Good Charlotte Vs Green Day

Rock? Greenday or Good Charlotte? Give me a break!

You just couldn't compare their ilk with the rock greats of guns n' roses, led zeppelin, def leppard, bon jovi...the list goes on.

My vote goes to Good Charlotte cos they haven't suddenly tried to become all political once they have an audience of appreciable size; though that's only because amputation wasn't an option...
 
They're both terrible, masquerading as punk bands gimme a break.

The Clash is always the band that ultimately all punks measure thmselves against. but if you want something better than greenday or good charlotte buy a indie label sampler

Punk-O-Rama series---you'll usually find something worth listening on here
Fat Wreck Chords-------these are generally good as well
Hellcat (Give em' the Boot) samplers---------these are better
IMHO the best label to check for good Punk that's not from the seventies is TKO records.

Just search them out on google. you shouldn't pay more than 5 bucks for any of them, and they're loaded with good tunes.

but the best band in my oppinion (which changes with the wind) is a band called SIXER.

Check them out if you can, you won't be dissapointed if you think that Green Day and Good Charlotte are punk.
 
Hmm their both really good :) but def. greenday

the best band of all time tho is From First To Last.. just 4t id share that with u :D
 
Rock? Greenday or Good Charlotte? Give me a break!

You just couldn't compare their ilk with the rock greats of guns n' roses, led zeppelin, def leppard, bon jovi...the list goes on.

I have to agree!
 
Im just going to say...the poll was Greenday or Good charlotte...Not if there as good as Led Zeppelin etc... How good a band is and their music is to Opinion and your opinion does not truly show the quality of a band say I said I like The Dresden Dolls someone will go "No their crap" that is their opinion and not the gospel truth.
Green day have been political for a long time...I wouldn't class the bands as Rock but more Punk bands...And don't come in classing them to the sex pistols etc because that was a different time and this is now...

There's my rant :)
 
If the choice is manufactured boy band or slit your wrists depressing crap, it has to be neither. They're both dire.

Saying that, when Jesus of Suburbia comes on Kerrang channel and goes on and on for hours about the angst of teenage life (like they've suffered a day of angst in their life!), driving you to want to rip your own ears off nd feed them to the dog, I'd pick Good Charlotte over that any day.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top