water beetles???

Magnum Man76 190

Fish Maniac
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
7,827
Reaction score
7,141
Points
113
Location
Southern MN
how destructive would they be in an aquarium??? I know there all kinds( some scary ) but I’m primarily thinking of the surface speedsters , could these be food, for something like my butterfly fish, maybe larval stages as a food… just really haven’t seen them discussed…
 
how destructive would they be in an aquarium??? I know there all kinds( some scary ) but I’m primarily thinking of the surface speedsters , could these be food, for something like my butterfly fish, maybe larval stages as a food… just really haven’t seen them discussed…
If you mean the small insects that move quickly across the water surface, they generally aren’t a major threat to a healthy aquarium. Most are opportunistic surface feeders and would likely be eaten quickly if a fish can reach them.


As food, they could provide some enrichment, but I wouldn’t intentionally introduce unknown insects into a reef tank. You could end up adding contaminants, pesticides, or species that reproduce faster than expected. If they show up naturally, your butterflyfish may treat them like live snacks, but I’d leave the population alone rather than trying to culture them in the tank.
 
I gave that a shot, and they didn't last. You'd be introducing them as a treat, not as a reproducing group. The surfaces of tanks are too small when there are fish predators. With Epiplatys killies, much smaller than your hungry Pantodon, they were gone in a minute, in a 4 foot 75.

Many diving beetles are fish predators.

As food, they could provide some enrichment, but I wouldn’t intentionally introduce unknown insects into a reef tank. You could end up adding contaminants, pesticides, or species that reproduce faster than expected. If they show up naturally, your butterflyfish may treat them like live snacks, but I’d leave the population alone rather than trying to culture them in the tank.

This isn't a reef tank situation. I regularly add insects from outside to my tanks, depending on the tank and the species. It takes a little research (a few minutes) when you meet a new one, but this is what my fish eat in the wild. I favour insectivorous fish. Mosquito, midge and fly larvae, ant eggs and larvae, swatted bugs, daphnia, cyclops - it's all great stuff. I avoid the predacious diving beetles and dragonfly larvae, although small dragon fly species have reached maturity unseen and unharmful in tanks here. I don't know if I accidentally introduced them or if they got in and laid eggs.

If you are in an urban centre or in a weird lawn mad suburb, then pesticides could be an issue. Otherwise, it's unlikely. At times of the year, insects are the staple here, allowing me to avoid processed fish foods. But the dream of a tank where insect species sustain themselves in the presence of a predatory fish species is just a dream. Tanks are too small and fish are just too good at their work.

Pantodon are large mouthed, and you could probably culture grubs used in the reptile hobby. They're too big for my fish, although I culture wingless fruit flies and white worms for my tanks. The aquarium are in an outbuilding 50 metres from the house, or my wife would kill me dead for all this!
 
who knew????


videos of them in a tank, but seems there are businesses out there shipping live bugs… a part of the hobby I never really knew existed…
 
ok… these were the ones I was thinking about, however they can and do fly , so sounds like death to me from the mrs. if they were introduced in the house…

 
Last edited:
If the bugs take wing, I'd suggest jumping into the pen with that bull you have on your farm. It's probably safer than staying in a house with a non fishkeeping partner. People can be so narrow minded about little things like swarms of fish food. ;)
 
these would seem to be more interesting in my native fish tank outside… maybe the spotted sunfish if / when they finally get here would eat them, and with the full tight cover, would be contained… might have to look at what it would take to raise them seasonally “outside”
 

Most reactions

Back
Top