Ok I have a 20 gal planted already set up with *sunset* or *sunburst* platy in it and it's been running for about 2 years...All is well and doing fine..But I am getting ready to remodel my bedroom and would love to have a larger tank set up in there. This will be a new tank and I am very excited about it. I'm thinking about a planted 40gal. I want it to look kinda "Dark Woods" feel to it and this tank would be the showpiece of the room. What would you recommend for stocking this tank..just wanting to bounce some ideas around. I know I want to have platy in the tank (cause I love them) but what else would you recommend and how many and could you recommend a type of plant for a tall tank.
This question is asked so often, and it's so difficult to answer, because everyone has their own likes and dislikes.
Clearly you're a livebearer fan, since you've posted in the livebearer section, so one suggestion would be other livebearers. But then you'd probably want some bottom feeders (Cories, small plecs, hillstream loaches) as well, maybe some invertebrates. Maybe you'd fancy something else like a dwarf cichlid, or tetras, or a siamese fighting fish, or....... There are so many options, really the question you've asked is too open-ended.
Use it as an excuse to go window shopping at your LFS(s) - write down the names of the fish that you like the look of, then come back to the forum. There are so many experts on stocking and compatibility that you'll get lots of excellent feedback. I suggest you post in the Tropical Discussion section.
Equally on the plants, there are several which grow nice and tall. Vallis is excellent in this respect, because it grows tall, but is easy to maintain.
Hope this helps.