Dosage Suggestion

jameshughes1989

Fish Addict
Joined
Jun 25, 2009
Messages
936
Reaction score
0
Location
Ashford, Kent, UK
Hi, Ive got a 160 litre planted tank that Ive just set up and all seems to be well. At the moment im dosing 5ml of TPN+ and easycarbo daily. Is this right? I feel I should be dosing more TPN+, any advice welcome.

Cheers
 
People often say 1ml of TPN+ for every 20L of water so that equals 8ml per day for you.

Not sure about the easycarbo.
 
i have a 240L and dose 8ml of each daily as advised by truck. all is well :good:

where is truck these days anyway?
 
So, you guys reckon 8ml then? Do you think I should stick with the 5ml of carbo?

The tank is moderately stocked with plants.


Thanks
 
8ml of TPN+ and 8ml of Easycarbo daily.

interesting, is that dosing purely based on water volume? I thought the amount of each should be calculated on water volume AND quantity of plants.

I've got a 125L with roughly 10 vallis, 10 cabomba and 2 anubias. I'm dosing 1.5ml of TPN and 1ml of Easycarbo....trying to follow the dosing for "lightly planted" aquariums.

Am I doing it wrong???
 
It's just a rough guide, a starting point. Based on volume and if its moderately planted. If people experience deficiencies or algae then they need to increase the dosage.
 
I've got a 125L with roughly 10 vallis, 10 cabomba and 2 anubias. I'm dosing 1.5ml of TPN and 1ml of Easycarbo....trying to follow the dosing for "lightly planted" aquariums.

Am I doing it wrong???

If you have a tank like yours with a few plants then just follow the instructions on the bottle. They are based on your 'average' planted tank and lo-tec setup. If you have a hi tec high plantmass setup then you have to up the anti.

Thats why most aquascapers (apart from those who have money to burn) mix their own because they would get through TPN+ almost as quickly as they get through beer :) And in that scenario best to save the pennies so you can buy more beer instead.

If you are CO2 injected with decent lighting then go for the 1ml per 20ltrs. If you are non CO2 with lower light then follow the bottle (or even stop.)

As an example (and I will have to suggest the lighting level to you because being LED the WPG would suggest much lower levels of light than they actually produce.) When my 125ltr was high light (3WPG+ equivalent) and CO2 enriched I was dosing 5ml TPN+ (which I got for free) daily. Obviously when the bottle ran out I went back to dry ferts (EI and then PMDD+P.) When I went non CO2 I lowered the lighting levels (1.5-2WPG equivalent) and all I dose now is a pinch of KNO3 every month or so.

With the EasyCarbo I would suggest that unless you have an algae problem then follow the bottle. Unless your light is pretty high then it won't matter if the levels of C are low (remember it is liquid carbon and not liquid CO2.) Just as under a low light tank you can get by with equilibrium levels. The plants become C limited but that shouldn't affect <2WPG tanks.

I should add that unless you are dosing EasyCarb due to an algae problem or that you want faster growth then it isn't needed at all in the <2WPG bracket (with a few exceptions - every system is slightly different)

AC
 
I've got a 125L with roughly 10 vallis, 10 cabomba and 2 anubias. I'm dosing 1.5ml of TPN and 1ml of Easycarbo....trying to follow the dosing for "lightly planted" aquariums.

Am I doing it wrong???

If you have a tank like yours with a few plants then just follow the instructions on the bottle. They are based on your 'average' planted tank and lo-tec setup. If you have a hi tec high plantmass setup then you have to up the anti.

Thats why most aquascapers (apart from those who have money to burn) mix their own because they would get through TPN+ almost as quickly as they get through beer :) And in that scenario best to save the pennies so you can buy more beer instead.

If you are CO2 injected with decent lighting then go for the 1ml per 20ltrs. If you are non CO2 with lower light then follow the bottle (or even stop.)

As an example (and I will have to suggest the lighting level to you because being LED the WPG would suggest much lower levels of light than they actually produce.) When my 125ltr was high light (3WPG+ equivalent) and CO2 enriched I was dosing 5ml TPN+ (which I got for free) daily. Obviously when the bottle ran out I went back to dry ferts (EI and then PMDD+P.) When I went non CO2 I lowered the lighting levels (1.5-2WPG equivalent) and all I dose now is a pinch of KNO3 every month or so.

With the EasyCarbo I would suggest that unless you have an algae problem then follow the bottle. Unless your light is pretty high then it won't matter if the levels of C are low (remember it is liquid carbon and not liquid CO2.) Just as under a low light tank you can get by with equilibrium levels. The plants become C limited but that shouldn't affect <2WPG tanks.

I should add that unless you are dosing EasyCarb due to an algae problem or that you want faster growth then it isn't needed at all in the <2WPG bracket (with a few exceptions - every system is slightly different)

AC

Thats really helpful, and im sure its cleared some things up for a few of us, cheers :good:
 

Most reactions

Back
Top