2 Weeks Into A Cycle Using Mature Media

The December FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

GetItSahn

Fish Crazy
Joined
Jul 26, 2013
Messages
285
Reaction score
0
Location
US
A few weeks back I was getting readings of 1 ammonia, 0 nitrites and nitrates 2 days after full dosing of ammonia.
Now, my ammonia drops from 3ppm to 0 in 24 hours (which is what i thought i should be looking for) but i tested my nitrite and nitrate and found them both to be crazy high. Looks like close to 5 nitrite and 160 nitrate.
What should i do? a large water change or will it resolve itself?
 
I'd suggest doing a diluted nitrite test (10% water from the tank, 90% distilled water), to make sure the nitrites are indeed 5% and not any higher. If it is at 5ppm, then I'd just wait til your nitrites cleared to zero.

It might also be wise to do a ph test, nitrates at 160 is kind of expected but can mess about with the ph.
 
Gruntle said:
I'd suggest doing a diluted nitrite test (10% water from the tank, 90% distilled water), to make sure the nitrites are indeed 5% and not any higher. If it is at 5ppm, then I'd just wait til your nitrites cleared to zero.

It might also be wise to do a ph test, nitrates at 160 is kind of expected but can mess about with the ph.
I did a small water change after getting the initial 5.0 nitrite reading (2 days ago)
Ok, I just tested my water again.
DIluted Nitrite: 0
Nitrite: still at what looks like 5
Nitrate: 40
Ammonia:  0
 
Even when using media to seed a tank or bottled bacteria for a fishless cycle, if ammonia is dropping, nitrites should be tested. In order to assess where in a cycle things stand, we need to know more information than you have provide. I would need to know how much ammonia you add and when and then all reading taken for ammonia and nitrite. With this info it becomes a lot easier to know exactly where things should be vs where they are and why.
 
Using an API (or similar) test kit, the number you do not want to exceed is 16 ppm of nitrite and I prefer to use 15 ppm as the line to be safe.
 
The fastest way to cycle is not to do any water changes without cause.
 
The danger of too much nitrate, and the cycle itself, is that it can result in dropping pH due to one's having the carbonates in the tank used up. Carbonates are a key component of KH which is what holds pH steady. Use up the KH and the pH falls and when it get into the 6.5 range or below, a cycle will stall.
 
Finally, there is no need to do 9:1 testing. It is overkill and usually more subject to inaccuracies. There is a good step by step set of instructions for how to do diluted testing that is easy and accurate here http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?/topic/433778-rescuing-a-fish-in-cycle-gone-wild-part-il/ These instructions are there for determining how much salt to add to help during a fish in cycle. However, the diluted testing process is the same for any form of diluted testing for nitrogen compounds.
 
One last note, knowing how much ammonia has gone in will let us determine what the maximum possible nitrite should result from that. In the cycling article here the ammonia ammounts and timing of their being added is intentionally designed to make it impossible for one to have too high nitrite even when it hits the top of the test scale we know it should be OK. It is when folks depart from the directions and add too much or too soon that the nitrite can go nuts.
 
In order to know if you need to do a water change I would want to know what your tap pH and KH are and then what they are now in your tank. Assuming your nitrite is actually under 16 ppm and your pH is not dropping rapidly (and HK too), there is no reason to change any water. While the nitrate may be high, if it is not slowing the cycle, there is no need to change the water. If your nitrite is under 16 ppm, then changing water will reduce that which, in turn, will slow your cycle. If your nitrite is 16 or more, no matter what the nitrate level is, you must do about a 1/3 or so water change. The goal is to drop it to about 10 ppm. This leaves a good amount to keep the nitrite bacs reproducing and gives you 5 or so ppms headroom for it to be able to rise again safely.
 
GetItSahn said:
A few weeks back I was getting readings of 1 ammonia, 0 nitrites and nitrates 2 days after full dosing of ammonia.
Now, my ammonia drops from 3ppm to 0 in 24 hours (which is what i thought i should be looking for) but i tested my nitrite and nitrate and found them both to be crazy high. Looks like close to 5 nitrite and 160 nitrate.
What should i do? a large water change or will it resolve itself?
 
I agree with TTA that knowing how much ammonia you have added in totality would help us determine how high the nitrite could possibly be.
 
First, 1 ppm ammonia will turn into 2.7 ppm nitrite.  So, if you've added 10ppm ammonia (added together) then the maximum nitrite level would be 27 ppm.  
 
 
And I'll say this, doing a water change may slightly slow the process of the cycle, but there's no real danger in doing the water change.  There are dangers in just adding more and more ammonia.  If the nitrite or nitrate levels go to high, they can stall the cycle and in extreme levels even kill your bacteria.  
 
So... if I were in your boat, and I was concerned about the nitrite and nitrate levels being really high - I'd just change the water (change as much as you can) and refill.  Then you will know that the nitrite and nitrate levels are in the 'safe' range.  Then you can add 3ppm ammonia and test after 24 hours.  And your nitrite should remain on the scale, if you've got any N-bacs.  And just wait 3-4 days before adding any more ammonia, unless the nitrite drops to 0 before then.  And then I'd suggest sticking to the article here... 1 ppm added every 3-4 days until the nitrite does hit zero.
 
TwoTankAmin said:
Even when using media to seed a tank or bottled bacteria for a fishless cycle, if ammonia is dropping, nitrites should be tested. In order to assess where in a cycle things stand, we need to know more information than you have provide. I would need to know how much ammonia you add and when and then all reading taken for ammonia and nitrite. With this info it becomes a lot easier to know exactly where things should be vs where they are and why.
 
Using an API (or similar) test kit, the number you do not want to exceed is 16 ppm of nitrite and I prefer to use 15 ppm as the line to be safe.
 
The fastest way to cycle is not to do any water changes without cause.
 
The danger of too much nitrate, and the cycle itself, is that it can result in dropping pH due to one's having the carbonates in the tank used up. Carbonates are a key component of KH which is what holds pH steady. Use up the KH and the pH falls and when it get into the 6.5 range or below, a cycle will stall.
 
Finally, there is no need to do 9:1 testing. It is overkill and usually more subject to inaccuracies. There is a good step by step set of instructions for how to do diluted testing that is easy and accurate here http://www.fishforums.net/index.php?/topic/433778-rescuing-a-fish-in-cycle-gone-wild-part-il/ These instructions are there for determining how much salt to add to help during a fish in cycle. However, the diluted testing process is the same for any form of diluted testing for nitrogen compounds.
 
One last note, knowing how much ammonia has gone in will let us determine what the maximum possible nitrite should result from that. In the cycling article here the ammonia ammounts and timing of their being added is intentionally designed to make it impossible for one to have too high nitrite even when it hits the top of the test scale we know it should be OK. It is when folks depart from the directions and add too much or too soon that the nitrite can go nuts.
 
In order to know if you need to do a water change I would want to know what your tap pH and KH are and then what they are now in your tank. Assuming your nitrite is actually under 16 ppm and your pH is not dropping rapidly (and HK too), there is no reason to change any water. While the nitrate may be high, if it is not slowing the cycle, there is no need to change the water. If your nitrite is under 16 ppm, then changing water will reduce that which, in turn, will slow your cycle. If your nitrite is 16 or more, no matter what the nitrate level is, you must do about a 1/3 or so water change. The goal is to drop it to about 10 ppm. This leaves a good amount to keep the nitrite bacs reproducing and gives you 5 or so ppms headroom for it to be able to rise again safely.
 
I was adding 7ml of ammonia because that equaled 3ppm on the calculator. I believe i have added it 3 times (so 21ml total), i was told to redose ammonia once it read 0. 
I'm using the freshwater master kit by API
 
The first two times i added ammonia, i wasnt getting back nitrite or nitrate. Then once i got my first reading of 0 ammonia 24 hours after dosing, i got the high nitrate and nitrite reading.
My tap ph is: 7.6
Tank ph: 7.0
eaglesaquarium said:
 
A few weeks back I was getting readings of 1 ammonia, 0 nitrites and nitrates 2 days after full dosing of ammonia.
Now, my ammonia drops from 3ppm to 0 in 24 hours (which is what i thought i should be looking for) but i tested my nitrite and nitrate and found them both to be crazy high. Looks like close to 5 nitrite and 160 nitrate.
What should i do? a large water change or will it resolve itself?
 
I agree with TTA that knowing how much ammonia you have added in totality would help us determine how high the nitrite could possibly be.
 
First, 1 ppm ammonia will turn into 2.7 ppm nitrite.  So, if you've added 10ppm ammonia (added together) then the maximum nitrite level would be 27 ppm.  
 
 
And I'll say this, doing a water change may slightly slow the process of the cycle, but there's no real danger in doing the water change.  There are dangers in just adding more and more ammonia.  If the nitrite or nitrate levels go to high, they can stall the cycle and in extreme levels even kill your bacteria.  
 
So... if I were in your boat, and I was concerned about the nitrite and nitrate levels being really high - I'd just change the water (change as much as you can) and refill.  Then you will know that the nitrite and nitrate levels are in the 'safe' range.  Then you can add 3ppm ammonia and test after 24 hours.  And your nitrite should remain on the scale, if you've got any N-bacs.  And just wait 3-4 days before adding any more ammonia, unless the nitrite drops to 0 before then.  And then I'd suggest sticking to the article here... 1 ppm added every 3-4 days until the nitrite does hit zero.
 
was posting as you were, put my stats in the post to TTA
 

Most reactions

Back
Top