Rethinking my plans

Rusty_Shackleford

Fish Crazy
Joined
Jan 6, 2019
Messages
264
Reaction score
531
My initial plan was to stock my tank with about 12 Hyphessobrycon pulchripinnis (lemon tetra) and 12 Carnegiella strigata (marble Hatchetfish). However after doing more research I'm rethinking things.

I think the tetras and hatchets would like it warmer and more acidic than the current resident Laetacara dorsigera would like. I would still like to keep a couple different species of tetra, so I'm concentrating on fishes endemic to the Rio Paraguay where the Laetacara dorsigera are found.
I've been reading a lot here, as well as other sites.

It seems there is a good number of contender tetras.

Aphyocharax natteri - Dawn/Panda Tetra, it seems somewhat rare in the hobby and probably pricey.
Aphyocharax rathbuni - Green Fire Tetra, this is definitely in consideration, a big school would look nice against the Black background, but I'm worried the green won't stand out amongst all the plants.
Hemigrammus lunatus - probably not in the hobby, of it is it's expensive.
Hyphessobrycon elachys = Veilfin/Reed Tetra, smaller tetra, but kind of plain of a plain Jane fish.
Megalamphodus eques - Serpae tetra, colorful tetra but with a reputation as a fin nipper.
Hyphessobrycon herbertaxelrodi - Black Neon Tetra, hobbyist staple, I've kept them before, not sure how it would stand out against the black background.
Megalamphodus megalopterus - Black Phantom Tetra, I've always liked these, and the red phantom cousin, again not sure if they would look good against the black background.
Moenkhausia sanctaefilomenae - Red Eye Tetra, pretty common hobby staple, the silver body would stand out, but they are a pretty.active tetra, I'm not sure the tank is big enough for a decent school. Plus they are nippers as well.
Pyrrhulina australis - No common names, seems rare in the hobby.
Serrapinnus kriegi - Krieg's Mini Tetra, small nanoish fish, seems rare in the hobby.

I have been searching vendors and found one that may work. However many of these fish are sold in lots of 8. I personally don't like that as it limits me. My initial thought is 16 Green Fire Tetras and 8 Serpae Tetras.
Is 8 enough to keep the aggression down in the Serpae? Should I just go with 24 Green Fire? I would actually like no more than 10 serpae, but I can't do that buying in lots of 8. One thing I don't want to do is have two members of the same genus. I would think they would be too closely related and would lead to aggression and possibly hybrid tetras.
Any thoughts guys and gals?
 
Every tank of Serpaes I've ever seen, regardless of number, contained fish with battered fins.

I think your concern about colors popping on the Megalamphodus and Aphyocharax might be unfounded. The sparkle on both species will stand out, I'm sure.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top