Hiya!
Well first of all hello everyone!
Anyway, I have just had the same problem, I bought 5 male guppies on sunday, it is now tuesday and by last night 4 of them were dead. All the readings were fine....Ammonia - 0 nitrite- 0 nitrate -10 Ph 7.0. They were in with 18 minnows.
We have since discovered that it is a change in the Ph of the water. Our guppies had exactly the same symptoms except that with 3 of them tails were completely shredded, I had to help one die because it was struggling so much and I couldn't watch.
Guppies apparently like alkaline water, the shop's tank had a Ph of 7.4 and our tank is 7.0 so not a big difference to us, but in terms of the Ph which is lagerithmic it is a huge jump. So it kills them basically.
If this doesn't make any sense tell me and I'll post again when I'm slightly more awake! As for the guppies, I have one in isolation because Im sorting tanks out at the moment, but he's fine if not somewhat annoyed with me and bored to be on his own with just a filter and an air stone for company and no toys. It's a hard life being a fish.
Anyway, hope this helps, try putting salt in the water, 1 teaspoon of sea salt to every gallon is what we've been told will help and it won't harm the other fish as far as anyone knows, it might not be great for them, but it's only short term hopefully!
Ok, Im off
(Sorry if it makes no sense!)
Minx
