Will All These Fish Mix

trbjones

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Apr 29, 2007
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
Location
birmingham, uk
Hi i been looking at all these fish will they all mix ok

Guppies
gold gournmi
orange salfin molly
spot catfish
cherry shrimp
pictus catfish
chinese algae eater dwarf
turquoise rainbow
 
mollies need brackish water so i dont think they are advised amongst the others there. Not overly sure on the rest though. My guppies and gouramis work fine with each other
 
chinese algae eater no-no, don't think there is a dwarf version but they get very aggressive, gourami could nip the guppy
 
220 litres

So you don't have any fish in it yet? What are the dimensions/length/width/height of the tank as well? Things like the actual dimensions of a tank also play an important role when choosing what fish are most suited to your tank. Are you planning on a heavily, medium or lightly planted tank set up and what sort of substrate are you planning on having too (like gravel, sand etc)?
 
my tank is roughly 48x16x16 in inches, i have planted it light to medium it has a gravel bottom. i am halfway through doing a fishless cycle.
 
my tank is roughly 48x16x16 in inches, i have planted it light to medium it has a gravel bottom. i am halfway through doing a fishless cycle.

Guppies
gold gournmi
orange salfin molly
spot catfish
cherry shrimp
pictus catfish
chinese algae eater dwarf
turquoise rainbow




Guppys are small tropical fish with high sex drives, they are generally very peaceful fish as long as care is taken when stocking them. Due to their high sex drives, they can often over-harrass the females, so its good to have a bare minimum of 2-3females per male.
They can be kept in all-male groups of at least 5 (although the more the better- the more you have, the more any agression between them will be spread out, and the less likely you are to get any particular male too picked on), or all-female groups of at least 3 (as guppys are sociable fish, its good to keep them in at least a trio or more).
They are prolific breeders, a single mature female guppy can give birth to over 30 fry a month- the vast majority (if not all) of this fry will usually be eaten if left to fend for themselves in the tank, but more than often you will always end up with at least a couple of fry making it to adulthood. Female guppys can store sperm in them, so keeping guppys in all-female groups will not nesarsaril rule out the chance of them giving birth to fry.

Mollys have similar requirements to the guppys, they are the same when it comes to gender stocking (i.e. 2-3females minimum per male, or a minimum of 5 males in an all-male group, or minimum of 3females in an all-female group etc) and have similar diet. The problem with mollys is that some varities are rather brackish, and so need salt in their water, while others are a lot more freshwater- for more info see my first post in this thread for more info on using salt with mollys and other fish;

http://www.fishforums.net/Fish-For-My-Tank-t197319.html

Gold gouramis are a colour variation of a particular type of gourami, gourami's like opaline/pearl gouramis and three spot gouramis are exactly the same type of gourami as gold gourami's, just a different colour/pattern variation.
Gourami's personalities vary a great deal, male gourami's like gold gourami's can be quite agressive/territorial and difficult to stock successfully with other fish. Female gouramis are a lot more peaceful on the other hand and much easier to keep in groups or with other fish.
They prefer a medium to heavily planted tank with gentle current, plants which grow all the way from the bottom to the top of the tank, or floating plants, make ideal plants for gourami's.

There isn't any such fish as a "spot catfish", do you mean some type of corydora's like this;

http://www.fishforums.net/Peppered-Corydoras-t35212.html

?

Cherry shrimp should be fine for the tank. Pim pictus are carnivorous though and have been known to eat small fish liek neons, i think that they might also try to eat cherry shrimp too, so might posibly not be a good combo;

http://badmanstropicalfish.com/profiles/profile70.html

When you say dwarf chinese algae eater, do you mean an oto;

http://www.planetcatfish.com/catelog/speci...?species_id=107

?

Sorry i do not know any fish called "turquoise rainbow".

so roughly 50 US gallons

Dimensions 122 x 41 x 41cm/48" x 16" x 16
Surface area 0.5 sqm/5.38 sq ft/ inches sq in
Volume 201 l./44 gal. (53.1 US gal.)
Probable volume 181 l./40 gal. (48 US gal.)
 
they are all on here the fish i like www.tropicalfish4u.co.uk. do u think they will all mix i probbaly wont get all the list i just choose from my top 8 probbal get 5 type of fish and have good numbers of them
 
they are all on here the fish i like www.tropicalfish4u.co.uk. do u think they will all mix i probbaly wont get all the list i just choose from my top 8 probbal get 5 type of fish and have good numbers of them


Can you answer some of my questions though as some of the names of the fish you gave are not real names for fish? The guppys, mollys, cherry shrimp and gouramis (if you get a group of say 5 females) should all go together (taking the above info into consideration of course though), however i personally wouldn't mix the pictus with the guppys and shrimp. Can't say on the other fish though until you give more accurate names on them.
 
I hope this will help

Gyrinocheilos aymonieri = algae eater

http://www.tropicalfish4u.co.uk/acatalog/D...lgae_Eater.html

melanotaenia lacustris = Turquoise Rainbow

http://www.tropicalfish4u.co.uk/acatalog/O...synodontis.html

Synodontis ocellifer = Large-spot Catfish

http://www.tropicalfish4u.co.uk/acatalog/O...synodontis.html


The syno, like the pictus, may eat the smaller fish in your aquarium, cherry shrimp could also posibly be on the menu too;

http://www.planetcatfish.com/catelog/speci...?species_id=551

The melanotaenia lacustris should be fine from what i'd read about them;

http://www.thetropicaltank.co.uk/Fishindx/mel-lacu.htm


However your link to the algae eating fish is just a standard Chinese Algae Eater (CAE), they eat a lot of algae while juveniles, but quickly grow and stop eating algae on a regular basis as they mature. They are known to become very territorial/agressive as they mature and are not safe to be kept with a large variety of fish, CAE's can get nasty habits like sucking the protective slime coat off flat bodied fish like gourami's, sucking the eye balls out of other bottom dwelling fish in the tank, and generally terrorising any fish that gets in their way.
Some CAE's grow to be less agressive than others, but i wouldn't advise them for the large majority of community tank set ups like yours, as most CAE's in my experience do grow up to be very nasty towards other fish. They do not come in a dwarf form, although there are some loaches which look similar to them, CAE's grow to 8-10inches long on average.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top