Cichlids And Rainbows?

Get Ready! 🐠 It's time for the....
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to enter! 🏆

BobbyBray

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Feb 2, 2009
Messages
121
Reaction score
0
Location
Alaska, USA
I've been trying to establish a tank over the past month, and so far I've had nothing but bad luck. Granted a good potion of it is my own fault, due mostly to a significant lack of information.

Background Info:
I killed my first two fish after doing a terrible water change, had another get sucked into filter intake, and the last two that I bought went belly up, ether from overfeeding, or the excess amount of copper that I found I've got in my water. Needless to say I've learned a lot of do's and don'ts, its too bad the little guys had to die for my mistakes.

I've found that using a brita filter pulls the copper out of my water, so while it takes about 10 times as long to prepare a water change when doing it that way, I see no alternative atm. I did a water change the other day, and pulled a lot of gunk out of the rocks, again probably from over feeding. This morning, my ammonia, nitrite and nitrate levels seem to be fine, so I think I may try to add another fish.

I bought the standard 29 gallon starter kit tank, so its about three feet long and two feet tall (not the longer shorter breeder tank variation). As of now the lone survivor of my mistakes is Edwardo, an Australian Rainbowfish. I was initially thinking about sticking to the lesser aggressive breeds of fish: Rainbows, Gourami's, Tetra's, Sharks etc. But I was chatting with a lady at the only LFS in my town, and she said that the rainbowfish tend to be slightly aggressive, and would do fine with any cichlads of the same size. Sooo....

Question:
Would you guys agree? I'm thinking with a 29 gallon I would prefer fish that are in the 4" or shorter range, with possibly 1 6" fish. Or should I stick to the original plan, and keep the 29 for docile fish? If I can get the hang of fish care, I think I'd look at getting a 55 gallon eventually, but that would be a year or more out with my current living situation and budget :/

Any advice you guys can offer is much appreciated, I've cruised around the forums here for a few days reading various articles, and there's definitely a wealth of knowledge.

Here's a photo of my tank setup as of today:

3249155244_4178c5b43c.jpg
 
what fish are u wanting to keep?

I can't seem to keep all the latin names straight, but it sounds like the Julidochromis, and Altoamprologus variations would work in a 30 gallon tank form what I've read. My LFS also had a small bright yellow cichlid, and unfortunately I can't remember the name of it now. Neolamprologus Lelepi maybe? It was suppose to stay around 4" and be a fairly docile cichlid... or at least so they told me. The store also had some jeweled, convict, and firemouth cichlids in stock. Any idea on how well those might work?
 
what fish are u wanting to keep?

I can't seem to keep all the latin names straight, but it sounds like the Julidochromis, and Altoamprologus variations would work in a 30 gallon tank form what I've read. My LFS also had a small bright yellow cichlid, and unfortunately I can't remember the name of it now. Neolamprologus Lelepi maybe? It was suppose to stay around 4" and be a fairly docile cichlid... or at least so they told me. The store also had some jeweled, convict, and firemouth cichlids in stock. Any idea on how well those might work?


these wont work with rainbows etc as these are rift lake cichlids. and require their own water conditions.

is it rainbows u want to keep

if so what kinds? then work wat u can keep around them
 
I could hand the rainbow over to my GF for her tank if need be. It was more of a curiosity to see if it would work or not. I'm still undecided as to what I want the whole tank to look like in the end, as far as fish goes that is.
 
I could hand the rainbow over to my GF for her tank if need be. It was more of a curiosity to see if it would work or not. I'm still undecided as to what I want the whole tank to look like in the end, as far as fish goes that is.


first of all u need to decide what fish u want, then build tank and conditions around it etc
 
Ok, so let me change the question then. If my tank was empty of all fish, would there be any particular cichlids you might recommend for a 30 gallon setup?
 
Ok, so let me change the question then. If my tank was empty of all fish, would there be any particular cichlids you might recommend for a 30 gallon setup?

Try this............. :good:

Tanganyika cichlids- 2 Julidochromis marlieri, 3 Neolamprologus leleupi, 1 Neolamprologus pulcher, 1 Neolamprologus Caudopunctatus, 1 Red Violet Cochliodon(L137) 1 Neolamprologus tretocephalus, 1 Neolamp Sexfasciatus Tanz Gold, 1 Spathodus (Clown Faced) Cichlid Goby.


This has been working in my 120lt (32us or 27uk galls) for a while now without problem
 
Thanks for the suggestions. I went ahead and quickly looked up each of those fish, looks like it'd be a beautiful tank to have. But in the end I think I'll stick with some none cichlids in my tank. Later if I decide to continue, or end up getting a second tank then I'll look at cichlids, and have already saved a list of all those fish you suggested, Tanganyika Cichlids seem to be an interesting group.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top