Feeding fish every other day, instead of daily???

Magnum Man

Fish Connoisseur
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
5,470
Reaction score
4,316
Location
Southern MN
I have a tendency to be an "over feeder", which I think part of comes from being impatient... most fish come in as juvenile, and of course we want them to grow to maturity, like yesterday... but I'm not finding any fish "suffering" from not eating daily, and there are plenty of things to munch on, in the tanks, they are not sterile... the fish, and tanks seem more healthy, with an every other day feeding regiment... I suspect long term, the fish will live longer???
 
This is a question if ever there was one . I feed every day and sometimes twice a day but I get caught up in other things and miss a day sometimes and the fish seem okay . I’ve even heard of people not feeding for up to three weeks and the fish are fine . I just can’t stand to see the poor things begging and not getting something .
 
I myself always skip one day a week of feeding them. This way they can show their natural behavior to look for food themselves. Which means also less cleaning for me to do. They'll be just fine if you feed them once every other day. They won't starve by all means.
 
I myself always skip one day a week of feeding them. This way they can show their natural behavior to look for food themselves. Which means also less cleaning for me to do. They'll be just fine if you feed them once every other day. They won't starve by all means.
I’m wish I could fast myself every other day. My waistline would benefit from it. My body could survive on all my stored excess fat. But my mind and cravings wont let me skip even one day. 🤪
 
I do the same thing as emeraldking. However, at least twice a month I will not feed another day as well. I feed my tanks in the evening. I eat dinner late and I like to feed the fish before I eat. This doesn't always work out and those 2 or 3 nights a month become unplanned skips.

Because I breed plecos I prefer to feed new fry every day. The nice part of the plecos is I feed a lot of sinking goods which get softer the longer they are in the water. This mean even a big sinking stick or wafer become soft enough for a fry to eat some of it. Also, the sticks and wafer tend to fall apart completely. At some point this means they break down in small portions.

Also, I have always felt fish do best on a varied diet to whatever extent this is possible.

As long as the subject is feeding in terms of skipping I have one observation. Every singles species of fish I have kept and every single fish have been or are pigs. They all will try to eat anything they think might be food. And though they may eat a specialized diet in the wild, in my tanks they respect few or no dietary rules. I do not understand it when I read or am in a conversation where somebody says their fish refuse to eat some brand or type of food. The only fish in my tanks that won't try to eat anything they can are ones which are sick and will be treated because have noticed this and other behaviors and symptoms which indicate they are ill.

Uh Oh- I did not feed yesterday. I just glance up at the 75 gal. in-wall and noticed the amano shrimp darting all over the tank. This means they are very hungry. I was taught this years ago by Rachel., aka msjinkzd who owned/ran Inverts by msjinkzd for many years. When I see that I feed them which means everything in the tank will get a shot at stealing their food.
 
My first meal of the day is at noon drinking either a blueberry smoothie using kefir (liquid yogurt) or an avocado smoothie. I eat dinner at 5 pm and then fast until noon the next day. This has been my routine for many years.
 
I feed 4 days per week. On no-feed days I hang strips of nori (seaweed). Everybody is fine. 7 tanks, 3 125s, 2 75s, 2 40s. It has been years. All tanks are planted to various degrees, and have sand substrata and wood.
 
I'd guess we feed 5/days per week. We sort of alternate, 1 of us has a heavy hand...& it's not usually me, ;)

But I agree w/2tank, fry or young fish need food more often...& more water changes.
 
We can learn from ourselves when it comes to fish feeding, I think. We're warm blooded, so our nutritional needs are different from those of a cold blooded fish. They don't have to keep an internal fire burning.

But we're generally hard wired to over eat, in anticipation of that incoming famine. Biologically, we're scavengers and hunter gatherers, and we're always ready to over scavenge, over hunt and over gather in case of hard times ahead. Our fish will pig out on an entire bug, or a newly found cache of algae or plant matter if they can, because they can go days without finding a steady supply. If you're a wild Betta, mosquitoes don't arrive on a schedule.

I intentionally vary my feeding times, and try to feed with stealth. I have no tanks with fish that beg at the glass. The food is delivered in different places in the tank at different times. I try not to train my fish.

If I'm bored, I eat badly compared to when I'm doing things I like. I project that on to my fish. I talk to people who've been in prison and when they're in, they seem to enjoy eating and drama. If I see my fish hovering for food and aimlessly fighting, I need to make changes. A larger tank. More water flow. A larger group of their species in some cases. I have to improve their set up, not feed them more. If they reward me by ignoring me and going about their lives, I feel I'm on the right track.

Prepared foods can be rich, and low in fiber. Live food is usually very full of fiber, and can take hours to catch to eat. I use it as much as I can. If I were a zoo animal and my keeper threw me big macs every day, I would be sluggish and miserable pretty quickly. So even without live food, some flake, some frozen, some freeze dried...

If I get out doing a project, in the garden, the fishroom, the community, whatever, I don't eat like I do cooped up in the house in the dead of winter. I'll forget to eat for an entire day. I'm too busy enjoying other things to notice. If you show up with a plate of food, I'll stop and enjoy it, but I won't plan for it, or wait. I'm engaged and busy and I only eat to live at those times. So I like to think fish live something similar. If food presents itself, it's gone. If it doesn't, they're busy. No regular meal times, varied offerings, as little association of seeing their keeper meaning food as possible (wander by many times without food to check them out), varied amounts. With a big tank, appropriate tankmates and a decor set up for their needs, they won't spend all day watching for the arrival of The Great Shadow and for the scattering of ultra fattening, ultra processed Costco lasagnas on the surface.

Over feeding shortens our lives and reduces the range of what we can do. It's the same for fish. I don't eat as well as @gwand, but probably about as often. I'm going out across the savannah later where I expect to find the still warm carcass of a freshly baked cheese bread loaf, baked by a small lion lady with an odd mane, in a seaside village. Don't worry, I'll save some for the rest of my pack.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top