IMO every freshwater tank should have an air pump. Are they NEEDED? No. Are they beneficial? Yes. They provide flow and very effective aeration. It may be rare, but I have seen air pumps alone save an entire tank of fish when the filter stopped working for various reasons (which definitely happens). Some people say this is too rare to even bring up, but obviously it has not happened to them so in their experience they are right, no tank needs one. But I have definitely seen it happen many times. Many fish like it anyways. For their cost they are more than worth it.
I always buy the largest, most are too weak IMO. I prefer the Azoo 9500 because on drsfostersmith where they are about $18, $13 when on sale. They are strong and quiet.