Platies And Mollies

llamalord305

Fishaholic
Joined
Jun 11, 2007
Messages
436
Reaction score
0
Location
Miami, Florida, U.S.
I may sound dense, but I need to know. I was planning to get mollies and platies and I wondered, whats the difference? When I found that mollies do much better in brackish, I decided against them. (I'm getting tetras) Do platies still need salt? Thanks in advance.
 
Platies don't need salt, only mollies. They should be fine with thteras, but The tetras might eat the fry...
 
Ahh, interesting. I think what ill do is half stock my tank with everything but mollies, and add a bit of salt to see if the other fish tolerate it. Thanks for the replies.
 
Your mollies are quite particular about the quality of their water and are not as easy as platies. They do not need salt but a good hard water with a pH of at least 7.5 is a must. If you use some sea salt, like you would use for a reef tank, it will raise the pH like that and provide added mineral content to the water. For people with soft water, it is one way to give the fish what they need and leads to stories about how mollies always die so easily without salt. I must assume people spreading these stories live in soft water locations. I run my mollies with absolutely zero added salt and they thrive, but my tap water is moderately hard, over 10 degrees, and has a pH of 7.8. Platies are not only a different species but a different genus, they are Xiphophorus sp. while mollies are Poecilia sp. Common platies and common mollies are both hybrids within the Xiphophorus and Poecilia genuses (geni?) but are from unrelated groups entirely. The platy family includes swordtails so a mix with swordtails can produce cross breeding as Betta Boy said. The mollies can theoretically cross with guppies but I have kept them together and never seen such a cross.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top