unusual fish you have had good luck keeping???

Magnum Man82 196

Fish Maniac
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
7,859
Reaction score
7,193
Points
113
Location
Southern MN
they don’t have to breed for you, just curious of some of the not seen everyday in the hobby fish, that have worked out well for you… sometimes it finding just the right set up, or tank mates, sometimes they are just easy to care for, but for some reason just aren’t seen in the hobby often…

one of my most unusual, and long lived fish, are my blood cap tetras ( Bathyaethiops breuseghemi ) they are an African tetra, that have. been easy to care for, are long lived ( mine have been here for at least 3 years, with no losses from the original group )

I’m optimistic about the spot tail algae eaters (
Crossocheilus reticulatus ) mine are babies yet, but seem to be a great fish, as playful, and curious as a panda garra, and are eating algae as good as any of the common algae eaters…

how about you???
 
L173, very rare. I have a wild caught breeding group which is even more rare.

IMG_0565.webp


IMG_0569.webp


A highly variable fish. Ideally they have the zig zag stripes and golden eyes. They are difficult to ID when younger and smaller and early one thought to be a wavy lined zebra. But they grow much larger and zebras have more black eyes often with a bit of blue color around the pupil. They take clearely longer to reach maturity (and breeding) than zebras. 173 is a slower grower than zebras of L236 which is now a part of the H. seideli complex. 236 breeds much sooner than either zebra or 173 and 236 if faster to breed than either. 236 mostly also have the goeld eyes but some do not.

I have kept and had breed all 3 species. Today, as a result of my downsing, the only Hypancisrtrus group I still have are the173. I should mention O have also kept and worked with the L173b which I do not believe are true 173. My 173b came from Aquarium Glaser and I got them before I had the opportunity to get the true WC 173. I initially was sent the group from the person who owned them to try to get them spawning. I did not own the group at that time but the deal was, if they spawned, the owner and I would split the offspring.

I was successful after some advice about my zebra group from Ingo Seidel and Dale Ernst at the 2016 semi-annual Catfish Convention outside of Washington DC in Herndon, VA. I came home from the event with a container of the Repashy Spawn & Grow. I ultimately bought the group as well as all of the first spawn.

At the start of my adeventures with the 173 I posted this first thread about it on Planetcatfish here if anybody is interested https://www.planetcatfish.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=5&t=42699

Here is a the part of the vid shot by Rachel O'Leary of the 173 fry when she came here for a visit. It is not hosted on Youtube. Rachel still has the full visit vid on her site.
https://www.smugmug.com/app/library?mediaType=Video&imageKey=9zhgqpd
 
My LFS used to occasionally carry peacock eels, which I purchased for my 29-gallon tank. They all eventually passed away, but during their time in my tank, they were some of the most interesting and wholesome fish to watch. I remember them always sticking together and curling around each other without ever getting into physical conflict like my ropefish. I am now awaiting the peacock eels return to the store, as I've recently "remodeled" my tank to be more suitable for species like them.

During May-June, I decided to try my hand at owning a L239 Blue Panaque Pleco again. My first of this species only survived a week, while the second survived a month. I have been in luck, as this specimen, a beautiful, young adult male with a striking color, has been thriving for at least four months! I am very grateful for this, especially so regarding my process of trial and error with plecos...
 
Once you figure out how to keep them, and it becomes relatively easy, they all become usual fish (for you).

What makes a fish unusual to me is when it's hard to get hold of. That's about 75% of the species we could keep in aquaria. If I compare what was readily available in the larger hobby of say 2000, compared to what we can get now... most really cool aquarium fish have become very unusual.

If you get an unusual arrival and don't breed it to share it out, it just lives and dies at your place without being available. That's a shame. I've had a number of one off importation fish I bred or couldn't breed. In most cases, they weren't harder to keep than other fish - it was just that the collecting or distribution network overlooked their habitats, as they might be the only desirable aquarium species there. Fishermen want to get 5 or 10 species on a trip - not one.

A lot of fish become unusual because the distances involved in bringing them to market is too expensive to work with. A tetra that has to be caught, transported by canoe, carried to a small plane, flown to a facility with a truck ride from the airport, shipped to a richer country, shipped to a store and bought online - the transport costs are going to make it rare or simply not worth importing.
 
Probably my favorite wierdos at the moment are Nemacheilus corica (Himalayan sand loaches). I've also enjoyed panda garra, scarlet badis, plains killifish, and probably a lot of others I can't remember at the moment.
 
I was lucky enough to show up at my LFS after a delivery of fresh water pipe fish.
maf0ch4-jpg.615484

^ this was them upon arrival to my fish room.^
aurnahi-jpg.615500

^I kept them in a 20 gallon tall tank with pothos roots for the perfect camo and comfort.^
6geb4il-jpg.615505

^ They really blended in well^
mk9nzjy-jpg.615503

wswgdnjl-jpg.616941

^ at one point one was carrying eggs^
They shared the tank with halfbeaks that stayed at the surface and enjoyed BBS daily for most of their food.
Never got any fry.
Never seen them again at my LFS.
My LFS will order from Wetspot/cichlid exchange so they do get a decent selection.
 
I was lucky enough to show up at my LFS after a delivery of fresh water pipe fish.
maf0ch4-jpg.615484

^ this was them upon arrival to my fish room.^
aurnahi-jpg.615500

^I kept them in a 20 gallon tall tank with pothos roots for the perfect camo and comfort.^
6geb4il-jpg.615505

^ They really blended in well^
mk9nzjy-jpg.615503

wswgdnjl-jpg.616941

^ at one point one was carrying eggs^
They shared the tank with halfbeaks that stayed at the surface and enjoyed BBS daily for most of their food.
Never got any fry.
Never seen them again at my LFS.
My LFS will order from Wetspot/cichlid exchange so they do get a decent selection.
Those are amazing little fish. Are they pretty sedentary?

I've tried to get my pet store to start ordering from TWS. They won't do it. :(
 
Those are amazing little fish. Are they pretty sedentary?

I've tried to get my pet store to start ordering from TWS. They won't do it. :(
They liked to hang in the roots and spent sometime resting on bottom.
They were more active then I thought they would have been.
Like the halfbeaks I kept with them just mid to bottom mostly.
6zrr4q3-jpg.615487

o4fymid-jpg.615485

^ the half beaks I kept with the pipes. They were albino and pretty cool also.^
 
We caught freshwater pipefish in a couple of places, and they are amazing. I didn't keep any because we never caught many.
Gary, have you ever found and/or kept Enteromius jae? I'm looking at those as an alternative to the various congo tetras if I ever do a West African tank. They are more interesting looking and I suspect a big school would fit better in a 30 gallon setup.
 
I have kept Enteromius jae, in several forms. My suspicion is I've kept several different species. I've even been in a habitat, though I didn't catch any. My travel companion did.

First - too small to be community fish.
Second - too fantastic not to keep in their own tank.

Soft acidic water kept cool. The habitat was dark at noon. If you stepped out into the slash in the rainforest that was the narrow road, you were blinded. In the forest, it was like just after sundown in a temperate region. The water was far cooler than the air. It was shallow - a stream about 3-4 foot wide and a foot or so deep, very stained by tannins.

My first group, from Cameroon, ran for years. They bred in a tank with a lot of peat on the bottom and very little light. Some java moss. The Gabonese ones were all males, which kind of wrecked the idea of breeding. At first, I thought there was one female, but alas...

I bought some early this year, but they wiped out after shipping.

Here is a photo I've shared before, of the more common Cameroon fish. Picture one.

I would also consider another probably complex of related species still under one name - Enteromius hulstaerti. It's a micro-barb, and really nice. This is a "cf" hulstaerti photo from my last lot. It varied from the usual markings enough I wasn't sure.
 

Attachments

  • byejae1 (640x427).webp
    byejae1 (640x427).webp
    30.1 KB · Views: 8
  • cf hulstaerti3aa.webp
    cf hulstaerti3aa.webp
    107.4 KB · Views: 9

unusual fish you have had good luck keeping???​

That would be Danionella translucida. This small transparent cyprinid fish from Myanmar is very rare overhere. Not as easy to keep. You really give it a real good thinking about how to set up the interior of your tank to be able to see them. They tend to make a certain noise. They start doing it when hitting a certain age. When they were young, I never heard them. And mostly, they produce noise when it's getting dark from what I've noticed. It's not an agitating noise, btw. It's species that should be left alone. I mean, feeding and a water change is all you need to do. Don't bother them too much.
655751728_2775281826156225_7234860114669178076_n.webpIMG_9375.webp
 

Most reactions

Back
Top