Great Low Budget Planted Tank - Really Need Help

Don't want to get into an argument on the costs of lo tec v hi tec really. thats not the argument here.

Quick answer - ferts may cost an amount for initial purchase. say £15. however on a low tech 200 you are gonna be using that £15 for 10 years. so say £1.50 a year.

Yeast CO2 can be used on larger tanks but needs more bottles. Say 4 bottles. User buys sugar 5kg at a time and bulk yeast so each bottle costs £0.50. 4 bottles a fortnight = £2 = £52 a year.

No extra lighting so no cost there.
Water changes are being used as garden watering instead of hosepipe/tap water so they cancel each other out.

That makes £53.50 a year. Work out how much the electricity costs per year for the filter, heater, lights any other gubbins. Add the fish food. That is far going to outweigh the £53.50.

To plant heavily in a 200 to a decent level is gonna cost more than or at least close to £53.50

Its not a huge uplift and £53.50 a year is by no way classed as a large cost. My kids' school seems to cost more than that for 'contributions' and charity 'sales drives' that seem to be back to back, week after week!!! OR buy 2 choccy bars less a week OR turn the fridge temperature from 3 to 2.5 etc. £53.50 is not much money when you think about it.

Saying that if it were my tank and I had worked out that yeast would cost me £53.50 a year I would buy pressurised. break even in 2 years on the equipment. 2Kg FE lasts a year so one more year to break even on that and after 3 years CO2 is costing £24 for the FE and therefore saving you £30 a year.

Glad you like the pink filter. You would have liked the pink rims too :) and maybe the pink and white gravel with crystal butterflies mixed in.
 
Most carpetting plants will also need a nutritious substrate

Nothing NEEDS a nutritious substrate. Everything needs nutrients. Where they get the nutrients from is the question. Nutritious substrates are mainly a back up for if you forget to dose the water column. Many people grow all sorts in setups with plain pea gravel including HC, glosso etc.

Absolutely correct, but in the context of the type of tank festo was discussing (low tech, few water changes), you're not going to want an aggressive dosing regime and so you'll want a nutritious substrate to give the carpetting plants a chance of any sort of decent growth.

PS. I think you should use pink filters in all your tanks :lol:
 
Most carpetting plants will also need a nutritious substrate

Nothing NEEDS a nutritious substrate. Everything needs nutrients. Where they get the nutrients from is the question. Nutritious substrates are mainly a back up for if you forget to dose the water column. Many people grow all sorts in setups with plain pea gravel including HC, glosso etc.

Absolutely correct, but in the context of the type of tank festo was discussing (low tech, few water changes), you're not going to want an aggressive dosing regime and so you'll want a nutritious substrate to give the carpetting plants a chance of any sort of decent growth.

PS. I think you should use pink filters in all your tanks :lol:

Agreed. Pink filters are a perfect fit for all your scapes...

Liz
 
What type of substrate would you reccomend?
and is it ok to cap it off with sand,
also what would you suggest to feed the plants and how often.
thanks.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top