Anaerobic zone myth?

Barry Tetra

Fish Aficionado
Pet of the Month 🎖️
Joined
Dec 23, 2019
Messages
3,384
Reaction score
1,829
Location
Thailand
Is the danger of anaerobic zone a myth? I recently observed that the substrate, which is 26.5 cm deep, in my mini planted pond is anaerobic, there's a hydrogen sulfide smell when I poke it but the inhabitants are still doing well. It happens in the natural puddle as well.
 
Last edited:
Yeh, I've had that happen loads of times in a sand substrate. You are doing something in the tank, move the substrate, and a smell of Sulphur and didn't seem to impact on the fish at all, ever in my experience
 
The danger is when you poke or disturb it too much. If left untouched its fine for years.
Then one day you get the urge to clean it and stir it up. pH crashes and everything in the tank / pond dies.
 
The danger is when you poke or disturb it too much. If left untouched its fine for years.
Then one day you get the urge to clean it and stir it up. pH crashes and everything in the tank / pond dies.
I did that once years ago . I had a deep sand substrate and disturbed it . I’ll never forget that smell as long as I live but it’s natural . Prove it to yourself by walking through a slow moving and shallow mud bottomed stream . You’ll dredge up that smell but also look and see how everything is growing right . Even here in the northern USA we have streams like that with some aquatic plants so you should have no trouble at all finding one in Thailand .
 
Most fish that live in habitats where gases are likely to bubble out have alternative breathing systems. Think anabantoids like Bettas - good Thai fish with survival skills via an ability to breathe surface air when things get bad.
I stepped into muddy stream bottoms in Gabon, and watched the mud flow away at a pretty solid speed. The small fish we were catching had somewhere to go if an elephant decided to take a dip (or a Canadian stuck his big feet in their habitat). Pick a point in an average tropical stream and think of how many litres flow over it on an average day. You'll probably find many thousands more than any plastic filter or even water changes provide in a tiny glass box.
Anaerobic sections in tanks are interesting. They can be very deadly to bottom dwellers like the Cory group. If the tank is large enough and well filtered enough, the fish can dodge the poison gas. Interestingly, some species are very aware. Dwarf Cichlids leading their young fry around a tank have been shown to avoid areas of low oxygen, and to keep their fry away from them.
With poor maintenance, you can suffocate fish easily in a small tank, because they have nowhere to escape to. What happens in nature and in tanks tends to be different. The glass walls...
There can be large scale fish die offs from gasses though. Volcano crater likes are well known for this, although some of their residents have evolved interesting red blood cells to resist the effects of low oxygen.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top