Which Is Better?

[KingofthePisces]

well ie done most of of my research on these fish and ive finally come to 2 decisions i either:
community 1
cichlid, ram, blue: 2
killifish, gardneri or blue panchax: 3
platy: 3
rasbora, hareliquin: 5
pencilfish, golden: 4
plecostomus, bristlenose: 2
or
community 2
corydoras, peppered: 4
tetra, black widow: 4 or 6
rasbora, two spot: 3
cichlid, kribensis: 2 or 3
barb, rosy or tiger: 4
plecostomus, bristlenose: 2

which one is better? i cant seem to figure it out i dont know a thing about compatabilty in this please help
kingofthepisces

 

[Musho3210]

forgot to mention tank size

 

[KingofthePisces]

oh sorry 30 gallons

 

[Mo_loves_fish]

I like number one.

 

[rdd1952]

I would also go with #1. If you do end up going with #2, don't get the tiger barbs. They are not community fish and will harass everything else in the tank to death.