Waht Type Of Fish Should I Use?

April FOTM Photo Contest Starts Now!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to enter! 🏆

nick66

New Member
Joined
Feb 7, 2007
Messages
9
Reaction score
0
I was just wondering what kind of fish i should use to clean debris in my tank. My tank is 35 gallons and is brackish i was thinking about a pleco but i heard that the brackish water can kill plecos. So that would not be good! Also i was thinking of algea eaters or cory cats. Which one or ones would you pick or are there any others that you would recommend for me since i have brackish water. If you could tell me that would be great thank you for helping! :good:
 
Please do not do Pleco's, I put a little salt in one of my tanks to cure some ich, woke up the next day and my $35.00 pleco was dead.
 
Corys are very sensative to salt and would probably die quickly. In a brackish tank you havent got much choice.
 
Please do not do Pleco's, I put a little salt in one of my tanks to cure some ich, woke up the next day and my $35.00 pleco was dead.


i do not think it was the salt that killed your pleco overnight.


Some plecos inhabit brackish water in nature even.
 
Ive had luck with ghost shrimp. I didn't think they could acclimate to brackish. But, I put 2 in as feeders for my puffers. Apparently the puffers didn't find them to appetizing and just let them be. They were in there about 2 wks - then, I went on vacay for a week and well, I think the puffs finally got hungry!!
Either way they are really cheap 12/$1.50 so if it doesn't work, you aren't out alot of money. Give it a go if you can.
 
Olive Nerite snails are excellent for algae eating and cleaning up, will tolerate anything from freshwater to full marine. You can get them @ Arizona Aquatic Gardens. Some Palaeomonetes speies (Ghost Shrimp) will tolerate brackish water but it's a crap-shoot finding the correct species. Amano shrimp would also make a good cleaner but only if the SG is 1.005 or lower.

As for plecos, there are 3 brackish species: Hypostomus ventromaculatus, Hypostomus watwata and Hypostomus plecostomus. However, these plecos are not traded and you won't find them at a LFS, online or anywhere. Brackish Water Catfish.
 
Just to echo AMS's comment above with a warning: the name "Hypostomus plecostomus" is often used in aquarium books and fish stores for the common plec --- but this isn't the correct species name. The common plec in the hobby can be anything really but is usually something like Pterygoplichthys multiradiatus or Pterygoplichthys pardalis.

Other brackish water algae eaters include mollies, Florida flagfish, and violet gobies. In fact most non-predatory brackish water livebearers and killifish eat a lot of algae, so buying any of them will be helpful. Mollies in particular will do a very good job of eating filamentous algae. Stiphodon gobies are prodigous algae eaters, but they aren't easy to keep.

It's worth mentioning that, contrary to popular belief, you DON"T NEED scavangers. Adding any fish, even a scavenger, reduces water quality by adding biological loading. It is ALWAYS better to clean a tank by siphoning out waste on sight. If you don't want to do a water change while doing this, simply pour the water back into the tank through an aquarium net, and you'll remove solid waste very effectively. I do this in a tank containing a wood eating catfish who produces masses of wood chippings every day, but I can't afford to change the water every time because the soft water used is rainwater, and sometimes the rainwater butt is empty!

Cheers, Neale
 
brackish water nerite snails are available and are brilliant at eating algea
 

Most reactions

Back
Top