Seachem Onyx Sand versus Flourite

The June FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Bloo

~ I learn something new ~ ~~~~ every day ~~~~
Joined
Mar 31, 2005
Messages
9,085
Reaction score
1
Location
Norfolk, UK
I'm thinking of changing over to something like Flourite in my one tank but just have a couple of questions.

What colour is it ?

How good will this be for my "burrowing" fish such as flounders or Kuhli's ?

But my main question is: Is the Onyx Sand(I like the dark colour) really just as good (for the plants) as the Flourite Red ?
 
Hiya Bloozoo

There are 2 types of Seachem Flourite, one is a mixed colour with the emphasis being on a dark reddish earthy colour, and the other is a plain dark reddish earthy colour (sorry best way i can explain it) so 1 is mixed and the other is all one colour, both are very nice colours IMO, in all respects they look like ordinary gravel that you would put in a tank except a nicer colour.

Here are some pics

Red Flourite (its a bit lighter when washed and in a tank but still darkish earthy red)

red flourite

Normal Flourite

normal flourite

The normal flourite as it would look in a tank

tank pic

So those are the flourites, i dont know how they would be for some of your burrowing fish as they as they are in most respects just like normal gravel.

I dont know much about the Onyx sand, so i double checked on another plant site that i visit to see what other more expert ophinions would be on it (i just read some previous posts in a search)

So here are my findings

It is a dark grey in colour when submerged in water, it will buffer your water, it will raise your Ph because of the carbonate content in it, usually by 0.5.

Most people thought the FE or iron content was better in flourite.

But most who had used it would use an alternative product called Eco Complete if they were to do it again, now these are not my ophinions, just my little bit of market research.

Eco complete is another product you should probably consider, its widely used in the planted world, and its highly thought of, its a very good substrate, its black in colour and would be the nearest to sand you could get as a proper planted substrate.

Heres alink for it

Aquatics Online Eco complete

I couldnt find a pic for it easily, but it looks like a black sand and looks really cool if the background of the tank is also black, it makes the plants and fish really stand out against the black.

Edit: Sugar........i forgot the pics wouldnt show up........but the links still work
 
Wow that's a fantastic reply Zig - and of much help !

Now it's time for decisions decisions -_-


I need to ponder a bit..... then I'll report back :D
 

Most reactions

Back
Top