Betta died overeating baby snails?

June FOTM Photo Contest Starts Now!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to enter! 🏆

Germanshepherd72

New Member
Joined
Jun 8, 2019
Messages
2
Reaction score
0
Hello. Yesterday I noticed my Betta, Penelope, appeared to be bloated/swollen. She wasn't her normal fiesty self, but was hovering closer to the bottom of the tank. Penelope would eat anything she could get her mouth around. She was in a 10 gallon tank with 6 pygmy cities and one mystery snail. When I'd feed her, I'd then throw in an algae wafer for the cories, and nearly every day she'd ram it, trying to eat off chunks of algae. I tried feeding the cories at night, but nothing would stop her from eating anything she possibly could. I often thought to myself "She'd eat herself to death if you'd let her." I was always careful when feeding the tank because of this.
Tonight, I arrived home to check on her. She was on her side, and you could see something discolored in her stomach. It had gotten even larger. Her breathing was normal. I tapped the top glass and her eyes shot up to the sound. I tried to think what she might have eaten, but could not. I had just fasted her 2 weeks ago for getting down 2 entire shrimp pellets after her 2 Betta pellets! I crushed them and stirred them for the cories but she still somehow managed to follow the school of feeding cories and actually take in mouthfuls of sand substrate, swish it around, swallow the bits, then spit our only the sand. Tonight she was on one side, stomach so full of something you could see inside her - she was a brilliant pearlescent white so you could see this brown mass in her belly. I could only observe her for about 20 minutes before I noticed this outcropping of 4 tiny snails in my tank. I had 2 mystery snails in my tank but no eggs. Tonight there were baby snails. The other mystery snail died at least 4 months ago. I really believe that Penelope picked baby snails off of the glass and fed on them until she nearly ruptured inside. I tapped the glass and her left fin shot her up an inch off of the bottom. She was so full that you could see her scales starting to stand up. I made the painful decision to euthanize her.
I had to put my much beloved 10 year old Belgian Malinois companion Ginger to sleep 10 days ago after a long battle with arthritis. I've been an emotional mess since. I laid her to rest in a Raku ceramic urn last night and sealed it. It's been nothing but tears since. Having to see Penelope in pain and put her down after Ginger... I feel so lost right now. I love my cories and lone male Betta Raphael in his own 10 gallon tank. But I had to put down my 2 girls in one week.
I'm bawling as I type, but could that mystery snail have laid fertilized eggs 4 months after mating? Is it possible that Penelope ate herself to death on snails? They would easily fit in her mouth. Judging by her stomach it looked like she would have eaten at least 8 to 10 snails. I'd just like to know - I'd hate to think I did something wrong with her and made her sick. Thank you in advance.
 
Do you have a picture of her before she died? My betta eats baby snails all the time and is fine so far. What are your ammonia/nitrate/nitrite levels? I'm thinking either she got dropsy, which often pops up over a single day or two, or had something messed up from the sand she ate before
 
Do you have a picture of her before she died? My betta eats baby snails all the time and is fine so far. What are your ammonia/nitrate/nitrite levels? I'm thinking either she got dropsy, which often pops up over a single day or two, or had something messed up from the sand she ate before
I didn't think to take a picture. It was just too much to bear to see her suffer after putting Ginger to sleep last week and I broke down when I saw her.
My tank parameters are fine. Those snails are the only new variable in my tank. No tank changes since October at the least. I guess it may have been dropsy. Never had a fish with it although I know it's common. Penelope would have eaten as many baby snails as she could find as fast as she could find them. I've never seen a fish quite like that. I believe she overate on them or a snail damaged her insides. I also can't explain how that snail might have hatched eggs so long after mating?
 
I had an Angelfish who rid my tank of pond snails...he was better than an Assassin snail!
 
Were they mystery snails or pond snails? Pond snails could easily go un noticed for a long time, say one egg came on a plant. It would hatch and then have to mature into adult and then they can reproduce on their own and then lay eggs and the eggs hatched. That's what happened on mine
 
I put one of my bettas in my shrimp tank and he ate about 40 shrimp before I realized and got him out. He was fat and happy but fine. I’m so sorry for your loss.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top