Moss Ball And Cycling?

The June FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

Rexenator

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Mar 11, 2014
Messages
73
Reaction score
0
Location
US
Hi everyone,
 
I have a 46 gallon bowfront, with a Fluval 306 canister filter that I recently cycled fishless by adding ammonia (started cycling two weeks ago).  I used most of the substrate from my previous 20 gallon tank, along with Tetra Safe Start to get the cycle going faster.  I tested the water frequently using an API master kit (not test strips).  The tank started at about 4ppm of ammonia, no nitrites and no nitrates as expected.  Water temps are between 68-70, pH hovers around 7.9 (using a digital pH meter, still trying to get this to drop a little).
 
Two days later, almost overnight really, I tested the water again and it showed no ammonia, no nitrates and 10 ppm nitrates.  I performed a 20% water change, and added one small black moor, and 3 dojo loaches and a gigantic moss ball from my previous tank (it had been soaking in a bucket of the old aquarium water) a few days later.  I also have some plants that I put in the tank before I started the cycling process.  I read online that moss balls are able to remove some nitrates from the tank water, but how much are they capable of removing?
 
The reason I ask is because now my tank reads no ammonia, no nitrites, and no nitrates, and has been consistently been showing this for about 4 days.  Occasionally I will see the nitrates between zero and 5ppm (faintly orange, but mostly yellow on the test kit), but it has not recovered to the pre-fish level.  As a matter of fact, one morning I tested the water and nitrates were at 10ppm, that evening they read 0ppm (no water change).  On my few previous tanks, the nitrates would settle to 10-20 ppm after cycling, but I didn't have any moss balls in those tanks.  The fish are doing fine, so I won't do anything unless the ammonia/nitrites spike for some reason.  Have I done something to affect the cycling process, or is this moss ball capable of removing the nitrates in my tank?  Thanks!
 
 
 
Moss balls are able to eat nitrates indeed. And the fact that you have so little fish, well.. yep.
 
Are you shaking the living daylights out of your Nitrate solution #2? If not, you may have nitrates and the test isn't showing them.
 
That bottle has solids in solution and they drop out of the liquid very quickly, so unless you've agitated it til your arms fall off you may not be getting a true reading.
 
Gruntle said:
Are you shaking the living daylights out of your Nitrate solution #2? If not, you may have nitrates and the test isn't showing them.
 
That bottle has solids in solution and they drop out of the liquid very quickly, so unless you've agitated it til your arms fall off you may not be getting a true reading.
Yeah, I add the 10 drops of bottle one, shake hard for 30 seconds, add 10 drops of bottle two, shake hard for a minute.  I'm just going to assume its because I don't have many fish in the tank.  Thanks!
 
It's not clear from what you said - do you give bottle 2 a very good shake before you add the drops to the tube or do you add drops from bottle 1, shake the tube then add drops from bottle 2 and shake the tube again?
 
essjay said:
It's not clear from what you said - do you give bottle 2 a very good shake before you add the drops to the tube or do you add drops from bottle 1, shake the tube then add drops from bottle 2 and shake the tube again?
Sorry, I shake both bottles first, then add drops from 1, shake the tube, then add drops from 2, then shake the tube.
 
Actually, I just tested the water, shook the hell out of the bottles (I was only shaking for a few seconds previously, this time I went all out) and just got a reading somewhere between 5 and 10 ppm on nitrates.  So either I wasn't shaking enough, or the nitrates are just building up slower in this tank than I expected.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top