First, mollies are a special case, unlike any of the other 'freshwater' fish in the hobby. Mollies are found in the wild in full freshwater, brackish, and full marine. So, when discussing mollies, we need to remember that, and not try to transfer too much 'molly fact sheet information' to other livebearers. Mollies are not 'freshwater' fish. They can range from full fresh to brackish to full marine... but for them to be ok in 'full fresh', it needs to be hard, alkaline water. So, upping the hardness of your tank is perfectly fine for mollies, especially in any sort of a freshwater community set-up.
I am not going to disagree with Neale Monks. He's a scientist who studies these fish, and his solution for adding salt to a MOLLY tank is effective, if done properly. The problem is that it is an added step and it is best done only for brackish water communities, or species only tanks.
The best solution for keeping any 'freshwater' species, is to keep them in water that meets
their needs. Livebearers, specifically mollies, guppies, swords, and platies, do very well in hard water systems with no salt added. None of them 'require' salt. They do all tolerate salt very well compared to other freshwater fish - guppies and mollies, more so. But, their 'needs' are hard water.
The key to keep in mind is that unless it is a species only tank, or livebearers only... adding salt is a problem for the OTHER fish. In addition to that, the salinity needs to be kept CONSTANT, even in a species only tank. Not only
Seriouslyfish: molly -
A planted
tank is preferable but
hard alkaline or
brackish water is mandatory if the fish are to live long lives.
http
/seriouslyfish.com/species/Poecilia-sphenops/
platy -
Not critical but this species does appreciate a planted aquarium, and will be seen at its best if kept in this type of setup. X. variatus will not thrive in soft, acidic water.
http
/www.seriouslyfish.com/species/xiphophorus-variatus/
guppy -
An incredibly adaptable species that occurs in almost every imaginable biotope, from high-altitude streams toturbid swamps and ditches.
Some populations also exist in
brackish conditions.
However it does tend to thrive best in habitats with lush growths of
algae,
marginal vegetation and/or
aquatic plants.
http
/www.seriouslyfish.com/species/poecilia-reticulata/
swordtail -
Natural populations are found in various types of habitat from sea level to around 1500 m altitude, including fast-flowing, rocky streams, to springs, ditches, ponds, and rivers containing clear to turbid water. In most cases the water is less than 1.5 m deep and there is no aquatic vegetation.
In flowing water adults tend to congregate in areas with greater current, while juveniles and subadults display a preference for quiet marginal zones.
Introduced populations may occur in springs, streams, rivers, canals, ditches, pools, artificial reservoirs and other environments, and the species exhibits a degree of tolerance to polluted conditions. Where
X. helleriioccurs in large numbers outside its natural range it is thought to exert a number of negative impacts on native species and ecosystems.
Temperature: 16 – 28 °C
pH:
6.0 – 8.0
Hardness:
90 – 447 ppm
http
/www.seriouslyfish.com/species/xiphophorus-hellerii/
So, what does this mean for your molly, platy, guppy tank?
Simply this: these are highly adaptive fish to hard water conditions and salinity. BUT, they do not require salt, and should not be kept in salt continually. If your water hardness matches their needs, then your fish will be fine. If not, adding a bit of crushed coral or similar to your filter would be far more suitable, and would maintain more stable conditions than salt. Also, most of the plants that you might be trying to grow for these fish would be better off without the salt.