long term gradual demise of schooling fish in a healthy tank???

Magnum Man79 194

Fish Maniac
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
7,838
Reaction score
7,162
Points
113
Location
Southern MN
so, in my south American tetra tank, most fish are thriving, however my schools of cardinals, and rummy noses, slowly grow smaller, and have to be restocked once a year or so, they aren’t noticeably dying off, but gradually one by one, yet the other fish populations remain stable, and on my cardinals I have one old timer who is larger, and lived through 2 schools of gradual die offs… I love both of these species , and can’t figure out why the schools can’t be maintained… this last group of rummy’s has been lasting longer, but the cardinals have been dying off more rapidly…
my goal here, was as I retired, was to slow down on ordering fish, but seems if I want to maintain a species like the cardinals, I’m going to need to resupply every 10 to 12 months, and it’s strange I have the one, that had been in this tank for around 4 years…
thoughts???
 
Last edited:
old timer ( middle of this picture ) still doing well, while there are only 4 left of the dozen, that I added 5-6 months ago…
IMG_0178.webp


Google was no help…
 
I had something similar with recline barbs. I had a really big one which was the lone survivor from a previous group. I put in a new group and it was the Alpha. It was in the tank when I got the eggs and fry, He died this summer along with one of the offspring that had survived and grown to a decent size.

One of things I have learned over the years is that people and tropical fish have a lot in common. We both can and do die from heart attacks and strokes. Some of us die young while other live well beyond expectations. had an aunt who die at 101. And I have a few fish that lasted in the way you describe.

(edited to put the d in redline and a space in Ihave)
 
Last edited:
When fish are "adult size" when acquired it's almost impossible to guess longevity. That's why I like to buy smaller younger fish in person when possible. I know it's not always, especially where you live, Magnum.

We do the best we can, but your hard water may have a negative impact on what are usually softer water fish...& little schoolers often don't live long no matter. Your cardinals & tank look very healthy. How are your other tetras doing in there?
 
… this is RO water, because my well water is so hard, it’s the only way I can keep anything besides rift lake cichlids, so I have a commercial sized RO unit, and a 100 gallon holding tank, for use with all my soft water fish, I’m pretty able to match their native water, or at least way closer than most aquarists…
 
Yep…..every year I have to add some Cardinals to my current shoal of 30 or so.:fish: One passes here and there throughout the year. I do have QT them seriously as I don’t want to introduce something to the current crew. Nothing like a large group of these guys swimming about in a 33g long tank. :nod:
IMG_2308.webpIMG_1894.webp
 
I have no idea how many cardinals I lose. I always tell people I have 60ish in my 200l tank and I top up when it gets below 30-40 (2-4 years). But then I mess it up because when I buy other fish (which doesn't happen every year ;) ) I usually add 10-20 cardinals as the shipping is already paid. The tank has a lot of plants so in reality I don't really have an accurate count. At 60 (which is where I started) the tank looks quite busy. When it starts to look emptyish I top up. I do have some monsters in there though. I last bought fish for another tank in May 25 and did not feel the need to add any cardinals then. The tank is not too busy now but I still don't feel the need to add any.
Edit: Forgot to mention I use RO water with nothing added.
 
Last edited:

Most reactions

Back
Top