Worst Advice Ever?

miniman

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Jan 14, 2007
Messages
85
Reaction score
0
Ok i just got this email from a good freind of mine after i emailed her the address to this forum when i heard she was setting up a tank. It looks like a disaster to me and the advice from the pet shop is beyond me, its not her fault, people in the shops should be there to help people make the right choices as they are meant to be the experts. :rolleyes:

ok so what do you think the story for the next few weeks will be? I know what I predicted to her, death, death, followed by more death...

Shame I didn’t read your email earlier really, you and I are so different I was FAR too impatient to wait anything like the time you did! Basically we set up the tank Sunday, and put NINE fish in on Thursday! I know that sounds like a lot, but the guy in the shop said bung in around 6 to 9 small ones that you don’t mind losing to get it going so I was happy with that! So far we’ve had two fatalities, one guppy died as soon as he went into the tank, I think the stress got him (and yes I did leave him in the bag for half an hour first!), and one Thai red crab which is inexplicable! he did climb onto the top of the filter then fall in the other day and we had to take the whole thing apart to get him out, so maybe he never really recovered from that!

The others seem very happy, they’re very mobile I sit and stare at them for what must be an hour a day, it looks like they’re loving it!

Now we have two yellow guppies, three tetras, three rainbow zebra danios (which are almost too energetic to be honest), two which I can’t remember the name of but they are medium sized and change colour depending on who is the dominant one of the day- they’re yellow with blue/purple spots and the dominant one develops thick black stripes and has a black Mohican which stands up on end. When they argue they both go like that, they’re so cool- one pitbull plec, two khuli loaches which have evolved into eel shapes, and one remaining thai red crab.

Ours is 85 litres, and by Juwel
 
wow, I hope that was not last Thursday, the 22nd, when she put the first fish in the tank. If so, I'm afraid you are probably right that many of them will die unless she does daily water changes to help keep the amonia lower.
 
Im surprised she hasnt lost more. Some one with more knowledge should go back to the store and complain with her.

She will have to monitor the water dailey and keep tabs with alot of part water changes. Hope it goes aswell as possible as 1st time mishaps like this can upset and put people off trying again.

Good luck, Tell her to stick in there.
 
Ive told her to do daily water changes, it was the comment about putting in fish you dont mind losing which got me! So cruel!
 
Yeh sadly Ive heard alot of places that say that, I think its cruel. People tend to think fish dont feel pain or suffering which annoys me. I hate to see any fish suffer and die.
 
I was told by the LFS to put some guppies in 3 days after I set up my tank and 2 angels. Well they died...

And the LFS told me 2 bala sharks would live perfectly in an 18lt tank (when I was considering getting a small tank).
 
Ive seen this at lots of pet stores... they'll put a sign on the danios, whiteclouds, platty tank that say "great for cycling"
Ticks me off.
 
rhiannon, do u mean u put the gups and angels in after cycling or before?
 
rhiannon, do u mean u put the gups and angels in after cycling or before?

If it was 3 days after setting the tank up then I would guess before ;)


I know Maidenhead say they won't sell to people whose tank is <7 days old or overstocked etc but they've never asked me about any of those things when I've enquired/bought fish...
 
When it wasnt cycled.

We had no clue about fish keeping, all I wanted was a tropical tank so hubby brought me one for my bday.

So we were told they would be fine (after telling them when we had started the tank) and a few days later they were all dead.

Then I found this forum and found out why! And I have learnt so much from here.
 
I think a comp is a great idea. I'd win. My tank was so bad people thought I was a troll when I first got on here.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top