Filter Problems

The December FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

KrystaK

Fish Addict
Joined
Jul 24, 2011
Messages
877
Reaction score
1
Location
CA
I have a 30 Gal tank with a Whisper Ex 45 filter (designed to take up to 45 gal) My tank is stocked with:
3 Honey Gourami
1 Zebra Danio
5 Panda Corys
1 BNP
Not a very good stock in my opinion; but thats for another thread.
I'm having trouble with my filter. Over the past 5 months or so, every time I turn the filter off to do a water change, some of the contents of the filter spew out into the tank. Both through the intake and the output depending on if I'm taking water from the tank or just turning the filter back on.
 
I went to a LFS in my area and asked the sales person in charge of filters and hardware about this, and he said that this happens to all filters, the best thing I can do is get some netting or pantyhose and put them over the intake or out put in hopes that this will catch all the debris. 
 
Why is it that for 6 months my filter was fine at holding it's contents but now it has become incontinent (for lack of a better word)? This is the only filter I've had this problem with, (and I've got three filters going at any one time)
 
I tried using pantyhose to catch the waste, but it is incredibly hard and dangerous to hold pantyhose over a filter out put and plugging it in. 
 
My tank looks gross, even with the pantyhose over the intake, 20 min after I do a water change there is waste all over the substrate as if I've done nothing. 
I am seriously considering getting another filter! Does anyone have any other suggestions before I go and buy a new filter?
 
(I added extra filter floss in the hopes this would catch extra debris, and it worked for the first two changes, but now that it has become saturated it makes no difference)
 
The stuff comes out of the intake tube when you turn it off? That is weird I have never had that problem. Can you just take the tube out of the water before turning it off? Shouldn't hurt the filter to do that. They also make a sponge that fits over the intake tube so babies don't get sucked up. That would stop the gunk and after you turn the filter back on, you can take it off and rinse it out.
 
Mine, gunk from the hose burps out of the return tube when I turn it back on. I don't worry about it cause the tank clears itself in an hour.
 
But are you turning the filter off every time you do a water change? If so can I ask why? I never do that. The only time I turn the filter off is when I clean it every month.
 
Well my filter is an off the back power filter so removing the intake from the water would mean taking the whole filter off the back of the tank.
 
As for turning it off every time, I do that because it's what I was told to do. I assume the filter can only suck up water until it gets so low, at which point it would be too much work and the filter would burn out.
That and I don't want to get shocked if it shorts. I had that happen with a heater so I don't like to take chances with electricity and water :p
 

Most reactions

Back
Top