Will This Stocking Work For 10-Gallon?

[GuppyGoddess]

one female betta
one female guppy
two platy fish

If the four will work, is it better to get two female platies rather than males so they don't bug the female guppy?

 

[arobinson1984]

The betta is likely to attack the guppy due to the guppies long tail.

Andy

 

[GuppyGoddess]

The betta is likely to attack the guppy due to the guppies long tail.

Andy

Will she attack the platies? Before she was in with three Rasboras and didn't bother them. (And, yes, I know they move quickly, but she didn't even pay any attention to them except at feeding time. She's hand fed, so I'd feed her seperately while sprinkling food in on the other side for the rasboras.)

So, even female betta attack guppies because of their tails?