Fish Suggestions?

Bobtastic

Fish Addict
Joined
Apr 15, 2009
Messages
742
Reaction score
0
Location
Manchester, UK
Hi guys,

I have a 110litre (80 x 35 x 45cm) with 3 platys and 4-5 live plants. I'm planning to add 3 more platys to get them back up to a proper shoal and I want to add a shoal of Corydorus (what's the minimum number I should get) in with them. What else can I put in with them? I think the misses wants to get a couple of Angel fish, but I'm not sure if the tank is deep enough...

Compatable suggestions for a community tank pls!! :good:
 
For cory's i'd go with a group of say 4+ they do preffer to be in a group

Angels require a tank of at least 18" high .Lovely fish either keep one or in a group to disperse aggression

But if you are wanting small shoaling fish IE small tetra etc i'd add those first and let them grow to full size before adding juvie angels but bear in mind that neons are angel's main diet in the wild but a fully grown angel would struggle to eat a fully grown neon

Or go for some larger tetra such as the penguin tetra very eye catching in the aquarium but are sensitive to nitrAtes

Hope that helps

:D
 
How about Dwarf Gourami's or Bolivian or German Blue Ram's? Would they be alright with the other suggested fish?
 
No you can't get dwarf angels, but my personal opinion is that a 29G tall (17" height it looks like you've got) would be perfectly fine for a single pair of angels. Some people don't agree with me on this and I suppose when they get very old and big, if you are successful, they might wish for a bit more swimming room ideally but I just don't think its really going to be that bad!

Platies are bright and beautiful! Note however that they are not really a "shoaling" fish per se I don't believe. They are livebearers and there will be some sort of ideal male/female ratio (probably 2 females per male, but that's a guess and I'll defer to the many experts on here) So you don't need to get them up to six and besides, since they are livebearers they are going to breed like crazy and you'll probably have tons of babies to try and re-home!

Cories will definately benefit from shoaling, the more the merrier! Shoals of tetras and a fantastic combination with angels. Little neons are the angels natural food but if you can be patient enough and wait the 4-6 necessary months to age your tank for the neons/cardinals and then give them some more months prior to the baby angel introduction then the little angels will grow up thinking that the neons/cards have always been there and are not food! Plenty of other possibilities among the tetras too but try to stick with the ones that don't grow too big and beware of the few species that are known fin-nippers. Always ask around and give some time for answers for each species you get interested in.

~~waterdrop~~
 
leave your amount of platys as is. you could get 2 angels. would say no more. 6 corys. cardinals are like neons but are hardier and get alil bigger than the neons. make sure it is well plated for the angels.
 
I made the mistake of wondering into my LFS yesterday, luckily I managed to walk out without purchasing anything but now I want some Gourami! Will a pair be ok with my 3 Platies and the 6 corys I plan to get?

I very nearly bought a pair of Royal Red Gourami, but there were also some Powder Blue and Golden ones that caught my eye and made the decision too complicated. :lol:
 
Gouramis would be fine with the platies and corys. Which corys you planning on getting? personally I like sterbai corys.

Becareful which gouramis you get because some can get very large, so research the ones you are interested in first.

I wouldn't recommend dwarf gourami as they have a tendancy to die within about 6-12 months.

Honey gourami would be nice in your tank, as would many of the other gouramis available. I made the mistake of getting 2 pink kissing gouramis for my 33gal tank without knowing they grow upto 12"

Lukily it won't be long before i get a 100gal+ so they will be fine then.

Andy
 
Well the Red Royal's (Royal Red, can't remember which way round it is) and the Powder Blue are both Dwarf Gourami (so I'm told). I think the Golden ones were smaller than your average Gourami, but bigger than the dwarfs (4-5" I think). Oooooh! the choices!

I quite like the Panda and the Sterbai but the misses wants the Albino ones.
 
I have 2 albino corys, they are extremely lively!! they dont sit at the bottom quiet like most corys do, mine go nuts and have swimming marathons lol, I once watched mine swim from one end of the tank to the other then turn round and go back to the other end, he must have done 50 lengths non stop before he got bored lol.

Andy
 
Do Ram's mix well with community fish? Would they hassel the Platies or Gourami if I chose to get some? I assume that the Corys are immune to hasselling being tucked away at the bottom.
 
Gouramis have their little complications to think about. Personally I'd stay away from the Golds just because they are really just a color variant of the Trichogaster trichopterus, the other colors of which are the Blue Gourami (used to be called "three-spot" years ago) and the greenish one called the "Opaline," which was a new color variant as I remember it back in the 60's. All of these trichopterus can be mean fish and they can get quite big. As such, they are really better suited to being the -smaller- fish in a really huge aquarium that has a lot of fish bigger than them.

Gouramis in general will cause some trouble with generalizations as there's a bit of individuality there. You can happen upon ones that are more passive or more aggressive. But the generalizations to know anyway, I believe, are as follows: Males can and will get aggressive. One male per tank can help this and is often the way people go. The other thing that works but is more rare is if there is a pretty large group of the same type of gouramis. In that case they will distract each other and not bother other species like they do when there's just, say, a pair of them. I guess this makes "one male, two females" the most common grouping many times. They like plenty of plant cover and especially some floating plants in a corner or side of the aquarium.

Calling the Dwarfs (Colisa lalia) royal red or powder blue is a very recent thing I think. I think there are some legit "less silver, more blue" ones coming out of color breeding that are called powder blue, but I'm not sure how much the royal red is a bred variation or is just a label for the traditional Dwarf. These dwarf varieties are subject to the viral/bacterial thing you hear about but of course that's a hit or miss thing, either your fish has got it or not and you don't know. Dwarfs can be jumpers, so they need a lid. They are, though, pretty nice tankmates except for the occasional male aggression problems.

Honey Gouramis are also in Trichogaster, like the Blues, but they are a completely different personality and are supposed to be pretty ideal compared to these others we've been discussing. Even members here have described their colors as being much nicer at home once they are settled than you'll ever see in the LFS.

Back to the aggressive dept, I'd also like to mention that "kissing gouramis, who are not really even in the same family (Osphronemidae) as all these gouramis we've been discussing, are every bit as agressive as the trichopterus in my opinion. Chocolate Gouramis are back in the Osphronemidae family but are in a whole different subfamily than the dwarves or trichopterus, so they may have different behaviours - perhaps another member could tell us about Chocolates...

~~waterdrop~~
 
Thanks for the info ~wd~, I was thinking of just getting a pair (male/female) if I got some. Sounds like the dwarf ones are probably better suited for me, I think.
 
So I think what a lot of that advice was about was to suggest that you first consider 3 honey gouramis (1 male, 2 female) or 3 dwarves (1 male, 2 female.)

I can't remember whether the final size of the honey's is that much bigger than the dwarves, perhaps another member could fill in...
(I'm remembering them as small but I don't know if they finish out as small or how much bigger. Honey's don't have the "ouch, I got hit randomly by the dwarf disease" problem.)

~~waterdrop~~
 
The species section seems to suggest that the Honey's stay the same size as the Dwarfs at around 2".
 

Most reactions

Back
Top