Ideal Plants For Bettas?

LilyRose Tank

Fish Herder
Joined
Dec 27, 2009
Messages
1,366
Reaction score
0
Location
GB
Hello all, As I have been advised not to use plastic plants, what plants would you recommend....silk ones too....which "plants" silk or real do your Bettas seem to love, photos plz, I remember the look rather than the latin name plz xxxx
 
stuff2987954.jpg


Ok so the stuff growing on the wood in the mid left is JAVA MOSS. Very very easy to grow. Just tie it to wood or rocks with fine fishing line, and leave it alone. It does absolutely fine under basic light, requires nothing special.

The shortish ones in the far right and left are ECHINODORUS, again, very easy to grow under bog standard light.

The bog brush looking fluffy plant in front of the filter on the left of the moss is CABOMBA. I always reccomend this to beginners because it's cheap and easy. It's usually sold as a bunch of stem cuttings ( no roots basically ) most places sell a pretty good sized bunch for your money and for around £10 you can really fill up some space in a typical 5 gal tank. You simply remove the bottom couple of pairs of leaves, and plant the stems in pairs or trios, about an inch apart between each clump. Roots will form and the plant grows quite long/tall. You will need to trim it as it reaches the surface, but since this one usually puts off side roots, just poinch it off slightly below a side root, remove the bottom leaves as before and plant in a bare space or transfer to any other tanks you may want to plant.


The short broad one in front of the coconut cave is a CRYPTOCORYNE. Another easy one that does fine in low/normal light. These are good for ground cover so you could actually carpet the tank floor in them if you plant carefully.

The long grassy stringy stuff you can just see nar the coconut cave is HAIRGRASS. Just plant the clumps and trim occasionally. I need more of that actually but my LFS has run out for the moment so I'll have to wait.

The round green balls are MOSS BALLS. They are not actually a moss at all, but a form of algae. But this type will not spread to anything or cause more algae, it just stays in a ball. When you first put them in they will float , but by the end of the week they will have sunk to the bottom where they'll happily sit. Very slow growing and the only thing you'll need to do is give them an ocasional rinse in your bucket of tankwater when doing a water change, just to get any bits off. Shrimp really love to pick bits of food and biofilm from the surface of these so if you do have shrimp or plan to, they are a good plant to get.


There are a fair few who wll insist you need all sorts of added ferts, CO2 ect ect to make plants grow well which is absolutely NOT the case. I've yet to ever use ferts in any of my tanks, and my plants have flowered and also produced plantlets ect. Certainly there are quite a few plants which do require high light and ferts and CO2, but the ones I have and the ones shown here in Bronson's tank do NOT require these things and are extremeley easy to care for.

The only real tip I will give you if you want basic live plants to get off to a good start when you first add them, is to buy a bag of basic cheap pond soil. ( you will need to start with a bare tank or empty the one you have and start again for this )

Spread a thin layer, around half a centimetre of soil on the bottom of the tank, then top with 2 inches of fine gravel or sand before filling ( carefully!!! ) and planting. I've found this to work excellently in my tanks.

Bettas LOVE plants, the more the better . They come from heavily planted waters in the wild so really fill your tank don't just have 2 or 3 plants. That's a huge mistake many people make and then wonder why their fish is not happy in a 5 gal+ tank ( and most of them subsequently put the fish back into a 2-3 gallon deathtrap ) . They like space, they simply dislike OPEN space. :good:

I still haven't finished planting this tank here !!!!
 
Thankyou for your wonderful reply, very informative...I shall give it some thought now, I shall wait for the tank to cycle and then set it up as you suggest, although should I do it before cycling the tank so the plants have time to root? I shall have to think hard as I filled this tank with plants, they died ( all except 3, 1 of which looks like it going too) and bought 50 pounds woth of plastic ones and if I gotta start again my bank manager ( myhubby) may not agree the next loan....lol
 
excellent suggestions for some wonderfully easy betta plants! however, i would not add any plants until the cycle is over. reason being is that with all the excess ammonia in the tank (more than the plants can use) you will most likely be looking at some sort of algae infestation. better to wait for the sake of the plants.
in the meantime do some searching for nice plants in your area and plan out how youd like to plant them :)
cheers
 
It's a pity you bought such a lot of plastic plants, perhaps sell them on ebay to claim a little of your money back?

If you have false plants always go for silk. They not only have no sharp bits but also look more natural.

As for the live plants, the ones I mention really are so easy to grow. I have mine in that tank under a basic 15 watt aquarium light. The tank is 12 gals.


If you do want to try live rooted plants again, Just start with a dry tank, do the soil topped with fine gravel or sand as I describe there, cycle your tank and then add your plants after it's cycled. Then add your fish ( a good way to do this is to get one of those guppy breeding nets and keep him in there for up to a week or so to let him get used to the tank, works very well IME )



If you wanted, you could do a mixture of live and silk plants to ease you back into things? And this way you wouldn't need the soil mixture . You could get some large tall silk plants ( lots of them ) to fill out the back and sides, and for the live plants you could have Java moss tied to some smooth bogwood, and a load of moss balls to roll around the bottom . The moss and the moss balls are the two easiest plants out of all the ones I have previously mentioned, and pretty much two of the absolute easiest and hardest to kill plants you could buy.
 
Just bought a whole stash of silk plants for the Aqua One Plant Life range. It was between £7 and £12 for a set of four, with the cheape sets having smaller plants and the more expensive sets having taller plants. Lovely range of greens and reds and they look really, really good. So pleased with them! I got 6 sets and spent about £60 for 24 plants.

Could have got 10-12 plant sets for £10-£20 but they didn't look half as nice. Saw some stunning silks as part of the new Biorb range but they were about £6-£9 per plant . . .

Got all of mine on Ebay. Type in "silk plant" and get browsing.

Will show photos once they are in the tanks (only arrived today)

Honeythorn - I totally respect the fact that you prefer 5+ gallon tanks for bettas. I really do. In fact, as soon as Matthew and I are living on our own without pesky housemates all the bettas are getting 6 gallon Clear Seal tanks each. However, I think it's totally over the top to imply that a 3 gallon tank is a death trap. It may not be ideal but if the water quality is properly managed, it is adequately planted and the owner knows the basic care requirements that bettas have then there is no reason why 2 or 3 gallons will kill the fish. Apart from anything else, it is factually inaccurate. It's just a little upsetting to be told that my divided tanks will be the death of my boys. They are all warm and in totally clean water, have a very well rounded diet and have between 15 and 28 litres each.
 
Your oversensitivity is not my problem. I can't stop you keeping them in such tanks and if it's working at the moment then it's working. The fact that it's working doesn't change my opinion of it's poor size. You don't have to care for my opinion of your chosen tanks.

And my opinion will not change no matter how well kept a 3 gallon is. I have always and will always believe tanks below 5 gals to be completely spatially inadequate for fish ,and over the years I've been on forums I have seen too many tanks that size and under go wrong even with good care. I also never stated it to be a fact that 3 gals will kill a betta , I name small tanks as deathtraps because their small size greatly enhances the chances of things going badly wrong even in good care not to mention the sheer lack of swimming space.

I often wonder if anyone here has even considered the concept of not taking words quite so literally and using common sense.

I'm hardly going to congratulate anyone on keeping a fish in a tank size I have always considered highly unsuitable for a permanent home. And since your tanks are not permanent and well kept there's a drastically reduced chance of things going wrong ( as you say you will be upgrading them to 6 gals )

It's small tanks for a permanent home I have a problem with, as a temproary measure and good care they work just fine.
 
Your oversensitivity is not my problem. I can't stop you keeping them in such tanks and if it's working at the moment then it's working. The fact that it's working doesn't change my opinion of it's poor size. You don't have to care for my opinion of your chosen tanks.

And my opinion will not change no matter how well kept a 3 gallon is. I have always and will always believe tanks below 5 gals to be completely spatially inadequate for fish ,and over the years I've been on forums I have seen too many tanks that size and under go wrong even with good care. I also never stated it to be a fact that 3 gals will kill a betta , I name small tanks as deathtraps because their small size greatly enhances the chances of things going badly wrong even in good care not to mention the sheer lack of swimming space.

I often wonder if anyone here has even considered the concept of not taking words quite so literally and using common sense.

I'm hardly going to congratulate anyone on keeping a fish in a tank size I have always considered highly unsuitable for a permanent home. And since your tanks are not permanent and well kept there's a drastically reduced chance of things going wrong ( as you say you will be upgrading them to 6 gals )

It's small tanks for a permanent home I have a problem with, as a temproary measure and good care they work just fine.

Tbh, if you were a little more sensitive in your manner towards people you disagree with you might convince more people. You're probably hurting your cause rather than helping and I'd wager that if you could find yourself capable of being less alienating you might save a few more fish.

Small tanks (at least, small-but-not-tiny tanks) are not deathtraps. Bad owners who don't know their bettas basic needs are deathtraps. Just like it's not a gun that kills someone, it's the person weilding it.

As for being literal - it's not my responsibility to interpret what you say in the least offensive and least literal way possible. It is your responsibility to make yourself clear.

Not that I don't agree with you on the small tanks thing, as I have said. I've just got the sense to draw a distinction between "non-ideal" and "deathtrap".

LilyRose - got some photos coming of the tanks. They are looking great with the new plants. If you like them I'll PM you details of where I got them from.
 
I make myself perfectly clear thankyou. Always have. I may be blunt but at least I'm honest and don't sugar coat things, at the same time I point out things I consider wrong, say why I think they're wrong and why whatever situation won't work, and offer practical ( almost always very cheap I might add ) soloutions for upgrading tanks in particular.

If whoever it is doesn't take that advice, well that's fine by me. But if it goes wrong I'll have the satifaction of saying "I told you so" ( espescially since I always try to offer a soloution/alternative ) and nothing but pity for the poor fish *shrug*

I personally hold no difference between deathtrap and less than ideal. If you know full well it isn't ideal then wait until you have something that is. Sorry but I can't understand anyone who deliberately gets a "less than ideal" tank/s and then stocks them. It's pretty selfish to the animal/fish ect. If you can't provide the space for something to begin with then simply don't get it until you do have space. Impaitience gets you nowhere .
 
Getting back on topic! If people dont agree with each other, can you guys not keep it to yourselfs/PMS, rather than hi-jacking someones thread.

--------------------

Hi, my betta tanks did have all live plants, but i threw them out:
SDC12899-1.jpg

Honeythorn has wrote an excellent article! The only live plants i now keep are Camboba Caralinia, MossBall and java fern. IMO they are the easiest.
Live plants need regular maintenance, if not pruned regularly the tank will look wild, likewise, if there is not enough light/ferts high demanding ones will die and the light substrate will look extremely messy.

I am now going for all silk, here is what i recently brought for approx £12:
sdc13210.jpg


HTH :)
 
Thankyou very much for that photo, And assaye,, dont bite babe...some people love winding people up through narrow mindedness which causes them to feel hierarchal. HEY THORNY, we apprieciate your opinio nand we think the same way, put your soap box away plz, this thread is about plants...so please, give opinions on plants, if you wouldn't mind. xx
 
EXCUSE ME, but I wasn't the one who picked someone else's ( my ) thread apart and started an argument about a small point in a reply that was otherwise entirely about plants as requested in the original post . I am not the one to blame here :grr:
 
Deleted as I realize I posted this in the wrong place.. Sorry about that
 
I dont know about anyone else, but I have 1 or two small live plants I let float at the waters surface, bettas love to rest on them at night. You can have some planted also.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top