Change F/ Cartridge Every Month?

Ficious

Fish Addict
Joined
Jun 25, 2008
Messages
947
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Location
Des Moines, IA
the manual says to buy a new filter cartridge every 4-6 weeks...is this necessary? Im sure its because they want you to buy more from them but what happens to the beneficial bacteria when i buy a brand new filter cartridge??? would the tank need to be cycled again? i wont have to worry as i am doubled up on filtration but i was just curious.

can i keep my cartridge for 6 months to a year??? does the carbon go bad??
 
the manual says to buy a new filter cartridge every 4-6 weeks...is this necessary? Im sure its because they want you to buy more from them but what happens to the beneficial bacteria when i buy a brand new filter cartridge??? would the tank need to be cycled again? i wont have to worry as i am doubled up on filtration but i was just curious.

can i keep my cartridge for 6 months to a year??? does the carbon go bad??


you dont need to change sponges just carbon
 
what filter you got?

I had one that said to change every month, but there was another small one in it that rarely gets cleaned (it was a black one - no not carbon)...

I decided to get bags of filter floss as it was miles cheaper and lasted long time..

I found that the tank run better this way and i only changed half of it every month, sometimes longer depending on how dirty it was.

the manual says to buy a new filter cartridge every 4-6 weeks...is this necessary? Im sure its because they want you to buy more from them but what happens to the beneficial bacteria when i buy a brand new filter cartridge??? would the tank need to be cycled again? i wont have to worry as i am doubled up on filtration but i was just curious.

can i keep my cartridge for 6 months to a year??? does the carbon go bad??


you dont need to change sponges just carbon

Some filters you do m8, like for example the tetratecs.
 
OP... do you have a hang on filter with bio wheel?
If so ... you dont have to replace the cartridge. I Clean them with discarded tank water.
I only replace them when there is physical damage to the cartridge.
 
yea theyre all hang on filters, 1 is a penguin 150 which has the 3 stages including the biowheel

the two that hang on my 36 are both w/o biowheels but have the "bio material".

im assuming the cartridge is the mechanical filtration, catching particles and such.

thanks for your advice, ill keep em clean but rarely buy new ones.


my question left unanswered is if the filters have just the cartridge with the carbon inside does this contain the beneficial bacteria?
 
All filters need to have their media rinsed clean (in aquarium water) periodically, if only the maintain a good flow of water. Typically this is every 4-8 weeks depending on how messy your tank is.

Carbon is an excellent substrate for biological filtration. After a couple of weeks the cracks on the carbon will be filled with bacteria. While not as good as, say, Siporax, carbon is an above-average media for squeezing in as many bacteria as possible per cubic centimetre.

But here's the thing: once carbon is covered with bacteria, the carbon no longer adsorbs organic chemicals in the water. So chemical filtration stops. That's why you are told to replace the carbon regularly.

Having said this, I recommend against people using carbon at all. It serves no useful function in a well maintained freshwater tank. Water changes will dilute dissolved organics, as well as remove nitrate and phosphate, which carbon doesn't do. Carbon is "old school", a solution to stopping the water from turning yellow back when people did 25% per month water changes. No-one should be doing that anymore, hence carbon is redundant. Moreover, carbon removes beneficial organic chemicals such as fish medications. If you try to treat whitespot (ick) in a tank with fresh carbon installed, you'll notice the medication doesn't work. Incredibly common mistake this.

Most people who use carbon have no idea what it's for, and this is why carbon sells most strongly at the "entry level" end of the market as cartridges for small, relatively inexpensive filters. It's an easy way for manufacturers to make money selling something dirt cheap for them but expensive for you.

Just say no to carbon!

Cheers, Neale
 
yea theyre all hang on filters, 1 is a penguin 150 which has the 3 stages including the biowheel

the two that hang on my 36 are both w/o biowheels but have the "bio material".

im assuming the cartridge is the mechanical filtration, catching particles and such.

thanks for your advice, ill keep em clean but rarely buy new ones.


my question left unanswered is if the filters have just the cartridge with the carbon inside does this contain the beneficial bacteria?
That is correct. It is for mechanical filtration.
The carbon in the cartridge is very small in amount and gets used up quickly.
I don't use any carbon.
If you incline on using carbon, get a small mesh bag and place it in front of the water outlet. That way you change the carbon on regular basis.
 
I've never replaced the main filter sponges in my filter, there's just no need as long as they are in good condition, and if you do replace them you're starting again with a fresh bit of uncolonized filter material. As has been said just rinse them out in old tank water when the water flow starts to slow and you're good to go. For my filter floss to polish the water i've got an old synthetic pillow that i'm cutting bits off that's doing a grand job. I only replace that when it gets clogged as it doesn't clean so well.
 
i don't think the OP's question has been answered yet, so i'll answer it.

nearly all of the beneficial bacteria of a bio-wheel filter is on the bio-wheel, which you should never replace unless it's no longer functional. the filter pad has very little beneficial bacteria on it, so you can use it until the pad starts falling apart. i change mine every 6 months.
 
i don't think the OP's question has been answered yet, so i'll answer it.

nearly all of the beneficial bacteria of a bio-wheel filter is on the bio-wheel, which you should never replace unless it's no longer functional. the filter pad has very little beneficial bacteria on it, so you can use it until the pad starts falling apart. i change mine every 6 months.
Thats what I meant to say :)
 
youve all done a good job at helping me understand all of this. thanks for your time guys!! its very appreciated
 

Most reactions

Back
Top