn't be available. That makes places like Dan's invaluable. We can't all track down breeders in small regions with our limited connections.
 
Keeping fish without breeding them is a lower level of fishkeeping, skills wise, compared to breeding them over generations. Keeping fish as ornamental creatures is limited, but if people didn't do it, fish wouldn't be available. That makes places like Dan's invaluable. We can't all track down breeders in small regions with our limited connections.
While i breed fishes my big concern is genetic diversification; i feel that after f3 or so new 'blood' should be added and that can be of course difficult with some of the species i keep and at the rate of extinction as habitat are lost or water becomes too warm is becoming alarming for those who care about nature's diversity.
 
Dans water is raw water from a natural creek in pristine Northern Wyoming that has NEVER been chlorinated . I think that makes all the difference in the world . I also agree with famed Killifish breeder Ed Warner , who writes in his book “Success With Killifish” that water parameters make no difference at all if you’ve acclimated new fish properly . Ed did it , Ed was successful , Ed’s right . ‘nuff said .
 
Dans water is raw water from a natural creek in pristine Northern Wyoming that has NEVER been chlorinated . I think that makes all the difference in the world . I also agree with famed Killifish breeder Ed Warner , who writes in his book “Success With Killifish” that water parameters make no difference at all if you’ve acclimated new fish properly . Ed did it , Ed was successful , Ed’s right . ‘nuff said .
Are you saying water hardness doesn’t matter for fishes well being if you slowly acclimate them to your municipal or well water? Or are you limiting your statement to killifish?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top