Cycle Almost Done - Time To Finalise Stocking List

scubadoo

Fish Crazy
Joined
Jun 6, 2006
Messages
377
Reaction score
0
Location
South Wales
As it says on the tin (well title).

I'm fairly sure that my fishless cycle is near to completion (just over 2 weeks) since my ammonia and nitrite are both 0. The only possible issue is that the nitrate is only reading 5ppm, but that could be down to the fact that there are a few live plants and a juwel green nitrate filter sponge which may be skewing the readings - or the nitrate test kit is just lying!

Either way, I'm going to keep a close eye on things this week, then intend to buy my fish at the weekend.

Now I know about the 1"/gallon rule of thumb - and that there are numerous variables that can affect the guidance, but I've also read that 1cm/litre is a decent stocking rule of thumb. Well that just doesn't add up.

My tank is a 190l Juwel Trigon (50 US gals), therefore at 1"/gal I could get about to 50" of fish (this equates to about 127cm), but at 1cm/l I could get about 190cm - big difference!

Anyhow, the intended stocking list something like this:

Cardinal Tetra (10 no.) = 20" or 60cm
Cherry Barbs (6 no.) = 12" or 30cm
Zebra Danio (6 no.) = 12" or 30cm
Small Cory (sterba or similar) = 12" or 30cm
Boesmani Rainbow (2 no.) = 8" or 20cm
Bristlenose catfish (1 no.) = 5" or 12cm

Total fish length therefore is about 69" or 182 cm.

Now this is greater than the "/gal but lower than the cm/l guide.
Using the PFK calculator, they recommend stocking about 40" or 97 cm, but also state that a maximum density of 76" or 193cm could be ok.

:dunno:

I have purposely selected a high number of small thin bodied fish to minimise the amount of waste produced per unit length, which I hope will allow for a greater number of fish in the tank.
I also know that the maintenance regime may be pretty heavy when the tank is fully stocked.

So here goes - I'd love to hear your opinions please [ducks now behind very big parapet] :fish:
 
I don't think 69" in a 50 Gallon tank is that over stocked. Bigger tanks are more lenient I think. I think you'll be fine. Plus none of your fish except maybe the catfish are big waste producers.

Karl
 
You actually even have room left over, maybe for a centerpeice fish or something? Or you could keep it as it is because its always good to under-stock. One more thing, Boesmani Rainbows are schooling fish so instead of just 2 I would go with 5-6 at the very least.
 
Cardinal Tetra (10 no.) = 20" or 60cm
Cherry Barbs (6 no.) = 12" or 30cm
Zebra Danio (6 no.) = 12" or 30cm
Small Cory (sterba or similar) = 12" or 30cm
Boesmani Rainbow (2 no.) = 8" or 20cm
Bristlenose catfish (1 no.) = 5" or 12cm

Total fish length therefore is about 69" or 182 cm

Not to be nitpicky (just wondering):
(no experience but) don't Boesmani Rainbow get bigger than 4" normally? (As said above) rainbows are schoolers (I can't say much I have 1 of 4 rainbow praecox left myself; hard to find here tho)
Four "Small Cory (sterba or similar) = 12" or 30cm"? Guessing b'cuz Most cory get about 3".

I personally like your fish choices & I also don't think 69" of fish in 55gal. is too bad. Kinda wonder what your filteration will be like tho, gph? (if you know... I don't know mine off the top of my head either lol) Do you subscribe to the "overkill filteration" mindset (say: water turnover of 10X per hour or greater)? Well, anyway, IMHO 2 filters on a 55gal. is almost always a good plan.

One Last ramble...... What I like best about Your post is that you put both in. & cm. (conversion isN't my specialty!) :)
 
Thanks for the input guys - I didnt realise that boesmani's were shoaling fish.

I dont think I've got the room to get 5 or 6 :(

May have to re-think on the larger fish I'd been aiming for.
How about a pair of gourami's ? - not sure about them getting nipped by the barbs or tetras tho'
 
I think I might substitute the bristlenose plec for 3 or 4 Oto's (maybe more in keeping with a tank which has smaller fish).

I really do want the boesmani's though - maybe I can just squeeze 5 in ?
 
AAAAARRRRRGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH !!!

@£$%%%*& Fishless Cycle seems to be going backwards - ammonia reading of 1 yesterday (been 0 for days), but I think I may have added too much - will check again tonight.

Nitrate readings all over the place - think its the test kit, so have gone to get a nutrafin one to try instead of the API one!




My lfs doesn't have any cherry barbs either, so may substitute for serpae tetra.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top